Does faith need the mind or the heart more?

Both. Heart and mind are like two legs. Sometimes one goes ahead, sometimes the other, and they support each other. A faith resting only on feeling breaks easily when a crisis comes.

Anyone who sets out in search of God often wonders whether they should follow their mind or their heart more. The answer is that one should not be played off against the other.

Heart and mind behave like two legs when walking. Sometimes one goes ahead, sometimes the other, and neither gets far on its own. Sometimes the heart is touched first, and only afterwards does the mind understand what lies behind it. Sometimes the mind is convinced first, and the heart follows and begins to love what the mind has recognised. The two influence each other constantly, often so closely that it is hard to say which came first.

A faith made only of feeling is like a house without foundations. As long as all goes well, it stands. But when a crisis, a loss or a serious doubt comes, it easily collapses. That is why faith also needs a reasoned conviction that can be examined and explained.

On the other hand, a faith that lives only in the head stays cold. It may know that God exists, but it does not live with Him. The verses above show how the Holy Qur’an brings the two together. It speaks of people of understanding who reflect on creation and at the same time remember God, standing, sitting and lying down. And it says that it is the heart that can see or be blind.

So whoever feels a new closeness to God may open their heart to it. But they should take their mind along too. Then a feeling becomes a faith that can carry them.

10 von 10 heute frei