Does one verse of the Holy Qur’an abrogate another?

No. Not a single verse of the Holy Qur’an has been abrogated. Every verse remains valid today, and apparent contradictions disappear once the verses are properly understood.

Some claim that verses of the Holy Qur’an contradict each other, and that a later verse therefore abrogated an earlier one. A common example is the verse telling believers not to come to prayer while intoxicated. It is said to be outdated now that wine is forbidden altogether.

The idea of abrogated verses has a long history. In earlier times scholars considered hundreds of verses abrogated, and they did not even agree on which ones. In this way more and more of the Holy Qur’an was cast under a shadow of doubt. As understanding grew, the number shrank over the centuries until only five verses were left. These too can be explained. Not a single verse has been abrogated, and every word of the Holy Qur’an deserves obedience until the end of time.

Behind this lies a simple thought. The Holy Qur’an says itself that it contains no contradictions, because it comes from God. Whoever assumes contradictions and explains them away through abrogation creates the very contradiction the Holy Qur’an rules out.

The verse about prayer shows how the puzzle is solved. The Arabic word refers to any state in which a person does not clearly know what he is saying. Wine can cause it, but so can illness, extreme exhaustion, or drugs that are not alcohol at all. Someone praying after days without sleep may be thinking of one thing while saying another.

That is why the verse still applies today. The ban on wine does not make it redundant, because the state it describes still exists. The two verses stand side by side and complement each other.

10 von 10 heute frei