The Questions

Three Questions by a Christian and their Answers

Muhammad (sa) was in doubt about his own Prophethood and about the Holy Qur’an being the Word of God, as is evident from this verse of Surah Al-Baqarah and Surah Al-An‘am:

This shows that in his heart of hearts he knew that he was not a Messenger of God. Had he been one, or had he shown any miracles, or had the Mi‘raj been a reality, or had the Holy Qur’an been revealed to him by Gabriel, he would never have been in doubt about his own Prophethood. This proves that he was in doubt about the Holy Qur’an and his own Prophethood. Hence he is not a Prophet of God.

Had Muhammad (sa) really been a Messenger, he would not have responded so helplessly to questions put to him, and would not have said, 'Only God knows'; which implies that he did not know. Nor would he have lied about the number of Ashab-e-Kahaf, nor would he have said that the Sun sets in a murky pool, for the Sun is 90 million times larger than the earth and it can not possibly hide in a pool of murky water.

Muhammad (sa) was never granted any miracles, as is stated in Surah Al-‘Ankabut: 'They say why were not a few signs sent down to him from his Lord.' (That is to say, 'Why was not a single sign sent down to him,' for, the expression 'La' in this verse is a universal negative, and it implies the negation of a class as a whole.) Then, in Surah Bani Isra’il, we read, 'And We did not send signs because people had rejected them before.' Which means that God did not give him any miracles. If he had been given even one miracle, he would not have been in doubt about [his own] Prophethood, nor about the Holy Qur’an.

10 of 10 left today