The Answers
Three Questions by a Christian and their Answers, Part 9
True, the people of Europe are very law-abiding and crimes against society, such as theft, murder, rape, etc., which are prohibited under the laws of the Royal Government for the common good of the country, have been checked; but this is not because of their belief in Atonement, it is only due to their fear of the law and because of social pressures. Without these, the Christians would have crossed all bounds. Nor is this a perfect check, for crimes are committed in Europe just as in any other place. [Author]
even a thousandth part of the sinfulness and debauchery had existed then. Besides, when we study the Gospels, it becomes quite clear that Jesus (as) had never wanted to be apprehended and beaten and to be put on the cross by the Jews. For if this was his desire, then why would he have cried all night and prayed for the calamity to be averted, and why did he keep crying and praying: "Abba, Father, all things are possible unto Thee; take away this cup from me." The fact is that the Messiah was apprehended unawares and against his will, and to his last breath he kept crying and praying, "Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?" That is to say, "My God, my God, why hast Thou forsaken me?" This shows that the Messiah wanted to live and stay in this world for some more time, and his soul was in extreme anguish that his life may be spared. But he had to undertake this journey against his will. We also need to see what the Messiah achieved by dying for his people in the manner suggested by the Christians, and how did this benefit his people? Had he lived, he would have brought about a great transformation among them, and would have removed their weaknesses. But what did his untimely death achieve? It only brought about every kind of mischief, and caused such corruption that led a whole world to ruin. No doubt, brave people do lay down their lives for the good of their people, and put themselves in danger to save them, but not in the absurd and foolish manner that is ascribed to the Messiah.
Anyone who prudently lays down his life, or puts it in danger for the sake of his people always chooses the best and most advantageous of all the available options. Even if it causes suffering to him or costs him his life, it still ensures that his people will be saved from the calamity. But one who commits suicide by hanging himself, or swallowing poison, or jumping into a well, and thinks that his suicide will do some good for his people, can only be a fool. No wise or virtuous person can do such a thing. Such a death is, in fact, completely unlawful, and only a very stupid or ignorant person ever desires it. I say truly that the death of a perfect man, who possesses will and determination, can never be good for his people, it is rather a great tragedy and an occasion to lament—except in special situations whereby it is necessary for a man to court death in order to save many other lives. And if a person, who is a source of great benefit for God’s creatures, decides to commit suicide, he will be guilty of a great sin against God, and will be held more accountable than other such sinners. Perfect men, therefore, are under obligation to pray to God for a long life, so that they are able to do for mankind all the great things that they are motivated to do. The death of a mischievous person, on the other hand, is better for himself as well as for mankind, because with his death the account of his mischief stops swelling, and mankind does not have to suffer his daily torments anymore. If it is asked, which of the Prophets put himself in the greatest danger in order to manifest the Glory of God, and who among them was most willing to sacrifice himself for his people at times of genuine need and through reasonable means—was it Jesus (as) or some other Prophet, or was it our Chief and Master Muhammad (sa)—I regret to say that it is not possible for me, in this short article, to say how passionately I wish to present the luminous arguments, manifest signs, and historical testimonies with which I am eager to answer this question. But, if life permits, I will write a separate book on this subject. Now let me just briefly give the glad-tiding that the Perfect Man, who was ever ready to sacrifice himself for his people and for all mankind, is none other than our Holy Prophet (sa).
I have more or less explained the earthly difference between a true religion and a false one. In other words, I have written some of the points that can be decided through the use of reason and conscience. But there is another distinction disclosed to us by heaven. It is also a very important distinction, and it is so important that it is not possible to distinguish truth from falsehood without it. The distinction is that the true follower of a true religion enjoys a special relationship with God, becomes a reflection of the Prophet he follows, and serves as a mirror for the latter’s spiritual powers and blessings. Just as a grandson is also called son because of the son’s intermediary link, similarly, the person who is nourished under the benign influence of a Prophet and in his submission, is treated with the same favours and blessings that are bestowed on the Prophet himself. Just as signs are granted to a Prophet, so are his true followers given special signs to increase their Divine knowledge. Such people serve as living signs for the truth of the religion in whose support they have appeared. God supports them from heaven, hears most of their prayers, and informs them of their acceptance. They do have their share of calamities, but these are not meant to destroy them; they are only meant to show signs of special Divine power in their support. They receive honour after they have been disgraced, and are given life after they are dead, so that the extraordinary works of God are manifested in them.
A subtle point that needs to be remembered in this context is that prayers are accepted in two ways: As a trial, or as a favour. Even the prayers of sinful, disobedient and unbelieving people are at times accepted in order to try them; but this does not signify true acceptance, it is, in fact, a kind of test or trial. But for a prayer to be accepted as a favour, the person who prays must be among the chosen ones of God, and should manifest all the blessings and signs that accompany such people. For, God never truly accepts the prayers of disobedient people, He only hears the prayers of those who are righteous in His eyes and follow His commandments. Therefore, the distinction between the acceptance of prayer as a trial, and its acceptance as a fa- vour, is that the former does not require a person to be righteous and a friend of God, nor does it necessitate that God, having accepted the prayer, should grant tidings of its acceptance through His specific communication, nor do these prayers relate to such lofty matters that their acceptance should be regarded as wonderful or extraordinary. On the other hand, prayers which are accepted as a favour, possess the following visible signs:
1. The one who prays is God-fearing, righteous and perfect. 2. He is informed of the acceptance of his prayers through Divine word.
3. Most of the prayers that are accepted are of a very high order and relate to difficult and complicated matters, and their acceptance, when it comes, strikes everyone as something beyond the power of man, and a manifestation of extraordinary Divine power which He displays only for His chosen ones.
4. Whereas the acceptance of prayer by way of trial is a rare phenomenon, the acceptance of prayer as a favour is quite a frequent one. At times, a person whose prayers are heard by way of favour, is engrossed by such grave difficulties that no one in his place could have escaped them except by committing suicide. This is exactly what happens: people who worship the world, and have forsaken God, are at times afflicted by such terrible woes and diseases and insoluble problems, that their own lack of faith makes them despair of God, and they end up taking some poison, jumping into a well, or shooting themselves. But, at such critical moments, God helps the favoured ones in a most wonderful and extraordinary manner. Divine grace comes to their rescue in such an amazing way that an intimate friend instinctively testifies that this man enjoys Divine support.
5. The one whose prayer is heard as a favour is the focus of Divine blessings, and God takes care of all his affairs. The light of Divine love, the abandoned loftiness peculiar to the accepted ones, and signs of spiritual ecstasy and bounty are all evident on his face, as Allah says:
[Publishers]
they grieve—those who believed and acted ever righteously—for them are glad-tidings in the present life and also in the Hereafter—there is no changing the words of Allah; that indeed is the supreme triumph.—Yunus, 10:63-65 [Publishers]
the angels descend on them, saying: 'Fear ye not, nor grieve; and rejoice in the Garden that you were promised. 'We are your friends in this life and in the Hereafter. Therein you will have all that your souls will desire, and therein you will have all that you will ask for.—Ha Mim al- Sajdah, 41: 31-32 [Publishers]
the prayer of the supplicant when he prays to Me. So they should hearken to Me and believe in Me, that they may follow the right way.—Al-Baqarah, 2:187 [Publishers]
by Him, are distinguished by the following signs. They have no fear of what they will eat or what they will drink or how they will get rid of certain calamities, because they keep receiving assurances from Him. They grieve not over the past, for they are blessed with patience. The second sign is that they are true believers, which means that they are perfect in their faith; and they are God-fearing, which means that they distance themselves from everything that is against their faith and against true submission. Their third sign is that they keep receiving glad-tidings through Divine converse and true dreams. This is a promise which God has made to them in this life, as well as in the hereafter, and this promise will never be withdrawn. This is the friendship and distinction that they have been blessed with, i.e., the chosen servants of God, who are His friends, certainly receive their share of Divine converse and true dreams, and deserve to be honoured with Divine communication
Let it be known that the status of being loved, accepted and befriended by God—some signs of which I have briefly mentioned—can never be achieved without following the Holy Prophet (sa). If a Christian or an Arya or a Jew wants to display the signs and blessings of acceptance, as against a true follower of the Holy Prophet (sa), let him know that he can
and Divine address. And this indeed is the very outstanding sign of their friendship. (This exactly is the law of God’s sovereignty) that those who turn away from sundry gods and take Him as their Lord, and declare that He alone is their Master, (and look to no other being for sustenance), and remain steadfast at the time of every trial, (no matter how strong the earthquakes, or how severe the storms, or how impenetrable the darkness, they are not the least shaken or unnerved, and remain perfectly steadfast); it is they upon whom angels come down with the message—they receive glad-tidings through revelations and true visions—that God is their Friend, their Protector and their Guardian, both in this world and in the hereafter, and that in the hereafter they will get whatever their hearts desire. In other words, even if they have unpleasant things to endure in this world, it should not worry them, for in the hereafter all their worries will come to an end, and all their desires will be satisfied. One may ask, how can all one’s desires be fulfilled in the hereafter? I say, this is essential for salvation, and this is what salvation stands for. Salvation would have no meaning if one were to continue to be haunted by unfulfilled desires. There can be no salvation which is accompanied by some sort of chastisement. It is, therefore, important that Jannah, or Paradise, or Mukti Khana, or Surg, whatever you may call it, is a place where one receives the greatest fortune, and it must be a place which provides man with unadulterated happiness, he must be free from any visible or hidden sorrow, nor should the torment of failure come back to haunt him there. Yes, it is true that in heaven there will be nothing unworthy and nothing unseemly, but pious hearts will have no desire for such things either. On the contrary, these pure and holy hearts, which have been freed from evil thoughts, will entertain only never do it. A very clear method of putting these things to the test is that a Christian, or anyone else for that matter, should enter a contest with a righteous Muslim who truly follows the Holy Prophet (sa), and should declare: 'Whatever signs appear from heaven for your sake, or whatever secrets of the unseen are revealed to you, or whatever support you are granted by way of acceptance of prayers, or whatever Divine wonders are manifested for your honour and glory, or whatever exceptional rewards are promised to you by way