Title Page
Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship, Part 45
329 === PDF-Seite 364 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part III
emissary was Suhail bin ‘Amar and the Muslim camp was represented by the Holy Prophetsa himself. Verbal conditions were settled and the treaty was about to be signed. Suddenly Suhail’s own son, Abu Jandal, somehow reached the field of Hudaibiya. He was bound in chains, occasionally dropping to the ground as he staggered. It was revealed that having accepted Islam, he was tortured and imprisoned by his own father, the same Suhail who was representing the idolaters. He made a piteous appeal to the Muslims to save him from the clutches of his own father. His father reacted strongly to this and said, 'if you give him shelter, no peace treaty will be signed'. The Holy Prophetsa repeatedly appealed to Suhail to allow his son to take shelter, but he adamantly refused. At this the Holy Prophetsa advised Abu Jandal to return to Mecca because the agreement had already been verbally reached that escapees from the Meccan idolaters could not be given shelter. Apparently this treaty was against the interest of the Muslims, but the way it was worded by the Holy Prophetsa, it turned out to be advantageous to the Muslims. He did not commit himself to send all the Muslim escapees who reached Medina seeking shelter back to Mecca. He only committed himself to send them out of Medina so they could settle anywhere they liked. This part of the contract ultimately developed into a grievous threat to the Meccans’ trade caravans. Those who had accepted Islam from among
330 === PDF-Seite 365 === Covenants with Non-Muslims, Treaties and Contracts
them and had escaped from the Meccans imprisonment, gradually grew into a strong band, settling somewhere near the Meccans’ trade route. They began to make surprise lightening attacks on their caravans and run away with the booty which they used as their livelihood. A cursory glance by an observer cannot fathom the depth of wisdom of the Holy Prophetsa underlying the wording of this decision. After a while the Meccans began to realise how they had been outdone by the Holy Prophet’ssa careful wording of the contract. If the idolators had agreed to let the escapees settle in Medina under the strict control of the Holy Prophetsa, they would never have attacked the Meccans because it was against the treaty. But when settled outside Medina under their own command they could do whatever they liked. The Treaty of Medina
One category of treaties can be that every participant, regardless of his religion, will enjoy equal rights with the other participants. The treaty of Medina belonged to this category. The important clauses relevant to this discussion are as follows: 1. The Quraish Immigrants from Mecca and the Ansar from Medina who gave them shelter and all those who, despite not being Muslims signed
331 === PDF-Seite 366 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part III
the agreement along with them, would be deemed as a single umma. The treaty required that if Medina was attacked by outsiders, while staying in Medina, they will all defend Medina together. The remaining part of the first clause of the treaty has been omitted because it was not directly relevant to the subject being discussed. 2. No Muslim would become the supporter or friend of a liberated slave without the consent of his previous master if that master happens to be a Muslim. 3. All the believers would join hands against another believer if he perpetrates cruelty or talks sinfully or transgresses against others or tries in any way to create division among believers. This will be adhered to by every believer even if he has to rise against his own transgressing father. 4. No believer would murder another believer for the sake of a non-believer, likewise he would not support a non-believer against his fellow believer. 5. The covers of God’s sanctity will include every participant in this treaty. Even the lowest among them would get his share of this sanctity. 6. Even the Jews who enter this treaty would enjoy equal rights with the Muslims. They will
332 === PDF-Seite 367 === Covenants with Non-Muslims, Treaties and Contracts
not be tyrannised, nor will an enemy of theirs be aided against them. 7. The security of every believer is equally important for all of them. 8. If a non-believer murders a believer accidentally he will have to pay blood money unless the inheritors of the deceased forgive him. If he does not pay blood money and has not been forgiven, then all participants of the treaty would enforce him together. 9. If the participants of the treaty quarrel against each other in any matter, their quarrel would be presented before God and His Prophetsa for judgement. 10. The idolaters of Mecca and their allies shall not be granted shelter. 11. If anyone invades Mecca, the participants of the treaty would help each other. If an armistice is offered, all participants of the treaty would participate to decide as one party. 12. The believer must grant the same rights to other participants and pay their dues, unless they oppose them because of religious differences. 13. This treaty would not help the transgressor or the sinful. 14. Every Medinite, whether he be on a journey or remains in Medina, has the same right to security. 15. Whoever acts righteously, God and His
333 === PDF-Seite 368 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part III
Messenger will be on his side.49
It is evident from this treaty that it was not a legislation of a government, the clauses of the treaty are in accord with the social requirements of every society, Hence the spirit of this agreement provides the Jews with equal rights with Muslims. According to this treaty every participant, whether he lives in Medina or leaves Medina to dwell elsewhere, will enjoy the right of living in peace. The participants of the treaty will have no right to interfere in their affairs. This treaty is a moral charter which can settle the differences of all disputing nations in the future, justly and amicably. According to this treaty, the powerful nations can enjoy no exceptional right to force their will upon the weaker nations. However, all signatory nations which are members of the United Nations Charter can use their united might against a belligerent nation which does not abstain from perpetrating aggression against another. During such an eventuality, they should exert a united pressure on both the disputant parties to immediately stop acts of hostility. Then they can settle their issues in accordance with a mutually agreed authority of arbitration. Although the charter of Medina gives the predominant right of arbitration to the Holy Prophetsa during disputes between Muslims and non-Muslims, he never used this clause to impose his religion upon
334 === PDF-Seite 369 === Covenants with Non-Muslims, Treaties and Contracts
the non-believers. He always offered the non-Muslims three choices. If they had a book of their own they had a right to be judged according to their own book, also they had a right to decide that the dispute should be settled according to Islamic law. The third option was that their dispute should be judged according to the prevalent Arab custom. The Personal Example of the Holy Prophetsa regarding his Commitment to Contracts
In relation to commitment to contracts, I now present before you some examples of the Holy Prophet’ssa virtuous conduct. Once an emissary of a people came to the Holy Prophetsa to deliver a message. Having met him, he was so impressed that he accepted Islam. Despite the fact that all his family, cattle and property were evidently left behind, he pleaded with the Holy Prophetsa that he should kindly be permitted to remain at his feet as he could not bear to leave him. The Holy Prophetsa responded by saying, 'I cannot be guilty of breach of contract. You, being an emissary, must return.' An emissary is not permitted to bring a message and stay behind without returning to his master with the answer. What a glorious teaching it is! Had it been someone else in the Prophet’ssa place, however just he might have been, he would be likely to have greeted him with all his heart, saying, 'With pleasure, it is your own choice, you are a free man to 335 === PDF-Seite 370 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part III
decide whatever you like.' However, the Holy Prophetsa would only permit him to return after having delivered his answer. So he went home, and because he was sincere, after some time he came back. This time he was not an emissary but simply an emigrant.50 On another occasion, a Meccan by the name of Huzaifa bin Yamanra came to the Holy Prophetsa during the Battle of Badr. He told him that he came with the intention of joining him in the battle against the Meccans but the Meccans had somehow sensed it. Therefore they had taken a verbal promise from him not to fight against the Meccans. The Holy Prophetsa admonished him to return without participating in the battle to fulfil his promise, adding that his God was sufficient to help them.51 Glory be to Allah, what a paragon of virtue he was. He had every right to remind him that because his contract was made under duress it was not binding upon him. But it was far below the dignity of the Holy Prophetsa to have taken such a stance. Woe to the so- called Muslim mullahs of today, that their conduct is far removed from that of the Holy Prophetsa. The Prophet Muhammadsa did not only commit himself to honour his own pledges, but also honoured the contracts of his Companions, despite the fact that they were not authorised by him to make them on his behalf. Here it remains no longer a matter of justice but aquires the higher stage of Ihsan.
336 === PDF-Seite 371 === Covenants with Non-Muslims, Treaties and Contracts
A similar incident is narrated by Hadrat Umm-e- Hani’, the daughter of Abu Talib. She narrates that once she came to the Holy Prophetsa after his ultimate conquest of Mecca. Finding the Holy Prophetsa engaged in prayer she waited till he finished, then told him that she had given protection to a son of Habira without consulting other Companions, or taking prior permission from the Holy Prophetsa. However, her real brother Ali, born of the same mother, was bent upon killing him because her offer of protection had no validity. The Holy Prophetsa declared 'O Umm-e- Hani, whomever have you given protection, I too have given my protection.'52 In no way was the Holy Prophetsa required to honour Umm-e-Hani’s commitment. No principle of justice could ever impose this on him. Most certainly it was his beneficence that out of regard for a humble member of his family he stood to honour her promise. A Prophecy Regarding the Moral Decadence of Muslim Political Leaders in the Future
The Holy Prophetsa once warned Muslims to honour their commitments to their non-Muslim subjects, if they fail to do so Allah would harden the hearts of the non-Muslim subjects and they will cease to pay the levy.53 The levy is a tax imposed on non-Muslim subjects in exchange for the promise of protection offered to them.
337 === PDF-Seite 372 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part III
If Muslim states had paid proper heed to this admonition, they would not have dwindled away. In this respect, the states of the early period were distinctly different from those of the later. Earlier, when Muslim rulers kept their promises and behaved kindly to their subjects, their subjects also responded by obeying them with respect amounting to love. The difference of religion never stood between their mutual cooperation. A people who protect their contracts, their subjects protect them. In the history of the Muslims, there is one glorious episode which deserves to be told again and again. Once, the Muslim army was forced to beat temporary retreat from the area of Hims under mounting Roman pressure. The retreating Muslims returned the levy they had received from their subjects. They told them that they had failed to protect them and defend their rights, for which the levy was imposed. Now that they were leaving this territory, it had become impossible for them to defend them against the enemy. At this, the reply of the people of Hims is recorded in history in the following golden letters: