Title Page

Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship, Part 9

The balance within species in relation to each other and the balance between the animal and the vegetative domains, are increasingly attracting the scientists’ attention. These kinds of balance comprise many categories. We enumerate some of them as below:

• the balance of living organisms in relation to the habitat where they belong • the balance between the predator and it’s prey • the balance in migration of fish from their breeding grounds in mountain tops to oceans, and their counter migration back to their breeding grounds • The maintenance of balance between rivers and lakes and the interchange of the various life-forms they contain to and from the oceans.

55 === PDF-Seite 84 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part I

Scientists are involved in these and many other similar studies, and each discovery leads them on to another underlying mystery of such balances, layer after layer. In order to describe the principle of justice operative in the entire ecosystem, covering both the inanimate and the animate, and their mutual co- ordination, one cannot conceive of a better expression or description than the word Mauzun. In short, the principle of justice found in the Holy Qur’an is so vast that one finds it operative in every particle of the universe. Much has been said and written on this topic, but the subject is inexhaustible. It would not be appropriate therefore to make an attempt here to discuss this subject in intricate scientific terms. The discussion, however interesting it may be, will remain out of reach of the layman.

56 === PDF-Seite 85 === 4 The Animal Kingdom

As far as the approach of philosophers is concerned, some among them believe that the creation of the universe does not require a Creator. They argue that it is an ongoing automatic, blind, evolutionary process. On this basis they obviously try to understand and tackle human nature with the same blind principle. Such Philosophers propose that there should be no special moral and ethical restrictions on man and that he should be as free to shape his life as animals are. In this scenario we do not find any role for an outside agency like God to legislate for man as a Supreme Lawgiver. In their opinion, the concept of justice is born merely out of the exercise of the human intellect which, in relation to its long chain of human experiences from time immemorial, gradually began to deduce rules and regulations for human society as it developed. So they began to legislate, among other things, in matters relating to justice too. The religious doctrine is in direct clash with this secular social theory. Religion teaches us that the faculty of discretion is granted to man by God with a specific purpose—to decide whether he should allow himself to follow his instinctive desires like animals, or whether he should refrain from following a course of action in certain situations.

57 === PDF-Seite 86 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part I

Conclusively if we believe that this attribute has been granted to mankind by God, it logically follows that the guidance on what he should do or should not do must also come from God, through His revealed guidance. However, this argument needs to be elucidated with the help of some illustrations. For instance, a lion’s natural instinct will tell him to go and kill an animal for the satisfaction of his hunger, but his ability to determine that his animal should be killed in the least painful manner is beyond his creative limitations. It is God who has intuitively taught him ways to kill his prey in a mode that would be least painful, in the sense that the affliction of unnecessary pain is avoided. Over a long period of gradual implementation, the process of Taqwim resulted in a slow but definite and well oriented transformation, whereby animals gradually gained awareness of the pain and suffering of others. Among humans, it began as a first step with the closest kith and kin and gradually it extended to the wider family circles and ultimately into the much larger sphere of all fellow human beings. Then came the turn of feeling for the suffering of lower forms of life as well. This attribute was born out of the same sense of belonging to one another as observed in the entire animal kingdom. At the time of crisis, animals of the same species flock together. This intuitive tendency is perhaps responsible for the group

58 === PDF-Seite 87 === The Animal Kingdom

awareness among dogs and wolves as well, who move in packs in the wilderness as hunting parties. These are but some examples in the evolutionary trend born out of same widening awareness of others’ feelings. Also at times of danger, elephants and wild beasts, zebras and deer etc. react as a group or class against the common enemy. It is here that we see a diffused awareness of belonging to one species or group widening its borders. As man evolved, the same animal tendencies grew stronger and more distinct in him. His sense of feeling and care for others no longer remained confined to his own family or to the human species, but spilled over into the animal kingdom of lower order as well. At this stage, one realises the need for a code of behaviour for mankind whose sensitivity has extended even beyond human borders. Ultimately, this plan of natural education and instructions resulting in material changes in the character-bearing genes of living animals, continued unbroken from one species to another higher species until it reached the stage of man. As nature broadened awareness in the evolving species of their surroundings, it also seems to have etched upon their character-bearing genes some of their behavioural patterns so that we can see specific behavioural patterns in each species as distinct from others. When one reaches the stage of man, one is astounded to discover that there is not just a drift of one or two notches between man and earlier life, but that there is

59 === PDF-Seite 88 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part I

a vast difference. Man has not only become alive to what he sees around him, but has also become aware of some forms of existence which he cannot see, hear or feel directly. He is provided with the faculty of imagining various forms of possible existence and it is this higher stage of evolutionary development which broadens his vision limitlessly, far beyond the confines of the planet earth. This awareness prepares him to fulfil the next higher role that he is destined to play and provides him with the capability of boundless progress. This new faculty builds a bridge between him and the Creator and provides him with a means of communion with God. As far as food for the sustenance of man is concerned, potentially he can be both carnivorous and herbivorous. Animal flesh has been a part of his diet from time immemorial. At the same time, he can also live entirely on vegetative products alone. This in itself illustrates the evolutionary direction of expansion. Apart from that, a very important social and moral question can be raised. One must also take into account a very important distinctive feature of man, viz., that he has been given the option to follow his instinctive desires or to refuse to act according to their dictates. Here, when we re-examine the whole issue of man’s options and the exercise of his options, the need for legislation and code of conduct becomes self evident. Now returning to the same issue, which

60 === PDF-Seite 89 === The Animal Kingdom

relates to the food consumption of man for his survival, we take up the question of the eating of animal flesh once again. If man had free choice, he could hunt any animal to satiate his basic urge for survival and also satisfy his personal tastes and likings. It is not possible to expect each man to achieve the same tenderness and taste as others, and so the spectrum of choices grows very wide. Also, this offers a good opportunity to compare man’s instinctive features to the lower stages of animal life. The food habits in the animal kingdom are specifically programmed and individual variation of taste and value play little role in their overall behaviour. In man, however, the widening of options and choices has greatly enlarged the field of his eating habits. Man has now evolved to a stage where, in spite of his urge for meat eating, he can control and suppress his desire in favour of other options—a completely different trend from other animal behaviour. Here his developed mental faculties and a much wider spectrum of awareness, make it possible for him to reject his inner impulses for the sake of a higher ideal. This ideal becomes so important for him that he is able to sacrifice his natural urges and find satisfaction in an alternative, and despite his strong urge for eating flesh, he can command himself not to submit to that urge. Animals are only controlled by their intuition while humans can make choices. They can behave

61 === PDF-Seite 90 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part I

like carnivorous animals as well as herbivorous ones. Amazingly, human teeth are also adapted to both dietary systems. There is another large difference between animal and human behaviour. In certain situations, humans can act in a more beastly manner than the beasts themselves. Beasts can never become cannibals, they never eat their own species; humans can. Even in this age in certain dark patches in Africa, one can find cannibals. There are certain tribes who capture some members of other tribes living across their political borders, to abduct and kill them for their flesh. They do so with the beating of drums celebrating this great festival. It is hard to imagine lions, wolves and dogs behaving in the same manner towards their fellow lions, wolves and dogs. Beasts are never cannibalists even when stricken with starvation. This apparent reflection on man’s character should be studied in further depth, lest we draw the wrong conclusions. When man abstains from eating the flesh of his fellow human beings it is not merely intuitive; in fact he has both options available to him. There is no law of nature that stands between this malpractice and him. It is merely a higher stage of refinement in matters of values which prevents most men from such acts. To illustrate this point in greater depth it must be stated that on the basis of non-cannibalistic tendencies, the lion may appear to be more civilised

62 === PDF-Seite 91 === The Animal Kingdom

than man, but this is not necessarily conclusive. A lion only acts as he has been taught by nature, he does not deviate from a prescribed pattern. Man, on the other hand, must choose his own path. An award is merited only when there is an option of choice. When there is no option, the question of award does not come up. But where there are options there is also a need for legislating a code of conduct in the areas of rights, obligations, proprieties, improprieties etc. Therefore to make the right choice man stands in need of guidance from God. It is needed because of varying customs, habits, traditions, values and social backgrounds which prevail differently in different parts of the world. This is the philosophy of the Divine teachings which all the major religions of the world share. Hence through a long, meandering course of gradual and steady instruction, man has ultimately reached the stage of humane conduct which distinguishes him from the animal kingdom of the lower order. This instruction comprises the inculcation of values not only belonging to the domain of ‘Adl, but also to the areas of Ihsan and Ita’i Dhil-Qurba. Moreover, light is also thrown on the meaning of Ajrun Ghairu Mamnun which speaks of an endless journey of achievements and rewards, further refining man’s conduct as he progresses. But it all hinges on the right choices on the part of man. If man continues

63 === PDF-Seite 92 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part I

with the right options, he will perpetually tread the path of constant refinement. However, if at any time he begins to abuse his freedom of choice he is bound to slide down the path of retrogression, the lowest stage of which is Asfala Safilin; and it becomes quite unlikely for him to evince concern for his fellow human beings. He could become so callous and selfish in his behaviour as to degrade himself to an order lower than the order of beasts. All the same, man has the exceptional ability to rise to the level of such refinement as is unseen in the rest of the animal kingdom. Man can achieve the highest form of nobility by performing righteous deeds while firmly adhering to the course of justice and fair play and can reach even the highest level of Ita’i Dhil-Qurba when he sacrifices his personal gain or comfort for the sake of others who are not actually his kith and kin. We have demonstrated many exceptions to this. A slightly different exception is found in the case of some depraved humans who kill innocent children just for the sake of consumption of their flesh without any compulsion. Again, child abuse also belongs to the same category. Here the warning of the Holy Qur’an regarding the potential danger that man may return to the lowest rung is demonstrated. Even as a group, man is known to indulge in heinous crimes of torture of his fellow human beings merely because of religious and political differences.

64 === PDF-Seite 93 === The Animal Kingdom

When bigoted, small minded religious clergy or despotic, immoral politicians gain ascendancy they lose all sense of balance and justice. The Spanish Inquisition is such a case in point. Similarly the Muslim history of the Middle Ages is also blemished with such atrocious incidents, where governments took no measures to stop religious zealots from putting people to death merely because of differences of opinion in religious matters. Even a cursory glance at such beastly acts of human deprivation makes one shudder. Alas these chapters are not fully closed and still no one can say that man has now become so refined that now there is no danger of him reverting to his subhuman stage of conduct. The Ahmadiyya Muslim Community has itself been long subjected to religious persecution of a worse nature, making it no longer necessary for scholars to search through the pages of history for such evidence. As against this, we also come across examples of such cultured and decent behaviour on the part of man which brings to mind the teachings in the Holy Qur’an of ‘Adl, Ihsan and Ita’i Dhil-Qurba. Even when on the whole man seems to be sliding down the course of moral degradation, there are such singular examples of excellence that one’s confidence in man’s future is restored. There is an interesting story which can be related here. A story it may be, but whoever wrote it provided

65 === PDF-Seite 94 === Absolute Justice, Kindness and Kinship— Part I

us with an excellent opportunity to understand the relationship between ‘Adl, Ihsan and Ita’i Dhil-Qurba and their respective merit in relation to each other. It is said that once a holy man was sitting in an open field when suddenly an exhausted dove who was being chased by a falcon fell into his lap. He gave protection to the wretched dove but the falcon protested bitterly saying it was against the principle of justice and that it did not behove a holy man to deprive him from the hard earned fruit of his labour. He said, 'This is how nature has provided me the means of my sustenance.' The holy man accepted this argument but his benevolence would not permit him to hand over the helpless dove to the falcon. As the story goes, he decided to cut a portion of his own flesh and offer it to the falcon, saying that he justly deserved a portion of fine meat, but his insistence that he must eat the flesh of that dove had no logic. He said, 'Nowhere has nature specified the dove for you. The meat you need is the meat I offer and that should suffice.' This story is amazingly appropriate in illustrating the subject under discussion. It explains the true meaning of justice and the principles of its implementation in relative terms and in situations where one’s life depends on the death of another. In this scenario, an explanation of the principle of Taqwim and justice would be that each animal has been granted provisions for his livelihood and the

·

10 of 10 left today