Foreword

Ahmadiyyat Is Not a New Religion, Part 5

This is a straightforward point that does not require lengthy debate. According to the Holy Qur’an [5:117- 118], Jesus (as) will clarify that only after his passing did his followers stray. Therefore, if they are corrupt, Jesus (as) is deceased. If they are not corrupt, then one could argue that he is alive; however, in that scenario, it must be acknowledged that Christians, rather than Muslims, are deemed most endearing to God Almighty.

Another perspective from which the death of Jesus (as) is substantiated is to examine if belief in the return of Jesus (as) serves to honour the Holy Prophets (as) or degrades him. It is not just a question of the Holy Prophet’ss (as) honour. We could accept the doctrine of his literal second coming if it honours God Almighty, for we want to establish the glory of God in the world. However, if accepting such a belief not only disgraces the Holy Prophets (as) but also dishonours God Almighty, one can hardly envision a more detrimental belief.

So, let’s consider the question of God’s honour. Based on this doctrine, it is accepted that Allah the Exalted has preserved an individual for nineteen hundred years to keep him from perishing so that the task of reforming humanity does not end—as though God was an impoverished man cautiously saving his provisions. What distinguishes the poor from the wealthy? If there are any [leftovers] from breakfast, a poor person will keep it for supper. If he manages to obtain winter clothing, he stores it away after use for next year in a neatly packed bundle or trunk. If any flatbread is left over, he saves it for another meal. Conversely, a wealthy person wears new clothes for a few days and donates them out of gratitude to Allah and consideration for the poor. After eating a desired portion of a cooked meal, he shares the rest with his workers or has it distributed among the poor. Neither does he save his clothes nor preserve his food, assured he can have freshly prepared food or newly sewn clothes.

Yet, regarding Allah the Exalted—who is All- Powerful and has the divine imperative to provide whatever is needed for religion—Muslims believe that He kept Jesus (as) alive in the heavens for nineteen hundred years, only because He had to make him descend upon the earth and revive faith of the Muslim ummah when it suffers from religious decadence in the latter days. How is this different from a helpless man storing leftovers for the next meal?

Besides, what feats did Jesus (as) achieve during his lifetime that God specifically chose to resend him in the latter days? He preached for a few days and ascended to the heavens when the Jews sought to crucify him. Was he so profoundly successful in his own mission that his return in the latter days was indispensable? Ascending to the heavens means a person has turned their back on the world. So what could a person who spurned the world and failed in his mission do for the Holy Prophet’ss (as) ummah? Can we expect him to succeed? This doctrine is an extreme insult to the majesty of Allah the Exalted and a disgrace to His Omnipotence.

It suggests that God is not All-Powerful and cannot raise another individual within the Muslim ummah when needed.

This belief not only undermines His Divine Power but also questions His Knowledge. It suggests that God assigned the mission of reforming the Muslim ummah to someone who previously faltered in the face of opposition. It is puzzling that He would treat Jesus (as) in such an extraordinary manner, yet never once elevate the Holy Prophets (as) to the heavens, despite the constant dangers he faced throughout his life. During the Battle of Hunain, four thousand trained archers rained arrows upon the Holy Prophets (as). At one point, only twelve companions remained to shield him. They approached and said: ‘O Messenger of Allahs (as), you cannot stay here. The life of Islam depends on your safety. Please retreat to a secure location. Once the intensity of their attacks diminishes, we will rally the Muslim army and counter the enemy.’ Some companions eagerly took hold of his horse’s reins, but the Messenger of Allahs (as) replied: ‘Release the reins, انا

In essence, God would seemingly prefer to let the Holy Prophets (as) die and be buried in the ground rather than allow Jesus (as) to be crucified, intervening instantly by raising him bodily to the heavens. No honourable Muslim could tolerate such a belief. If there was ever a prophet worthy of being preserved, it was the Holy Prophets (as). Despite his willingness to sacrifice his life, God Almighty did not save him. Yet, He promptly rescued Jesus (as), lifting him to the heavens.

One must also consider the trial that Jesus (as) faced. If he was tested by God, he should have endured it patiently. However, instead of accepting it with resignation, he prayed fervently against it. The Bible even recounts that he spent the entire night supplicating and trying to awaken his disciples so they could join him in praying for this cup to be taken away from him. It is as though the one who pleaded to be saved from the cup of death was elevated to the heavens by God, while the one who was prepared to battle the enemy alone met with death. Essentially, the brave warrior on the battlefield was granted retirement with a pension, while the deserter was given an extension. Therefore, accepting this doctrine does not honour

God, His Messengers, or Jesus (as). Though we believe that Jesus (as) was saved from the cross, according to other Muslims, he escaped to the heavens. It is the greatest disrespect to a prophet to believe that he ascended to heaven and idly sat by instead of fulfiling his assigned mission.

Moreover, God designated him as a prophet, yet Muslims believe that when Jesus (as) descends in the latter days, he will no longer hold this title. Instead, he will descend as an ummati [subordinate]. Consequently, they demote an independent prophet of God to a subordinate status, thereby defaming Jesus (as). If it were claimed that Jesus (as) had to be downgraded to an ummati as a punishment for abandoning his mission—though still a disgrace to a prophet—it could be considered a somewhat logical explanation. However, Maulwis offer their perspective without attributing any fault to Jesus (as). Consequently, they insult and blame Jesus through this doctrine.

Furthermore, it does not occur to them that a person who failed to handle a minor disorder among the Israelites cannot possibly emerge in the Muslim ummah and confront Dajjal, the worst disorder in world history. Thus, to regard Jesus (as) as alive in the heavens is an insult to God Almighty, an affront to the Holy Prophets (as), and a slight to Jesus (as).

I often compare this belief with going to a neighbour’s house and asking for a matchstick to relight the extinguished lamp in yours. The analogy might not strike a chord with the affluent who are accustomed to using electric lamps, but it resonates with the impoverished, who are familiar with oil lamps. When the light runs out and no match is available, they go to a neighbour’s house to borrow a matchstick or use their flame directly to relight the lamp. Considering this analogy, let’s examine the implications of this belief. Essentially, it suggests that in a particular era, the flame of Islam will be extinguished and need to be relit. The Messenger of Allahs (as) will search but find no light among the Muslims. However, a lamp will be burning in the house of the Jews. Upon seeing it, the Holy Prophets (as) will proceed to their house and use their lamp to relight the extinguished flame of Islam. Now, does this belief bring honour or disgrace to the

·

10 of 10 left today