Arba’in Number Three
O our Lord, decide You between us & between our people with truth, & You are the Best of those who decide.
Amin!
Public Announcement of Five Hundred Rupees Reward for Hafiz Muhammad Yusuf, Canal Revenue Collector, and similarly addressed in this announcement are all those whose names are included below:
Maulawi Pir Mehr ‘Ali Shah Golarhvi; Maulawi Nazir Husain Dehlvi; Maulawi Muhammad Bashir Bhopalvi; Maulawi Hafiz Muhammad Yusuf Bhopalvi; Maulawi Talattuf Husain Dehlvi; Maulawi Abdul Haq Dehlvi–Author of Tafsir-e-Haqqani; Maulawi Rashid Ahmad Gangohi; Maulawi Muhammad Siddique Deoband, presently teaching at Bichrayon in District
Muradabad; Sheikh Khalil-ur-Rahman Jamali Sarsawah, District Saharanpur; Maulawi ‘Abdul ‘Aziz, Ludhiana; Maulawi Muhammad, Ludhiana; Maulawi Muhammad Hasan, Ludhiana; Maulawi Ahmad Allah Amritsari; Maulawi ‘Abdul-Jabbar Ghaznavi also Amritsari; Maulawi Ghulam Rasul, also known as Rusul Baba; Maulawi ‘Abdullah Tonki, Lahore; Maulawi ‘Abdullah Chakralvi, Lahore; Deputy Fateh ‘Ali Shah–Deputy Collector Canals, Lahori; Munshi Ilahi Bakhsh–Accountant, Lahore; Munshi ‘Abdul Haqq–Accountant, Pensioner; Maulawi Muhammad Hasan Abul-Faiz–resident Bhayni; Maulawi Syed Umar Wa‘iz, Hyderabad; Ulema-e-Nadwatul-Islam care of Maulawi Muhammad ‘Ali–Secretary Nadwatul-Ulema; Maulawi Sultan-ud-Din, Jaipur; Maulawi Masihuz-Zaman, Tutor Nizam, Shahjahanpur; Maulawi ‘Abdul Wahid Khan, Shahjahanpur; Maulawi A‘zaz Husain Khan, Shahjahanpur; Maulawi Riasat ‘Ali Khan, Shahjahanpur; Syed Sufi Jan Shah, Meeruth; Maulawi Ishaq, Patiala; all Ulema of Calcutta, Bombay and Madras; all Sajjadah Nashin [the inheritor of a spiritual endowment] and Masha’ikh [patriarchs] of India; all people of intelligence, justice, righteousness and faith from among the Muslims.
Be it known that in a meeting in Lahore, Hafiz Muhammad Yusuf, Canal Revenue Collector, under the influence of his ignorant and misguided clerics, has stated with full confidence that if anyone falsely claims to be a Prophet, or a Messenger, or an Appointed One from Allah, and thus seeks to misguide people, that such a fraudulent person can survive for twenty-three years or more. What he means to say is that a person surviving for twenty-three years after fabricating a lie against Allah cannot serve as an argument in support of his truthfulness. Those who were present in that meeting were: Mirza Khuda Bakhsh—companion of Nawwab Muhammad ‘Ali Khan; Miyan Mairaj-ud-Din Lahori; Mufti Muhammad Sadiq; Sufi Muhammad ‘Ali, Clerk; Miyan Chittu Lahori; Khalifah Rajab Din the Merchant, Lahori; Sheikh Yaqub ‘Ali, Editor of the newspaper al-Hakam; Hakim Muhammad Husain Qureshi; Hakim Muhammad Husain, the Merchant of the Ointment of ‘Isa; Miyan Charagh Din Clerk and Maulawi Yar Muhammad.
He stated further that he can cite the names of many such people by way of example who made claims to be Prophets or Messengers, or Appointed Ones of Allah, and who continued to tell the people for more than twenty-three years that the word of God Almighty descends upon them, while, in fact, they were great liars. Thus, based merely on his observation, Hafiz Sahib [Muhammad Yusuf ] insisted upon his above-mentioned claim from which it follows that the reasoning given in the Holy Qur’an in the verses that say that the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be on him, is from Allah is incorrect. It is as if God Almighty has totally misrepresented this argument before the Christians, Jews, and idolaters and that the past Muslim religious scholars and commentators of the Holy Qur’an, who presented the same argument to their opponents, did so in mere ignorance.
Even Sharah ‘Aqaid Nasfi—a book that contains the Ahl-e- Sunnat beliefs—presents this argument in the form of a belief. And the ulema agree that to belittle the Holy Qur’an or any one of its arguments is blasphemy. It is not clear, however, what preconceived notion prompted Hafiz Sahib, despite claiming to have memorized the entire Holy Qur’an, to forget the following verses of the Holy Qur’an. And these are:
See Surah al-Haqqah, Part Number 29, and the translation of this is that: ‘This Qur’an is the word of the Messenger’—that is to say, it has reached to him through wahi [revelation]—‘and it is not the word of a poet; but because you possess little discerning faith, you do not recognize him! And is it not the word of a soothsayer’—that is, it is not the word of one who is connected somewhat with the Jinnat [hidden beings, great or small]—‘but you think so since you are given very little to thinking and reflecting. You fail to consider how abject and disgraceful the condition of soothsayers is. On the contrary, it is the Word of the Rabbul-‘Alamin [Lord of all the worlds], Who is the Lord of both the physical world as well as the world of souls’—that is to say, He desires to nurture your souls in the same way that He nurtures your bodies—‘and it is indeed due to the requirements of this Rububiyyat [Providence] that He has sent this Messenger. And if this Messenger had fabricated something from himself and said that such a thing has been revealed to me by God, while that word would have been his own and not of God, then We would have seized his right hand, and then severed his main artery, and no one from among you could have saved him.’ This means that if he had fabricated a lie about Us, its punishment would have been death because, in such a case, by his false claim and fabrication and inviting to kufr [disbelief ], he wanted to bring about destruction by causing death through misguidance, so his dying was better than the occurrence of spiritual death of the whole world through his fabricated teachings. For this reason it has indeed always been Our practice that We destroy that very person who presents to the world the paths of destruction and desires to bring about the spiritual death of God’s creation by presenting false teachings and false beliefs and commits insolence by fabricating lies against God.
Now, it is perfectly clear from these verses that Allah the Exalted presents this argument in favour of the truth of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that if he were not from Us, then We would have destroyed him and he could certainly not have remained alive even if you people had tried to save him. However, Hafiz Sahib does not accept this argument. He says that the sum total duration of wahi [revelation] for the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be on him, was twenty-three years, and I can show people who lived longer than this duration, who made false claims to prophethood, and messengership, and who—despite uttering lies and committing slander against God—remained alive for longer than twenty-three years. Thus, for Hafiz Sahib this reasoning of the Holy Qur’an is false and meaningless, and through it the truth of the Prophethood of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be on him, cannot be proven.
Nevertheless, it is strange that the late Maulawi Rahmatullah and the late Maulawi Syed Al-e-Hasan had presented this very argument to the Reverend Pfander in their books Izala-e-Auham and Istifsar, and Reverend Pfander could not think of any rebuttal to it. Despite the fact that these people have great proficiency in the study of history, they could not cite any example ٭ to break this argument, and thus remained unable to respond. Yet today Hafiz Muhammad Yusuf—being a son of Muslims—is rejecting this argument of the Holy Qur’an. And this matter is not merely verbal anymore, we have a written document with Hafiz Sahib’s signature on it which he gave to my dear brother Mufti Muhammad Sadiq with the promise that he would present evidence of [the existence of ] such liars who had claimed to be appointed by God, or claimed to be Prophets or Messengers of God, and lived for more than twenty-three years after making such a claim. It should be known this gentleman belongs to the group of Maulawi Abdullah Ghaznavi and is well known as a believer in the Oneness of God, whereas the state of their beliefs is as written here by way of example. It is not hidden from anyone that to deny arguments presented by the Holy Qur’an is to deny the Holy Qur’an, and if one argument of the Holy Qur’an is rejected, then the promise of safety and security [of the Holy Qur’an] would be lifted and it would follow necessarily that the sum totality of all arguments in the Holy Qur’an affirming the Tauhid [Oneness] of Allah and prophethood must be erroneous and frivolous.
Today Hafiz Sahib has taken it upon himself to prove, in support of this denial, that there are people who made false claims to be Prophets or Messengers of God for twenty-three years or more and then remained alive. Perhaps tomorrow Hafiz Sahib may state that this argument of the Holy Qur’an:
is also wrong, and claim that I can show that there are some other gods besides Allah who are true, but that the heavens and the earth still continue to exist. Thus, we may expect anything from such a brash Hafiz Sahib.
However, the body of a person of faith begins to tremble when someone says that something mentioned in the Holy Qur’an is contrary to the facts, or that such and such an argument which is in the Holy Qur’an is false. On the contrary, it is not the job of a person of faith to adopt that filthy approach concerning any matter by which an attack results upon the Holy Qur’an and the Holy Prophet, peace and blessing of Allah be upon him. The only reason for the plight of Hafiz Sahib to have reached such a degree [of severity]