The Holy War Waged by Reverend Dr Clark and Its Response: An Announcement

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam

The Holy War Waged
by Reverend Dr Clark and in Response
AN ANNOUNCEMENT

بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَنِ الرَّحِيمِ
نَحْمَدُهُ وَنُصَلِّي عَلَى رَسُولِهِ الْكَرِيمِ
Let it be clear that, through some of his letters, the
aforementioned Doctor has expressed his desire and
readiness to hold a Holy War with the Muslim scholars.
He has also articulated in a letter that this contest
would be held with the objective of reaching a final
verdict. Moreover, he has also threatened that if the
Muslim clerics shy away from this contest or suffer
a crushing defeat, they would forfeit their right to
confront the scholars of Christianity in the future, or
to consider their own religion to be true, or to challenge
the Christian people. Since I have been commissioned
for such religious contests and, on account of divine
revelation, know for certain that I shall be victorious
in every field; therefore, Dr Clark has been forthwith
informed through a letter that it is my earnest desire to
take part in this contest so that the distinction between
truth and falsehood may be clearly manifested. Not
4
5
In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. [Publisher]
We praise Him and invoke blessings on His Noble Messengersa.
[Publisher]

Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
only this, but I have also sent some respected friends
to Dr Clark in Amritsar as representatives in order to
formally accept this challenge. Their names are:
1. Mirza Khuda Bakhsh
2. Munshi Abdul-Haqq
3. Hafız Muhammad Yusuf
4. Sheikh Rahmatullah
5. Maulvi Abdul-Karim
6. Munshi Ghulam Qadir Fasih
7. Miyan Muhammad Yusuf Khan
8. Sheikh Nur Ahmad
9. Miyan Muhammad Akbar
10. Hakeem Muhammad Ashraf
11. Hakeem Ni'matullah
12. Maulvi Ghulam Ahmad, the Engineer
13. Miyan Muhammad Bakhsh
14. Khalifah Nur-ud-Din
15. Miyan Muhammad Isma'il
After some discussion, Dr Clark and my friends who
represented me, agreed unanimously that the debate
ought to be held in Amritsar. Mr Abdullah Atham,
the former Extra Assistant, was proposed to be the
champion on behalf of Dr Clark, and it was also
proposed by them that both parties would be permitted
8

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
to have three assistants. Each party would be given six
days to raise objections against the other. In the first
six days, we would have the right to raise objections
against the religion, teaching and creed of the opposing
party. For example, to demand proof of the divinity
of the Messiah, peace be upon him, or proof of him
being the saviour, or present other objections against
Christianity that are likely to arise. Similarly, our
opponents would also have the right to raise objections
against the teachings of Islam for six days. In order
to conduct the debate efficiently, it was also decided
that a president from each side be appointed to stop
the other party from raising an uproar, engaging in
prohibited activity, or causing unwarranted disruption.
It was also mutually agreed and settled that each party
would be accompanied by no more than fifty people;
after printing one hundred tickets, both parties would
issue fifty tickets each to their own supporters and no
one would be allowed to enter without an issued ticket.
In the end, in accordance with the special request of
Dr Clark, it was proposed that the debate would
commence on 22 May 1893; Dr Clark would be
responsible for selecting the venue and making other
arrangements for the debate.
9

Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
Having settled all of these issues, Dr Clark and our
brother Maulvi Abdul-Karim signed the document,
which outlined the conditions of the debate in detail. It
was decided that, by 15 May 1893, both parties would
publish the conditions of this debate. After this, my
friends returned to Qadian.
Since Dr Clark himself has named this debate The Holy
War, I wrote to him on 25 April 1893 that I too accept
the conditions of the debate, which were accepted by
my friends, but it should first be determined how this
'Holy War' would affect the two parties. How would it
be clearly understood that a certain party had actually
been defeated? As years of experience have proven that
no matter how clearly one party prevails over the other
in terms of rational and scriptural arguments, the
latter does not concede its defeat. Rather, they try their
utmost to prove their victory by adding explanatory
notes to their written documents when the debates are
published. Now if this debate is limited to scriptural
disputes alone, then an intelligent person can foretell
that this debate would not be any different from the
previous ones held between the Christian priests
and the scholars of Islam. On closer examination the
present debate seems to contain nothing new. The
Christian clergy will have the same usual objections:
10

10 of 10 left today