The Prayer Duel in The Holy War

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
which a twelve-day stay at Amritsar is a must, will yield
any positive result.
In view of these reasons, it was proposed to Dr Clark
by registered post that it would be appropriate for
both parties to engage in a prayer-duel after each one
has completed their six days. For this purpose it would
suffice for each party to solicit a heavenly sign from God
Almighty in support of their religion and a one-year
time frame should be stipulated for the manifestation
of these signs. Then, if a heavenly sign, which is
beyond human powers and the like of which cannot be
produced by the opposing party, appears in favour of
either one of the parties, it shall be mandatory for the
defeated group to embrace the faith of the other whom
God Almighty has given ascendancy with His heavenly
sign. If they refuse to accept the other's faith, then
they ought to give away half of their property to the
victorious party in order to support the true religion.
Thus will the distinction between truth and falsehood
become abundantly manifest. For when one party has
utterly failed to demonstrate a sign in response to an
extraordinary sign, then the victory of the one that has
shown a sign will become abundantly clear and there
would be no need for further debate and the truth shall
become apparent. However, as of today, 3 May 1893,
13

Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
more than a week has passed and Dr Clark has given no
reply to this letter whatsoever.
Therefore, through this announcement, I respectfully
advise Dr Clark and his party, who have named this
debate The Holy War and who seek a conclusive verdict
between the Muslims and Christians, so that it may come
to light as to whose God is True and Powerful, that it is
a vain desire to expect this from such minor debates. If
this desire is sincere, then there is no better way than to
test truth and falsehood by means of heavenly support;
I agree to this method with heart and soul.
Though I do not consider it necessary in the least, I still
do accept this manner of debate that is to be held with
scriptural and rational arguments. However, it would
also be mandatory that after each party has completed its
six days, the opposing parties should engage in a prayer-
duel as mentioned above. Both parties must publish in
advance their announcement that they shall engage in a
prayer-duel. That is to say they should pray: ‘Our Lord!
If we pursue falsehood, then disgrace us by showing a
sign in favour of the opposing party and if we follow
the truth, then humiliate our opponents by showing a
heavenly sign in our favour.' Both of the parties should
say ameen )آمین( at the end of this prayer. A one-year
14

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
time limit will be set for this and the defeated party
shall be subject to the aforementioned penalty.
If the question arises as to how the matter will be
decided if a sign appears in favour of both parties or
in favour of neither during the year, the answer is that
in both scenarios I shall consider myself defeated and
liable to the aforementioned penalty, as I have been
commissioned by God Almighty and have received
the glad tidings of victory. Thus, if any Christian, for
his part, demonstrates any heavenly sign against me, or
conversely if I am unable to show one within a year, I
shall be proven false. I swear by Allah, the Glorious, that
He has clearly conveyed to me through revelation that
the Messiah, peace be upon him, was without doubt a
human being like others, and that he was a true prophet
and messenger of God Almighty, and divinely elected. I
have also been informed that by following the Prophet
[Muhammad], peace be upon him, I have been blessed
with all of the bounties that were given to the Messiah,
and that I am the Promised Messiah; I have been given
the weapon of divine light that shall dispel all darkness,
fulfilling the prophecy that the Messiah will come and
break the cross. So when this is the case, it is necessary
that a sign be manifested in my support within one year
of the prayer-duel, as proof of my truthfulness. If no
15

Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
such sign appears, then I am not from God Almighty
and I not only deserve the proposed punishment,
rather I am worthy of death. Thus, I accept all of the
aforementioned and make this announcement today.
After the publication of this announcement, it is proper
and incumbent upon Dr Clark that he too ought to
announce that if after the prayer-duel a sign appears in
support of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad within a year and
no sign appears in his own support within this period,
he would accept Islam without delay, or give away
half of his property to the victorious party in order to
support Islam, and that he would never again stand in
opposition to Islam.
Dr Clark should realise that I have imposed harsher
conditions upon myself than I have proposed for
him. For instance, if both of us can show a sign, then
according to the above conditions, even then he would
be considered truthful; if neither of us can show a
sign within a year, even then he would be considered
truthful. I will only prove to be true if I am able to
manifest a sign within a year and Dr Clark is unable to
match. If, after the publication of this announcement,
he fails to publish his announcement in parallel, he
clearly will be deemed to have evaded the challenge.
16

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
I will in any case remain ready to engage in a debate
with him based on reason and scriptures, provided he
publicly acknowledges that he and his people are unable
to manifest any sign in contest with Islam, and concedes
in writing that heavenly signs are the hallmark of Islam
alone and that Christianity is devoid of such blessings.
I have heard that Dr Clark also said in the presence of
my friends that he would surely engage in this debate
but only with the Ahmadiyya sect and not with the
Muslims of Jandiala. Let it be clear to Dr Clark that it is
members of the Ahmadiyya sect who are true Muslims.
They do not confuse human opinion with the Word of
God Almighty and they accord the Messiah only with
that status which is consistent with the Holy Qur’an.
6
وَالسَّلَامُ عَلَى مَنِ اتَّبَعَ الْهُدَى
And peace be on those who follow the guidance. [Publisher]
17

10 of 10 left today