A Response to the Letter of Mr. Abdullah Atham

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam

A Response to the Letter of
MR ABDULLAH ATHAM

Just as I had completed writing this announcement
today, I received a letter by post from Mr Abdullah
Atham. His letter was in reply to the letter I wrote to
him and Dr Clark regarding the aforementioned debate.
Below, I present a reply in the form of his objections and
my answers.
OBJECTION:
We do not believe in the notion that old teachings
require new miracles. Therefore, we neither see any need
for miracles nor do we find any capacity in ourselves to
show a miracle.
ANSWER:
Dear Sir, I did not use the word miracle in my letter.
Indeed, showing a miracle is the work of no ordinary
person, but of a prophet and messenger of Allah.
However, as you believe and know, a tree is recognised
by its fruit, and the fruits of faithfulness that the Holy
Qur’an refers to are mentioned in the Holy Gospel as
well. I hope you will have understood, and so to prolong
this discourse is unnecessary. I only wish to inquire: do
you not possess the ability to demonstrate these fruits of
faithfulness at all?

Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
OBJECTION:
In any case, if you are willing to show a miracle we will
not close our eyes to it and will consider it our duty to
rectify our mistake as much as possible in light of your
miracle.
ANSWER:
Undoubtedly what you have said is based on justice,
for no one can categorically make such a statement
unless they have regard for justice. However, here your
statement, and [we] will consider it our duty to rectify our
mistake as much as possible in light of your miracle, needs
some explanation. I have been sent only to convey the
message to Allah's creation that from among all of the
world's existing religions, the only religion that is true
and acceptable in the sight of God Almighty is the one
brought by the Holy Qur’an, and the door to enter the
and no لَا إِلهَ إِلَّا اللهُ مُحَمَّدٌ رَّسُولُ اللهِ abode of salvation is
other.
Are you prepared and willing to embrace this religion af-
ter witnessing such a sign? Your aforementioned phrase
gives me hope that you will not refuse. If you are pre-
pared for this, then the following statement ought to
7
There is none worthy of worship except Allah, Muhammad is
the Messenger of Allah. [Publisher]
26

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
be published in three newspapers, namely Nur Afshan,
Manshur-e-Muhammadi, and any Aryah newspaper, to
the effect that you promise-upholding the belief that
God Almighty is Omnipresent and Omniscient—that:
'If after this debate, which is to be held on 22 May 1893,
God Almighty helps Mirza Ghulam Ahmad by manifest-
ing a sign in his support, of which he informs in advance,
with the sign being fulfilled exactly as he informed, then
upon witnessing such a sign, we vow that we will become
Muslims without delay. We also promise to accept this
sign without making any frivolous criticism. Moreover,
such a sign will not be considered unconvincing and
objectionable under any circumstance, except that a
similar sign is also manifested by us within one year. For
example, if in the form of a sign there was a prophecy
that at a particular time a specific calamity would befall a
certain person or group and if within the stipulated time
it is fulfilled, then in all circumstances we would have to
accept it unless we can produce the like of it. If after wit-
nessing such a sign we neither embrace Islam nor are able
to manifest a similar extraordinary sign within the same
year, then we will give away half of our property in sup-
port of Islam as a penalty for breaking our promise. If we
fail to act upon the second clause as well and break our
pledge, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad will be free to publish,
27

Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
after this breach, any sign of divine wrath against us, ei-
ther in newspapers or in his journals.
You need only to have this announcement published in
three newspapers along with your name, father's name,
religion, address, and attested by fifty respectable and
credible witnesses from each party.
Since your purpose is to reveal the truth, and as this
criterion is in accordance with both of our religions, so
in God's name, do not hesitate to accept. In any case,
the time has now come for God Almighty to manifest
the light and blessings of the true religion and bring the
entire world under one faith. Therefore, if you muster
the courage to take this path before others, and also to
live up to your pledge with sincerity and determination,
you will be considered truthful before God Almighty.
This will be an everlasting sign of your piety.
However, you may ask: ‘We will do all of the above
and accept Islam if we see a sign, fulfil the other
aforementioned conditions and have this pledge
published in advance in three newspapers; however,
what will be your penalty if you turn out to be false,
and fail to show a sign?' The answer is that I will accept
the punishment of death according to the teaching of
28

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
the Torah. If it contravenes the law of the land, I will
hand over all of my property to you. In this regard, I
am prepared to give you any assurances that you may
require in advance.
OBJECTION:
I call upon your good self to remember that in our
estimation a miracle is something that appears only
after a challenge has been made by the claimant, and
must testify to something that lies within the realm of
possibility.
ANSWER:
I agree with this statement-indeed, this is what a
challenge is. For instance, if a person claims to be from
Allah and makes a prophecy in support of his claim
as is beyond human ability, and the prophecy comes
true, such a person would be considered truthful in
accordance with the Torah, Deuteronomy 18:18. It
is true, however, that such a sign should testify to
something within the realm of possibility. For example,
if someone claims to be God and makes a prophecy
in support of his claim to divinity, it would not be
permissible to consider him God even if his prophecy
were to be fulfilled.
29

Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
Here, I would like to ask you that when I claimed to
be the recipient of divine revelation and to have been
commissioned by Allah, Mirza Imam-ud-Din, with
whom you are well acquainted, demanded a sign from
me in an announcement published against me in
Chashma-e-Nur, Amritsar, in 1888. At that time, in order
to show him a sign, a prophecy was given which was
published in Nur Afshan on 10 May 1888; the detailed
account is also found within the same newspaper and
also in my book Aʼina-e-Kamalat-e-Islam, on pages 279-
280. This prophecy was fulfilled on 30 September 1892,
within the given time.
Thus, I ask you, as a test of your sense of justice, whether
or not this is a sign? If in your opinion it is not, then
why? If it is a sign, and you have also witnessed its fulfil-
ment, and it has not only been published in Nur Afshan
on 10 May 1888, but also in my announcement issued
on 10 July 1888, long before it came to pass, then please
do tell whether it is obligatory upon you or not to ben-
efit from this sign and correct your error? Please do also
inform me as to how you have changed your ways and to
what extent you have forsaken the Christian doctrine?
For this sign is not something of the past; in fact, it is
very recent. It was published in Nur Afshan and in my
announcement of 10 July 1888.
30

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
Moreover, it is in conformity with all of your conditions.
In my opinion, this is a criterion to judge your sense of
justice. If you accept this sign and rectify your error, as
you claimed that you would, then I firmly believe that
in the future also, you will be prepared for a significant
transformation. This sign should move you to at least
publish the admission on your part, that the faith of
Islam, in all probability though not certainly, seems true
to me; for the prophecy which had been made in support
of its truth was fulfilled.
You are aware that Imam-ud-Din, who rejected Islam
and is an atheist, demanded through an announce-
ment a sign proving the truthfulness of Islam and of my
being the recipient of divine revelation. Thus, God
Almighty had shown a sign in his close relations as
irrefutable evidence against him. You must respond as
to whether you accept or reject this sign. Otherwise,
this shall be the first instance in which you will be in
my debt.
OBJECTION:
Prayer-duels are also counted among miracles, but
according to the teachings of the Gospel, we cannot
curse anyone. You are free to beseech whatever you like
and then wait a year for an answer.
31

Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
ANSWER:
My Respected Sir, in a prayer-duel, there is no need to
curse anyone else. Rather, it suffices for a Christian to say,
for example, that he firmly proclaims that the Messiah is
in fact God, that the Holy Qur’an is not from God Almighty,
and that if he is false in this assertion, God Almighty
may curse him. This kind of a prayer-duel is not against
the teaching of the Gospel; rather, if you read the
Gospel carefully you will find that it accords with it
completely.
Besides, as I have stated earlier, I am prepared to manifest
a sign regardless of your incapability. I wholeheartedly
agree with this, and you for your part should publish
your declaration in keeping with the aforementioned
conditions. Whenever you ask I will come to Amritsar
immediately.
I already know that the Christian faith has been plunged
into darkness since the day Christians gave the Messiah,
peace be upon him, the place of God Almighty while
rejecting Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah
be upon him, the Chosen One, the truthful, perfect,
holy, and the most exalted of all prophets. Therefore,
I am most certain that no Christian has the power to
compete with the living divine light of Islam. I find
32

A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
that the 'salvation' and 'everlasting life, which the
Christians always advocate, is as clearly evident among
the elect of Islam as the shining sun. Islam has an
extraordinarily distinct quality of drawing people out
of darkness and into its light. Through the blessing of
this light, believers manifest signs of God Almighty's
acceptance and are blessed with divine discourse.
Further, God Almighty manifests in their persons the
signs of His love. Thus, I declare and claim emphatically
that only a true Muslim can live a life of faith.
This very distinction is the sign of the truth of Islam.
Now that your letter has been precisely answered, I am
sending this announcement in the form of a booklet
to you and to Dr Clark through registered post. I have
fully conveyed and completed my argument, it is for you
to accept it or not.
8
وَالسَّلَامُ عَلَى مَنِ اتَّبَعَ الْهُدَى
Writer, humbly,
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad,
Qadian, District Gurdaspur
And peace be on those who follow the guidance. [Publisher]
33

10 of 10 left today