A Copy of the Letter Sent to the Christians of Jandiala Through Registered Post on 13 May 1893
A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
A Copy of the Letter Sent by
MIRZA GHULAM AHMAD
to
THE CHRISTIANS OF JANDIALA
through registered post on 13 May 1893
بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَنِ الرَّحِيمِ 13
TO:
The
Christians of Jandiala
With due regards. Today, I have read from beginning to
end the correspondence you sent to Miyan Muhammad
Bakhsh. I agree with what you propose in this regard.
In fact, I was so delighted upon reading the contents of
this letter that I am unable to truly express the degree
of my happiness in this brief letter. Without a doubt
it is true that the current daily disputes do not bode
well, as they increasingly stir up mutual enmity that
leads to disturbance of peace and security on both
ends. However, this is a minor issue and what is more
important and noteworthy is that, as both parties are to
ultimately die and depart from this world, they will not
only be wronging themselves but others as well if they
do not bring out the truth through an organised debate.
I have come to realise that more so than the Muslims of
Jandiala, it is my prerogative to take on such a task, as
God, the Noble and Merciful, has sent me for precisely
such purposes and it will be a grave sin on my part if I
13
In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. [Publisher]
Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
keep quiet on this occasion. I, therefore, inform you that
I myself am ready for this task.
It is obvious that both parties claim that their religions are
blessed with many supporting signs from God Almighty.
Both parties also agree that a living religion cannot be
one that is founded upon arguments that constitute mere
tales of the past, rather, its validity must be supported by
arguments that are prevalent and prominent even now.
For instance, if some book mentions that a particular
prophet healed such and such ailing persons by way of
miracle, then such phenomena, or other similar incidents,
cannot constitute a conclusive and certain proof for
the people of this age. Rather, these are mere narrations
which, in the eyes of a sceptic, can be either true or false.
In fact, a sceptic will consider them to be nothing but
tales. This is why European philosophers cannot derive
any benefit from the miracles of the Messiah recorded
in the Gospel; rather, upon hearing them they burst into
laughter. Such being the case, this is a rather easy debate.
That is to say, an individual among the Muslims should
embody the teachings and hallmarks of a true Muslim as
are stated in the Holy Qur’an, and if he fails to do so, he is
a liar, not a Muslim. Likewise, a person from among the
Christians should prove himself to manifest within his
being the teachings and signs of the Holy Gospel, and if
50
A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
he fails, he is a liar, not a Christian. Both parties claim that
the light which their Prophets brought was not only self-
illuminating, but also illuminated others. In such a case,
only that faith which proves to illuminate others will be
judged by reason as living and true.
For if we fail to attain the spiritual life and enlighten-
ment-along with all its accompanying signs-that
are attributed to a particular religion, then such a
faith is nothing but a vain boast. Let us suppose that
there indeed was a prophet who was holy himself, but
was unable to purify a single one of us; he manifested
miracles himself, but was unable to empower anyone
else to do the same; he was a recipient of revelation, but
was unable to endow this quality on any of us; of what
benefit would such a prophet be to us? However, all
praise and benevolence belongs to Allah, our Master and
Messenger, the Seal of the Prophets, Muhammad, the
Chosen One, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him,
was not like this. According to individual capacities,
he blessed an entire world with the light he was graced
with and was recognised by his luminous signs. He was
sent as the everlasting light and no such eternal light
came before him. Had he not come and testified to the
Messiah's prophethood, we would have no proof of it,
as the religion of the Messiah had perished and his light
51
Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
had faded, with no heir remaining who had been granted
this light.
Islam is the only living religion in the world today. My
humble self has witnessed and found through personal
experiences that both forms of light are still freshly
present in Islam and the Holy Qur’an, as they were in the time
of our Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon
him. I take it upon myself to manifest them; if anyone
has the ability to compete with me in this challenge, let
him correspond with me.
وَالسَّلَامُ عَلَى مَنِ اتَّبَعَ الْهُدَى
In conclusion, let it be clear that anyone who seeks to
compete with my humble self should be a renowned
scholar from among the revered British clergy. For the
very purpose of this contest and debate is to make an
impact on the general public, and that depends on the
fact that the representatives of both parties be prominent
figures among their respective communities.
For the attainment of conclusive evidence and an
irrefutable argument, I am even ready to agree that, Rev.
Imad-ud-Din, Rev. Thakurdas, or Mr Abdullah Atham
be selected on behalf of the Christians, and then their
14
And peace be on those who follow the guidance. [Publisher]
52
A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
names should be published in a newspaper, with a copy
sent to me. I will thereafter publish an announcement
accepting this challenge and will send a copy to the
nominee. However, let it be clear that Muslims and
Christians have long been disputing and debating with
each other and many books have been written from
both sides. Indeed the scholars of Islam have made it
crystal clear that the objections levelled against the Holy
Qur’an, in one form or another, also apply to the Torah.
Similarly, the criticism directed against our Prophet,
peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is actually a
criticism against all of the prophets, with the Messiah
being no exception. In fact, due to such criticisms, God
Almighty Himself comes under accusation.
Thus, this debate will be held in order to determine
which religion is living and which is lifeless; to examine
whether or not the spiritual signs claimed by the
religion and their scripture are still to be found. It seems
appropriate that Lahore or Amritsar be the venue of
this debate, which ought to be held in the presence of
scholars from both parties.
Humbly,
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad,
Qadian, District Gurdaspur
53