Amritsar Medical Mission: 18 April 1893
A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
AMRITSAR MEDICAL MISSION
18 April 1893
TO: Respected Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian
I hope you are well. Greetings. I received your letter and
was very pleased to read it, particularly as the Muslims
of Jandiala have found a most worthy and excellent
person like you, but since our challenge is addressed to
the Muhammadans of Jandiala, not to you, we therefore
cannot accept your invitation. We have already sent a
letter to them and are still awaiting their reply.
If you are willing to help them, then the most appro-
priate and formal way of doing so is to write to them
directly and inform them of your gracious intent. If they
accept you as their representative for this Holy War, we
will have no objection; rather, we will happily welcome
it. As an enlightened and well-experienced person, you
know well that it is not our prerogative but that of the
Muslims of Jandiala to accept you for this special debate.
Thus, you should first reach an agreement with them, to
which we too will readily agree. We are eagerly waiting
for you and them to make a decision. Best Regards.
55
بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَنِ الرَّحِيمِ 15
My dear and kind Reverend,
With due regards. How blessed is this hour that I am
prepared to take part in the Holy War referred to in your
letter. I am sending a few of my dear friends as repre-
sentatives and hope that you will agree to accept me as a
contender for this holy contest.
When I received your first letter addressed to some
Muslims of Jandiala and read the sentence, 'Is there
anyone who dares to challenge us?' at that moment, my
soul spoke out, 'Yes, it is I, at whose hands God Almighty
will grant victory to the Muslims and manifest the
truth. The truth I have been granted and the sun that has
risen among us will no longer remain hidden. Indeed, I
see that it will shine with bright rays and will penetrate
the hearts and draw them towards itself, but it needed
an opportunity to manifest itself. Thus, your challenge
to the Muslims is a greatly blessed and auspicious
opportunity.
15
In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. [Publisher]
57
Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
I do not expect you to insist that you will only deal with
the Muslims of Jandiala and nobody else. You are well
aware that there is no well-renowned scholar in Jandiala
and it will not befit your grandeur to compete with lay
people.
You are well informed of my situation. For the past ten
years I have been thirsting to debate with the Chris-
tians and to quench this thirst I have even sent thou-
sands of letters in Urdu and English to revered priests
like yourself, but having received no reply, I was left
disappointed. I am sending you some of these letters by
way of specimen so that you may realise that I should
be the first to deserve your attention in this regard.
I am ready to face any punishment if I am lying. I have
been prepared for the past ten years and to me there is
none in Jandiala who is eligible to enter this contest. I,
therefore, respectfully request that if you desire to settle
this debate once and for all, accept my challenge so that
some of the distinctive signs of the divinely supported
religion and of those who believe in the true God are
manifested.
One of your major claims is that the Messiah, peace be
upon him, was in fact God and the Creator of heaven
58
A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
and earth. We, on the other hand, believe that he was in-
deed a true prophet and messenger and was the beloved
of God Almighty, but he was not God. Hence, this
debate will be held in order to truly settle these issues.
God Almighty has directly informed me that the teach-
ings brought by the Holy Qur’an are, in fact, the true path;
every prophet has preached the same pure Oneness of
God to their respective nations, but with the passage of
time people became corrupted and accorded the status
of God Almighty to humans. In short, this will be the
objective of the debate.
I am certain that the time has come when the jealousy
of God Almighty will demonstrate its power and I trust
that due to this contest, useful and effective results shall
display themselves to the world. It would not be surpris-
ing if the entire world, or a large part of it, would now
accept the one true and living religion that is shaded by
God's cloud of mercy. The debate ought not to be lim-
ited to the earthly realm alone, but rather the heavens
ought to participate in it as well. The focus of this con-
test should be around which religion possesses spiritual
life, heavenly acceptance and enlightenment. It would be
incumbent upon me and my opponent to demonstrate
the effects of our respective books in our own beings.
If later on, they so desire to reconcile these two doctrines
59
on the basis of reason, this too is well and good; nev-
ertheless, the heavenly and spiritual contest must take
precedence.
وَالسَّلَامُ عَلَى مَنِ اتَّبَعَ الْهُدَى
Humbly,
Ghulam Ahmad
Qadian, District Gurdaspur
23 April 1893
16
And peace be on those who follow the guidance. [Publisher]