Amritsar, 24 April 1893: Translation of Dr Clark’s Letter
A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
Amritsar, 24 April 1893
TRANSLATION OF
DR CLARK'S LETTER 17
17
The heading is taken dirctly from the Urdu, and the letter
given herewith was re-translated from Urdu. The original English
text could not be found. [Publisher]
RESPECTFULLY TO:
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, Chief of Qadian
Dear Sir,
Maulvi Abdul-Karim, accompanied by an honourable
delegation, arrived and personally handed me your
letter. I gladly accept your challenge on behalf of the
Muslims. Your delegation has agreed on your behalf to
the necessary terms and conditions of the debate and I
am certain that you too will agree to them. Therefore,
kindly inform me at your convenience whether or not
you accept these conditions.
Yours sincerely,
H. Martyn Clark
MDCM (Edinburgh), MRAS, CMS
THE PROPOSED
CONDITIONS OF THE DEBATE
between the Christians & the Muslims
(Translation from English) 18
1. This debate will be held in Amritsar.
2. Each party will be represented by no more than fifty
people. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad will issue fifty tickets
to the Christians, and Dr Clark will release fifty
tickets to Mirza Sahib for the Muslims. The Muslims
will collect tickets from the Christians and vice versa.
3. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian will represent
the Muslims at the debate and Deputy Abdullah
Atham Khan will do so on behalf of the Christians.
4. Except for the two aforementioned gentlemen, no
one else will be permitted to speak in the debate.
They can, however, each select three persons as
assistants but they will not have the right to speak.
5. Both parties will accurately note down the
proceedings for the purpose of publication.
6. No speaker from either side will be permitted to
18
The heading in parenthesis is taken dirctly from the Urdu,
and the section given herewith was re-translated from Urdu. The
original English text could not be found. [Publisher]
Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
speak for more than one hour.
7. In administrative matters, the decision of the
president will be considered definitive.
8. There will be two presidents. At the time of the
debate, a member from each side will be selected.
9. The venue of the debate will be decided by Dr Henry
Martyn Clark.
10. The time of the debate will be from 6 am to 11 am.
11. The debate will be held in two sessions. The first
session will last for six days, from Monday 22nd, to
27th May. During this period, as Mirza Sahib has
made evident in a letter to Dr Clark dated 4 April
1893, he will be permitted to put forth his view
that the truth of a religion ought to be established
through living signs.
12. Afterwards, the second point of discussion, namely
the divinity of Christ will be addressed; Mirza Sahib
will be entitled to raise any further questions, albeit
within the allotted six days.
13. The second session will also last for six days, from
29th May to 3rd June (if required). During this
session, Mr Abdullah Atham Khan will be permitted
to present his questions as outlined below:
66
A Conclusive Argument in Favour of Islam
a. Unconditional Mercy
b. Predestination and Divine Decree
c. Belief in Predestination
d. Proof that the Holy Qur’an is the Word of God
e. Proof that Muhammad (peace and blessings of
Allah be upon him and his progeny) is the Messenger
of God
Mr Atham can also raise other questions provided
that he does not exceed the prescribed six days.
14. The tickets will be issued by 15th May according to
the sample below.
15. The Christians and Deputy Abdullah Atham Khan
consent to abide by the above conditions and certify
to the following statement: I (the undersigned) sign
this document on behalf of Mr Abdullah Atham Khan
by way of testimony that either of the parties that fail to
abide by any of the aforementioned conditions will be
considered guilty of breaching their agreement.
16. To confirm the validity of the speeches, both the
presidents and the speakers will sign them.
(Signed)
Henry Clark MD et al.
Amritsar
24 April 1893
67
Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
SAMPLE TICKET
The debate between
Deputy Abdullah Atham Khan
of Amritsar and
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
of Qadian
ENTRANCE TICKET FOR THE CHRISTIANS
ALLOW ENTRY TO..
NUMBER
Signature:
Mirza Sahib
SAMPLE TICKET
The debate between
Deputy Abdullah (Atham) Khan
of Amritsar and
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad
of Qadian
ENTRANCE TICKET FOR THE MUSLIMS
ALLOW ENTRY TO..
NUMBER
Amritsar
Signature:
Dr Clark
24.4.1893
68