Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part IV, Part 27

Now, returning to the original subject, I reiterate that all of the beauties, divine insights, and attributes of Surah al-Fatihah, outlined by me so far, are manifestly without parallel and equal. For instance, anyone who honestly reflects upon the exalted status of the verities contained in Surah al-Fatihah, and then ponders over the beauties and fine points that the blessed surah comprises, and then studies the beauty of its composition and brevity of its text as to how vast meanings have been encapsulated in very few words, and then looks at the text as to how splendid it is and how it possesses such fluency, clarity, and delicacy that it is like pure and limpid water flowing ever so smoothly, and then contemplates its spiritual effectiveness that miraculously transforms hearts, purifying them of mortal darknesses and making them recipients of the light of Allah the Almighty which I have proven at its appropriate place in this book,1 the exalted status of the Holy Qur’an, which is beyond the reach of human capacities, will become manifest to such a one to a degree that cannot be surpassed. But if, despite witnessing these excellences, the peerlessness of the Holy Word remains doubtful to an inwardly blind person, the Holy Qur’an has a remedy even for such deniers against whom it brings its argument to completion. And that is:

Meaning that, if you doubt that this Word is from Allah, then write a composition like any surah in it. But if you cannot do it—and, bear in mind, never shall you be able to do it—then guard against the Fire, which is prepared for the disbelievers and the fuel of which is disbelieving men and their idols who are stoking up the fire of Hell with their sins and mischief. This is the conclusive verdict which God Almighty Himself has provided in order to indict those who deny the miracle of the Holy Qur’an. Now if there is anyone who, in spite of being confuted and indicted, still denies the peerless eloquence of the Holy Qur’an and does not desist from idle and obscene talk, then such a shameless and crooked nature cannot be treated in this world; their only remedy is the one promised by God in His conclusive verdict.

Some mischievous and malicious people, who have taken a firm stand upon obstinacy and egotism, and who have been utterly blinded by the whirlwind of bigotry, try to mislead people by saying that all of the beauties and fine points that Muslims attribute to the Holy Qur’an and all of its wondrous beauties mentioned in Muslim books are the product of the acute intelligence and inventions of their own natures; whereas in reality, the Holy Qur’an is devoid of such beauties, fine points, and wondrous characteristics. However, such people can do nothing to hide the light in the Holy Qur’an; rather, they only expose their own foolishness and depravity. It should suffice to say in response to them: If Muslims have indeed invented, through the exercise of their own intellect, all forms of beauties, fine points and qualities of the Holy Qur’an which were not actually present there, then you, too, should, as against them, produce beauties, fine points and qualities relating to your revealed books or, for that matter, any other book; and if you cannot compete with the whole of the Holy Qur’an, then at least, by way of specimen, try to produce from any other book the excellences contained in Surah al-Fatihah alone, some of which have been described in this very footnote.

Alas! From where have these congenitally blind ones come up, whose darkness is not dispelled even after seeing such profusion of light? How putrid and stinking is the substance of their inner diseases that it has rendered useless all of their outer and inner senses. They do not consider in the least that the Holy Qur’an is the Book which has itself proclaimed its own greatness, its wisdom, its truths, its eloquence, its subtle verities and its fine points and its spiritual light, and it has proven its own incomparability. It is not at all true that the Muslims have put forward these excellences on their own. On the contrary, it itself sets out its own beauties and excellences and puts forward its matchlessness and peerlessness as a challenge to the whole of creation and is loudly blowing the trumpet: ‘Is there any contestant?’ And its fine point and verities are not confined to two or three which would leave room for doubt on the part of an ignorant person; rather, its subtleties are surging like a swelling ocean and are shining bright in every direction like the stars of the sky. There is no verity that lies outside of it and there is no wisdom that is not comprised inside of its all-encompassing words, and there is no light that cannot be obtained through following it. These things are not without proof and are not mere verbal statements. On the contrary, it is an established and clearly proven verity which has been manifesting its brightness continuously for the last 1,300 years. And I have also set out this verity in great detail in this book of mine and have expounded the subtleties and insights of the Holy Qur’an in such detail as to constitute a surging ocean for the satisfaction of a seeker after truth. How then could anyone trivialize this great light by mere verbal nonsense? However, if someone really entertains the misgiving that all these subtleties, insights, beauties, and qualities which have been proven to exist in the Holy Qur’an can also be derived from some other book, then the straightforward manner of debating it would be for him to present those beauties, divine insights, and qualities in keeping with the conditions laid down above.

He should prove that, as the Holy Qur’an refutes all false beliefs, and just as this Holy Word establishes every true doctrine with rational arguments, and just as these Holy Scriptures1 contain divine insights and verities, and wonderful qualities and unique effects relating to the enlightenment of the heart as I have amply proven in this book, he should demonstrate that all of them are also contained in his book. Until he has done so, his howling at the moon will not deprive it of any of its light. Rather, pitiable indeed is the state of the person who is still deliberately traversing the path of misguidance to remain deprived and devoid of self-evident truth. There are many famous and renowned gentlemen among our opponents whose knowledge and understanding, in my estimation, is such that—as far as I can tell—they would readily understand these verities, provided they reflect upon them with a fair mind. It is not at all my intention to dispute out of self-conceit, and I have no objective other than to spread truth and righteousness in the world. Hence, I request fair-minded and knowledgeable persons to make use of their sincere intentions for a moment. In view of the fact that their open-heartedness and integrity is established in their respective communities, how can I lose hope and how can I believe that this good disposition cannot be further broadened? Therefore, although I have not yet seen any of my opponents take a fair step in this regard, my opinion until now has been based on firm certainty and I believe with a strong conviction that when our fair-minded opponents will turn their close attention to this issue with deep and profound insight, then in their eyes these doubts of theirs would be sufficiently removed.

When Part III of this book was published, I had hoped that the intellectuals among the Brahmu Samajists and Aryah Samajists would learn of their error and hasten thirsting for the real truth. But alas, I now realize that I was wrong in my judgement. Indeed, I was disheartened to find out that Brahmu and Aryah gentlemen did not read my book with care. Especially when I saw the review [of Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya] by Pundit Shiv Narayan, I realized how vast is the world of prejudice that has engulfed the nature of the Aryas. (May God have mercy.) It is a pity that the Pundit failed to derive any benefit from the divine verities that shine bright like the sun, and the light of such strong and powerful arguments could do nothing to diminish the darkness of the Pundit’s prejudice. It is really surprising that such intelligent and knowledgeable people should hesitate in accepting a perfect proof after it has been demonstrated. In rejecting it, the Pundit has not only trespassed the boundary of justice, but by deliberately concealing the truth, he has deprived himself of the goodwill for his people and has even deserted God. I need not explain here as to how the Pundit’s denial is full of injustice; for it will become apparent to anyone who first reads my book—in which I have given proof of the need for divine revelation and its existence—and then looks at the Pundit’s writing and sees what he has written in response to me and how he has answered my arguments. The Pundit cannot put a veil upon the souls of the people of his religion who read this book carefully, provided their natures are not already covered by veils.

10 of 10 left today