Sub-Footnote Number Four
Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part IV
My humble self had written [this book] up to this point when a man, by the name of Shahab-ud-Din, of Theh Ghulam Nabi, a believer in the Oneness of God, came and informed me that Maulavi Ghulam Ali, Maulavi Ahmadullah of Amritsar, Maulavi Abdul Aziz, and some other maulavis [Muslim religious clerics] emphatically deny the kind of revelation that resembles prophetic revelation. Further, some maulavis among them regard such revelations to be delusions of maniacs. The argument they advance in support of this contention is that if this kind of revelation was indeed true and authentic, then the Companions of the Holy Prophet of God, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, were the most deserving and worthy of receiving it, and yet it is not proven that they were recipients [of such revelation].
I, the humblest of men, now submit that if the maulavis have indeed raised this objection—as Shahab-ud-Din, a believer in the Oneness of God, says they did—then, in response, every seeker after truth as well as the above-mentioned maulavis should keep in mind that the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. Is it not possible that the revered Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, might have been the recipients of these types of revelation and yet did not deem it appropriate to make them generally known at that time? God Almighty ordains ever new courses of action to be appropriate in every age. Hence, during the time of the prophethood, divine wisdom required that the revelations of non-prophets should not be recorded in the manner of prophetic revelation, lest the words of the non-prophet be intermingled with those of the Prophet. But the revelations of the auliya’ [friends of Allah] and other men of inner spiritual excellence who came after that age are well known and well publicized, and have been duly recorded in every age. To verify this, one should read Maktūbāt of Shaikh ‘Abdul-Qadir al-Jilani 1 and Mujaddid Alf Thani,2 as well as books by other auliya’ullah [friends of Allah], wherein a vast number of their revelations have been recorded. Even Imam Rabbani [Mujaddid Alf Thani] has explicitly written in the second volume of his Maktūbāt, letter number 51 to be precise, that even a nonprophet can be honoured with the divine word and discourse, and that such a person is called a muhaddath and his rank is nearer to the rank of the Prophets. Likewise, Shaikh ‘Abdul-Qadir al-Jilani has elucidated this matter at various places in Futuhul-Ghaib. A diligent search into the sayings and letters of auliya’ullah will yield many such statements. And the rank of muhaddathiyyat 3 in ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah [the followers of Muhammad] is proven so widely that only the extremely ignorant and utterly unaware can deny it. Up to the present day, thousands of auliya’ullah have appeared within this ummah, endowed with perfect excellences, whose wonders and miracles are as proven and established as those of the Israelite Prophets. Anyone who investigates will know that just as the One True God has bestowed the title Khairul- Umam [the Best of People] upon this ummah, so has He bestowed the greatest excellences on its elders which cannot be concealed in any way, and to deny them is the worst kind of concealment of truth.
I would also like to add that it is completely baseless and wrong to allege that there is no proof that the revered Companions received such divine revelations. For, according to authentic ahadith, there is ample proof of the great number of revelations and miracles experienced by the revered Companions, Allah be pleased with them. Hadrat Umar’s, Allah be pleased with him, learning of the perilous state of Sariyah’s troops through divine communication has been recorded by al-Baihaqi 1 on the authority of Ibn-e-Umar. What was it, if not divine revelation! Moreover, Hadrat Umar’s words,
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘O Sariyah! The mountain, the mountain!’] were uttered in Madinah, but were heard by Sariyah and his troops in a far off land through the grace of divine providence. What was it, if not a miraculous Sign! Likewise, certain revelations and visions experienced by Hadrat Ali Murtada, may Allah honour and exalt him, are also very well known. Besides this, I ask: Is the testimony of God Almighty in the Holy Qur’an in this regard not sufficient for one’s satisfaction? Has He not said regarding the revered Companions:
When on one hand, the Almighty God declares the Companions of His Noble Prophet to be better and greater than the past peoples in terms of all excellences, and on the other hand, by way of example He gives an account of the perfect ones of the past peoples, such as Maryam
Siddiqah [Mary the Truthful], the mother of ‘Isa [ Jesus], as well as the mother of Hadrat Musa [Moses], the disciples of Hadrat Masih [i.e. Jesus the Messiah] and Khidr—none of whom was a Prophet, but they were all recipients of revelation from Allah and were apprised of the secrets of the unseen through wahy-e-i‘lam.1
Now consider what conclusion follows from this. Does it not prove that the perfect followers among ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah should be more deserving to be mulham-o-muhaddath [the recipients of revelation and discourse] than those people, because according to the explanation of the Holy Qur’an they [the perfect followers among ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah] are Khairul-Umam? Why do you not ponder over the Holy Qur’an? And why are you so prone to error in your deliberations? Do you not know that the Sahihain 2 record, about this ummah, the glad tiding of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, that like the previous ummahs, many a muhaddath would be raised in this ummah as well? And the word muhaddath—in which the د [dal] is pronounced with a fathah—refers to those who are blessed with divine converse and discourse. You are also aware of Ibn-e-‘Abbas’ qira’at 3 of the verse: و ما ارسلنا من قبلك من رسول و 4اٰیٰتہ ہللا مکما یلقی الشیطٰن ثم یح ہللا تہ فینسخيال نبی وال محدث اال اذا تمنّٰی القی الشیطٰن فی امن . Thus, according to this verse, which Bukhari has also documented, it is established that a muhaddath’s revelations are certain and unequivocal, in which the interference of Satan cannot stand.
It also goes without saying that if the revelations of Khidr and the mother of Musa were only a bundle of doubts and delusions, and were not certain and unequivocal, what right did they have to endanger the life of any innocent person or to push them to death, or do anything else that was both unlawful and unreasonable? After all, it had to be unequivocal knowledge that made those actions obligatory upon them, and made permissible for them matters that were by no means permissible for others.
Apart from this, one should reflect impartially that an observable and existing phenomenon which has been proven true and has been established as fact through verifiable experiences cannot be shaken by mere conjectures and suspicions:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[And conjecture avails nothing against truth]. In the revelations received by my humble self, there is nothing concealed or hidden. Rather, it is a phenomenon that has withstood the crucible of hundreds of trials, yet emerged securely intact, and the Benevolent God has granted me manifest victory in great contests.
Here I recall that the true dream, which I have recorded in Part III regarding a court case of a Hindu, was also accompanied by a revelation that came at a time of a strange dispute and denial and relieved me of a great anxiety and distress. The following is a detailed account.
In this true dream of mine, which was like a clear vision, it was conveyed to me that one Bishambar Das, a Khatri 1 Hindu, who is alive and present in Qadian, would not be acquitted in a criminal case, but that his sentence would be reduced by one-half, and that his fellow prisoner named Khush Hal, who is also alive and present in Qadian, would serve out the whole of his sentence. A trial was encountered about this aspect of the vision. It so happened that when the Chief Court remitted the case to the lower court, in accordance with the prophecy of my humble self, the relatives of the two accused persons considered this remittal as an acquittal and announced the news in the town that both of them had been acquitted of the crime. I recall that this news spread in town during the evening. I was ready to offer the ‘Isha’ prayer while I was in the mosque, when one of the worshippers stated that this news had been spread in town and that the accused persons had returned to town. As I had publicly announced that they would certainly not be acquitted, I became prey to indescribable grief and sorrow. Then God, who always lends support to this humble servant of His, gave me the glad tiding at the beginning or during the course of the prayer with this revelation:
Fear not, for you will have the upper hand.
Accordingly, the next morning it became clear that the news about the acquittal was totally false and that the result was exactly as my humble self had been foretold and of which Sharampat, the Aryah, and several other people—who still live in Qadian—had been apprised in advance.
Another similarly awe-striking incident took place which is even more astonishing. It is described hereunder. Concerning a case instituted by my late father against one of his tenants relating to some tenancy rights in dispute, it was revealed to me in a dream that the suit would be decreed favourably. I communicated this dream to an Aryah who lives in Qadian. Then it so happened that on the final date of the hearing, only the defendant appeared in the court with some of his witnesses, but no attorney etc. appeared from this side. The defendant and all witnesses, upon their return in the evening, spread the news that the suit had been dismissed. On hearing this news, the said Aryah accused me of falsehood and mocked me. It is difficult for me to put into words the pain and torment that I suffered at that time, for it was hard to imagine that all these people, including some who were impartial, would make a statement contrary to the facts. In this condition of extreme grief and sorrow the following revelation came to me very forcefully and was entrenched into my heart like an iron nail: