Footnote Number Eleven

Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya Part III, Part 15

It is these people [i.e., Muslims] who have benefitted from the Word of Allah, and it is this spring of God’s Word that gushed forth and carried its water far and wide, so much so that it has restored greenery to almost a third of the withered garden of India. The hearts of many of the rest were also affected by this holy spring, for they, too, have been drawn somewhat closer to Tauhid.

The level of misguidance to which the Hindus had fallen before the coming of the Holy Qur’an is evident from the study of the Puranas and Pustaks , whose idolatrous teachings had taken the whole of India in their grip, and which had been written just a short while before the Holy Qur’an. They will show you what your revered rishis thought at the time, and how deeply your devoted ascetics and mystics were steeped in false superstitions as they supplicated before lifeless idols and chanted mantras to invoke them. All this was happening at a time when they were quite well-versed in the rational sciences and, compared to the times of the Vedas, had made considerable progress in rational and logical analysis. Indeed, they were not far behind the Greeks in terms of logic and philosophy, but their beliefs were corrupt, unholy and polluted by the filth of idolatry both in form and substance. In fact, their beliefs did not have the slightest semblance to divine truths and were totally fallacious, groundless, without substance, and useless, which prompted your ‘wise’ forefathers to view everything in the world as their deity. Seeing a tree verdant and beautiful, they took it to be their god; a flame emerging from the earth was to them worthy of worship; and the name of parmeshwar [god] was given to anything that was strange or fearsome in its physical appearance or in its characteristics. There was nothing they did not worship—water, wind, fire, rocks, the moon, the sun, birds, animals, and even snakes.

The truth is that the Vedas had only advocated creature-worship to a limited degree and they did not even refer to worshipping idols, but those who came afterwards and took themselves to be great logicians kept adding footnotes whereby they created hundreds of artificial parmeshwars and some even claimed to be parmeshwars themselves. As a consequence of their thoughts and innovations, they became entangled in all kinds of ridiculous delusions and went so far as to deny the existence of the Omnipotent Creator and all His perfect attributes.

The effect that the Upanishads, Puranas, and Pustaks had on the minds of the Hindus, the superstitions they sowed in their hearts, the paths they established for them, and the objects they led them to worship, is not something hidden or which can be concealed by anybody, nor can it be made dubious by denial. Similar was the case with the Greeks. Being hailed clever as a crow, they also gorged themselves on the filth of idolatry. Thus, at no time in history did unaided reason prepare a community that was established on pure Tauhid.

I have conducted thorough research into the reason for the Brahmu Samaj’s inclination towards Tauhid and I have concluded that from among their religious elders, the founder of their faith had acquired this concept from the Holy Qur’an. However, it was his misfortune that he could not fully absorb the teaching of Tauhid. This is how the seed of Tauhid, taken from the Book of God, gradually spread among the Brahmu Samajists. If any gentleman from among the Brahmus holds doubts about this finding, then he is under obligation to show us, with arguments, from where else they acquired the concept of Tauhid. Did they hear of it from elsewhere or did one of their founders discover it solely through their intellect. If they heard of it from some other source, then let them explicitly state which book, apart from the Holy Qur’an, had propagated throughout India the concept of God being One and without partner, beyond the need for family or offspring, free from every form of incarnation or embodiment, and complete and perfect in His person and in all His attributes. Let them give us the name of the book from which they derived the concept of Tauhid. And if they say that their founder did not hear of it from anywhere but reasoned it out himself, then the onus is upon them to prove that—at the time when the founder of the Brahmus was establishing their religion—the concept of Tauhid had not already been propagated in India through the Holy Qur’an. For if it had, then there can be no question of ‘discovering’, and it will perforce have to be admitted that the founder of the Brahmu Samaj acquired the concept of Tauhid solely from the Holy Qur’an.

In any event, unless you disprove my view with powerful arguments, it will stand proven that you have indeed acquired the concept of Oneness of God from the Holy Qur’an. And yet you remain ungrateful and refuse to acknowledge the debt you owe to your benefactor and teacher. Instead of expressing gratitude, you resort to abuse like those who are mischievous and depraved by nature.

In addition to this, all historians know well that in the past whenever someone acquired full cognition of God and His perfect attributes, it was only through revelation. The concept of the Oneness of God was never propagated through rational arguments alone in any age. This is why those whom divine revelation did not reach remained unaware of the existence of God, and were left uncivilized and uncultured like animals. Can anyone show us a book written in the past that spoke of divine knowledge and contained real verities, and yet its author claimed that he did not discover the right path to recognizing God through revelation, nor did he hear of the One God from elsewhere; rather, he discovered God and learned about divine attributes by his own reason, reflection, meditation, and diligence; that he found the concept of Oneness of the Divine without being taught by anyone; and that his mind attained true enlightenment and perfect cognition on its own.

Who can prove to us that there was an age when there was no sign of divine revelation and the door to the holy scriptures of God was closed, and yet the people of such an era had attained true knowledge of God and His Tauhid merely through the study of the book of nature. And who can name us a country whose inhabitants reached God through their reason alone while remaining ignorant of the existence of revelation, or came to believe in the Oneness of God, the Creator, through their own reflection and observation.

Why do you mislead the ignorant masses and—without fearing God even for a fleeting moment—utter that which is deceitful and deceptive. Why do you call that which is open to be closed and vice versa. Do you have no belief in the Omnipotent God who knows well what is in man’s heart, and from whose all-encompassing glance no dishonest person can remain hidden. Alas, the trouble is that your faith is like a narrow and dark place where not even a ray of clear and bright light has reached. This is why your religion is a collection of thousands of types of straitness and darkness, and is so constricted that no part of it can be seen as open and none of the issues seem to be set out clearly and correctly.

As for your faith in God, I have already stated where you stand in that regard. And as for your conviction regarding the Day of Reckoning, and the doors of enlightenment that the law of nature has opened for you about it, suffice it to say that all you possess in this respect is a bundle of baseless speculations and superstitions, let alone certain knowledge of the minute details of the Reckoning. First of all, you are not even sure that reward and punishment are a reality and that God will certainly recompense man for his actions. For if you know this, then please prove by a rational argument why God should be obliged to reward mankind for their righteousness and why He should hold evildoers to account for their sins and transgressions.

Whereas God is under no obligation to grant eternity to the human soul as opposed to the souls of other animals, why would it be obligatory for Him to reward and punish man exclusively and spare the others. Does God derive any benefit from your good deeds or does He suffer pain from your bad deeds, so that He may reward the virtuous for the comfort He received from their good deeds and take revenge from the evildoers for pain He has suffered. And if doing good or evil neither personally benefits nor harms Him, it does not matter to Him whether you obey Him or not. And if that is the case, then how can it be proved with certainty that reward and punishment must be a consequence of actions under all circumstances.

Would it be in accord with justice if someone did something on his own without being asked by another person but then started demanding recompense from the latter. Certainly not. For instance, if Person X were to dig a ditch or erect a building without Person Y having asked him to do it, then, even if we were to assume such a ditch or building were of great benefit to Person Y, the law of justice does not bind Person Y to compensate Person X for his labour and toil, which he carried out of his own accord without any instruction or order from Person Y.

·

10 of 10 left today