Introduction
Blessings of Khilafat, Part 14
Human beings, on account of their limited knowledge, commit many errors in making their decisions. There was a time when people believed that the heavens were made of different metals. Later, philosophers suggested that the heavens only marked the endpoint to which a human eye could see, and that there was nothing physical about them. They said that no one knew what else could be discovered in the days to come. That is how all fields of knowledge are shaped. The branches of knowledge that existed a hundred years ago do not exist any more; instead, some new fields have emerged with the passage of time. Initially, it was believed that the universe consisted of just one sun, and that all other stars and planets revolved around the same sun; but now we have come to know that there are stars which are so huge and so far away from us that their light is just reaching us now. Moreover, they are much bigger in size than the sun. At one time, people used to believe, and it is a well-known premise, that the pointer of a compass always faced north; but now experiments have revealed that at certain intervening periods it starts moving towards the west as well, and having travelled in that direction for some time it again changes its course and turns towards the north. In short, knowledge is undergoing such rapid changes that what we know today may prove to be wrong tomorrow. There is no doubt that God has blessed man with knowledge and wisdom, but He has certainly not endowed an intellect which is infallible and which cannot accept changes to the conclusions it has drawn already. This is why God has taught Muslims how to pray, because humans being are prone to making mistakes.
Instead of praying to God that something must be given to them or some work must be done for them; God has taught that they should pray that God may cause to happen that which is good in His estimation, and that may He provide them with that which is truly beneficial. Since God never makes mistakes, His decision is always right and correct. To turn towards God is the simplest and best method available to everyone in this world to make the best decisions in regard to every matter. To us, also, this is the simplest method available. Anyone who had failed to understand the philosophy of Khilafat should have prayed to God, and performed Istikharah, beseeching God for guidance and submitting to Him, ‘O my Lord! If the right path is that of Khilafat, pray do let me know. If not, show me the straight path, and do not let me off the path of the righteous lest I go astray.’ But, alas! There are many who did not give heed to this method. I told many of my friends about this method and they acted upon it and received guidance from Allah through some dream or revelation, or God blessed their hearts with satisfaction and conviction in some other way. If someone is still in doubt and feels apprehensive, he can still follow this same method. God will surely guide him on the right path.
In my first speech, I was only able to highlight one point, but there are fourteen more points to speak on. Four of them require the same time to explain as the first one, but I have neither the strength nor the time needed to do so. In addition, there is another important point to be discussed tomorrow. By the grace of Allah, I am feeling relieved of the cough, but I have started feeling some pain in the chest. Therefore, I would like to explain the remaining points more concisely. God willing, I shall speak on them in greater detail at some other time.
One more thing that I must speak on is politics. There is a great confusion in our Jama‘at over this issue, and lack of clear guidance has been a great trial for some. Questions as to whether or not we should take part in politics, and whether politics is good; or if it is bad, just how bad it is; all these questions have been a source of much controversy. In light of this growing confusion, I reflected upon the teachings of the Promised Messiah (as) , and asked his companions for their opinion on the matter. They are unable to quote even a single example whereby the Promised Messiah (as) ever instructed them to focus their attention on politics, or told them to pursue it. However, it raises another objection, and this objection is not only repeated by the newly educated youth, but by some experienced people also. The objection is: why is the Ahmadiyya Jama‘at not allowed to take part in politics?
Why is the Ahmadiyya Jamaaaa‘at Not Allowed
to Take Part in Politics?
An ignorant and unwise person may say that Ahmadis are told not to take part in it because it is a useless waste of time, but a person who has studied history and who is well-informed regarding the peoples of the past will never make such a comment, for he knows that worldly governments and rulers depend upon politics. God Almighty has also stated some benefits of politics in the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an has considered this topic worthy of discussion for it found it to be something beneficial; else, why would it have mentioned it? Moreover, we also observe that strikes often help people secure their rights. Governments, too, do not mind agitation as long as it is justifiable. The question then is, why is the Jama‘at not allowed to take part in politics, and why has the Promised Messiah (as) forbidden us to pursue it?
First of all, I do not consider politics to be useless outright. However, the difference between my opinion and that of others is that I do not see the same benefits that others do. Since I am afraid this controversy could result in discord amongst the members of the Jama‘at, I wish to explain the reality of this particular point of view so that, God willing, the matter can be resolved once and for all.
The Holy Qur’an sets out an easy way to decide on any matter, which is, that before making any decision, one should seriously consider all the advantages and disadvantages that may ensue. The Holy Qur’an, in relation to gambling and drinking, states:
That is, people ask you about drinking and whether it is lawful to drink or forbidden, and similarly they ask you about gambling. God instructed His Prophet (sa) to tell them that both carry some good qualities as well as some bad qualities. But the disadvantages outweigh the advantages. How pure is the religion of Islam! It never closes its eyes from even the slightest good and virtuous qualities that a thing may have. How beautifully and truly it has answered the question. Upon the question being asked, it has not forbidden drinking and gambling outright, but it has made clear that the drawbacks far outnumber the benefits. Then it has left the decision up to you. The formula that God has laid down for us is that everything is possessed of two kinds of attributes, those that are
both there is great sin and also some advantages for men; but their sin is greater than their advantage.’ (Surah al-Baqarah, 2:220)
beneficial as well as those that detrimental. For this reason, it instructs us to do something only when the advantages exceed the disadvantages. It also advises us to shun those things whose negative aspects are more than the positive ones. All of the world’s enterprises move according to this doctrine. Every single person opts for that which carries greater benefit and avoids that which is likely to cause risk or damage. Therefore, you should judge politics on the same principle. Politics, in itself, is not a bad thing at all. But, our point of view is that a thing lawful at one time can become unlawful at another. For instance, through prayer one attains nearness to God, but sometimes the same person becomes Satan by offering the same prayer at sunrise or sunset. In such a situation, he becomes Satan rather than attaining nearness to God. God says that He Himself becomes the reward for a person who fasts for His sake, but the Holy Prophet (sa) has said that those who fast on the Eid day are Satans. So, although fasting for the sake of God is indeed a great form of worship, to fast on the Eid day has been declared a satanic act by the Holy Prophet (sa). It is obvious that a thing which is good at one time can become bad at another. For instance, if someone suffering from backache requests someone else to massage his back to relieve the pain and thereby receive a reward in return, the massager will surely get a reward; but if someone is busy speaking to some gathering and his servant while sitting to his back starts massaging him, then could you anticipate the treatment the servant will get from his master? The servant will be punished, because everything is meant to be done at its appropriate time.
In other words, something which is considered to be bad at one time can become good at another. The reason why the Promised Messiah (as) forbade his Jama‘at from taking part in politics was that the time was not yet ripe for such an activity. Therefore, despite the fact that the government encourages participation in politics, it is still improper for us to engage in it. The Promised Messiah (as) wrote that though the government permits indulging in political matters to some extent, he saw that the end of such indulgence was going to be harmful. That is why I too do not permit my Jama‘at to take part in it. Once the Promised Messiah (as) went to see a high official of the province. Although it was not his practice to go and see such people, he went this time considering the official to be his guest. The government in those days considered the Muslim League to be of some benefit to the state in the future. The official asked the Promised Messiah (as) of his opinion about the Muslim League. He answered that he did not know about it. Khawaja Sahib had recently acquired its membership so he drew a very rosy picture of it before the Promised Messiah (as) . The Promised Messiah (as) remarked that he did not really like that people take part in politics. The official said, ‘the Muslim League is nothing bad. It bodes well’. The Promised Messiah (as) replied: ‘How do you say it is not bad? A day will come when it will also stand against you.’ The official said, ‘Maybe you have Congress in your mind. The League is not like Congress; for the result of anything depends upon the principles it is founded on. Congress proved to be harmful since its foundation rested on wrong principles, but the Muslim League stands on doctrines which shall never allow any kind of rebellious element to take root in it.’ The Promised Messiah (as) replied that this might be what he thought today, but the League would soon behave in the same way as Congress.
Now, certain incidents have proved that the Muslim League is also inclining towards demanding self-rule which the Congress had been seeking for a long time. However, it is possible that the Muslim League may be using some other term for it. In short, even though an official who held a responsible position greatly emphasized that the Muslim League would not be harmful, the Promised Messiah (as) reiterated that their activities would not result in something good. Eventually, his statement proved to be true. Remember it well that the reason why the Promised Messiah (as) has stopped his Jama‘at from taking an even legitimate interest in politics is not that politics is bad in itself; rather, he did it keeping in view its being more harmful than beneficial at this particular juncture. Here, I will continue to explain this point even further.
There is a hadith which says:
That is, a time will come when such rulers will appear who will desire everything good only for themselves and will pay no attention to the comfort of the ordinary people, and such things will appear which you will abhor. The companions of the Holy Prophet (sa) submitted, ‘O Prophet of God! What are we supposed to do in such a situation?’ That is, they asked whether they should stand against such rulers and forcefully put them on the right track. The Holy Prophet (sa) said, ‘Do fulfil your obligations which you owe to the rulers, and as for the rights which they owe to you, do not demand it of them. Let God Himself take care of your needs, and pray that may He be your help.’