A Review of Two Booklets

Blessings of Prayer

& Tahrir fi Usulit Tafsir by Sayyid Ahmad Khan Sahib, K.C.S.I.

invoke His blessings upon His noble Prophet (sa). [Publishers]

Holy Qur’an.' [Publishers]

O prisoner of your own intellect!

Be not too proud of yourself;

This wonderful celestial sphere

Has brought forth many like you.

One who is alienated from God

Can never find access to His court;

The secrets of the Beloved are revealed

Only to him who comes from heaven.

It is foolish to think that you can fathom

The secrets of the Holy Qur’an on your own;

Whoever invents meanings from himself

Invents only filth and carrion.

In his booklet with the above heading, Sayyid Sahib has the following to say on the subject of the acceptance of prayer:

Prayer does not mean that whatever is prayed for will necessarily be granted, for if this be the meaning of acceptance of prayer, two difficulties would arise: First, thousands of prayers are offered with great humility and in extreme anguish, and yet the wish is not granted. This means that the prayer has not been accepted despite the fact that God has promised the acceptance of prayers.

The second difficulty is that whatever is going to happen has already been determined; likewise that which is not going to happen has also been determined, and nothing can ever happen contrary to this determination. If the acceptance of prayer was taken to mean that whatever one asks for is granted, then the Divine promise:

will obviously not apply to the prayers which have been determined never to be granted. In view of this interpretation, the promise of the acceptance of prayer cannot be taken as a general promise, since only those requests will be granted which have already been decreed. And yet the promise of the acceptance of prayer is a general promise and admits of no exception. Moreover, as some verses of the Holy Qur’an indicate that things which have been decreed not to be granted are never granted, and at the same time it is evident from some other verses that no prayer is rejected and all are accepted—what is more, God Almighty has promised to accept all prayers, as indicated in the verse:

There can be no other way of reconciling this contradiction and inconsistency between the verses, other than to interpret the acceptance of prayer as the acceptance of worship, i.e., to consider prayer as a kind of worship which God Almighty has promised to accept when it is offered earnestly and with humility and submission. Thus the reality of the acceptance of prayer is that it is only a form of worship and it is merely on this account that it deserves merit. Of course, if the granting of something has already been determined and, perchance, a prayer is also offered for it, it will be granted—not because of the prayer, but only because it was predetermined. Nevertheless, a great benefit of prayer is that when one prays one’s heart is overawed by the Majesty and Omnipotence of God, and this feeling overcomes all the apprehensions which had been the source of distress, and the supplicant begins to experience forbearance and fortitude. This is a natural consequence of worship and this is what the acceptance of prayer means. Towards the end of his booklet Sayyid Sahib writes that those who are unaware of the reality of prayer and the wisdom inherent in it might object: What is the use of prayer when we know that nothing can happen that has not been predetermined? i.e., as we know that something which has been determined shall, in all circumstances, be granted—whether one prays for it or not—and that whatever has not been predetermined will not be granted—no matter how many prayers one offers for it; thus prayer turns out to be a futile exercise. In answer to this, Sayyid Sahib says that it is man’s nature to seek help when in distress, and it is due to this natural faculty that he prays without giving a thought to whether or not his prayer will be granted. He prays because it has been ingrained in his nature to seek everything from God.

It is obvious from the discourse I have summarised above that Sayyid Sahib does not believe prayer to be the means of attaining an objective, nor does he believe it to be helpful in achieving any purpose. He believes that a person who prays for the sole purpose of attaining an objective is grossly mistaken, because something which has been predetermined does not need any prayers; and crying and beseeching is of no avail when something has not been preordained. It is quite clear from this discourse that Sayyid Sahib believes prayer to be related only to worship, and that he considers it a folly to think of it as a means for achieving any worldly objective. Let it be clear that Sayyid Sahib is seriously mistaken in his understanding of the verses of the Holy Qur’an. God willing, I shall elaborate on this misconception later on.

Here it pains me to point out that if Sayyid Sahib did not have enough understanding to comprehend the verses of the Holy Qur’an, was also the law of nature hidden from his eyes when he wrote on this subject? How could he have ignored the law of nature while he professes to follow it and regards it as the interpreter of Divine guidance and of the hidden mysteries of the Holy Qur’an? Was Sayyid Sahib not aware that though there is nothing good or evil in the world which has not been preordained, nature has nevertheless appointed certain means for their occurrence, and no reasonable person will ever question the effectiveness of these means. For instance, if we were to take everything to have been predetermined, it would be as ineffectual to use or not to use medicine as it would be to pray or not to pray. But Sayyid Sahib would never say that medical science is utterly baseless, and that the True Physician has placed no effect in medicine? If Sayyid Sahib, in spite of his faith in the Divine Decree, also believes in the efficacy of medicine, then why is he creating mischief and why he is discriminating in the similar and parallel laws of God Almighty? Does he believe that God Almighty had the power to invest certain medicines such as Turbad, Scammony, Senna and Cottonseed with such powerful effects that one full dose of one of them immediately relieves diarrhoea; or, for instance, that God has endowed Arsenic, Beesh and other fatal poisons with such powerful effects that imbibing a pure extract of these is enough to dispatch a person from this world within minutes; and yet He treats as dead and ineffective the earnest and heartfelt supplications of His chosen ones as if they were without any effect whatsoever! Is it possible that there should be disharmony in the Divine order, and that the Will which God has manifested in medicines for the benefit of His creatures should fail to manifest itself in the case of prayers? This is definitely not so.

The fact is that Sayyid Sahib is himself unaware of the true philosophy of prayer and has no personal experience of its profound effects. He is like a person who uses an old, discarded and expired medicine for a long time, and then, finding it ineffective, declares the medicine to be without any effect. It is a pity that though Sayyid Sahib has reached old age, the system of Divine order has eluded him and he has failed to understand how Destiny and Predetermination has been closely linked to causes, nor does he understand the deep, indispensable and interdependent relationship between cause and effect. This is why he fell into the error of thinking that things can take place without the coming into play the physical and spiritual causes appointed by nature. Of course, there is nothing that has not been Preordained, and all the things that man makes use of, such as fire, water, air, soil, corn, vegetables, animals and minerals, have been ordained for him; nevertheless, if some fool were to imagine that anything can be gained without all the means that

God has appointed for the purpose, and without proceeding in the way that has been determined by nature, and without the mediation of physical or spiritual means, such a person seeks only to falsify the wisdom of God Almighty. The only meaning I can give to Sayyid Sahib’s words is that he does not regard prayer to be one of those effective causes whose existence he has proclaimed to the point of exaggeration. For instance, if the properties of fire are mentioned before Sayyid Sahib, he will never deny them and will never say that if burning has been preordained for someone he will burn even without the medium of fire. I am, therefore, surprised that despite being a Muslim he denies the effectiveness of prayer which at times lights up the darkness like fire and sometimes burns the hand of an impertinent foe. Does Sayyid Sahib only think of Predestination when it comes to prayer and forget it when fire and other elements are mentioned? Is it not the same Predetermination that affects both? Although Sayyid Sahib believes in Predetermination, he at the same time vehemently believes in the physical means, and his exaggeration in this regard has even earned him a bad name, why then does he forget the system of nature which he himself professes when it comes to prayer?

He considers a fly to have some effect, but he does not believe the same about prayer. The truth is that he is completely unacquainted with this realm. He has neither personal experience in this field, nor kept the company of those who have had such experiences.

Now, for the benefit of the general public, I will briefly set out the facts about the acceptance of prayer. Let it be clear that this subject is part of the larger subject of prayer, and it is a matter of principle that one who is not conversant with the fundamentals of a subject is bound to be mistaken and deceived in understanding its branches. This is why Sayyid Sahib has also been mistaken. Prayer, in essence, means a relationship of mutual attraction between a righteous person and his Lord. This means that God’s grace first draws a person towards Himself, and then, through the magnetism of the person’s sincerity, God draws closer to him. In the state of prayer this relationship reaches a point where it manifests wonderful qualities. When a man in grave difficulty falls down in prayer with perfect certainty, perfect hope, perfect fidelity, and perfect resolve; and when he becomes perfectly alert and advances far into the field of self-annihilation, tearing aside all veils of heedlessness, lo and behold, he finds before him the

10 of 10 left today