A Review of Two Booklets
Blessings of Prayer, Part 3
In this second book, Sayyid Sahib does not seem to consider Predetermination to be of any importance for of what Qutub-e-Rabbani and Ghauth-e-Subhani* Sayyid Abdul Qadir Jilani (ra) has written in his book Futuhul Ghaib, regarding the effect of the prayers and attention of the perfect men of God, based upon his own personal experiences. The meaning of the following excerpt is that the only testimony recognized in any field is that of a person who is well experienced in that particular field. Thus, only the person who enjoys a relationship of true sincerity and love with God can truly understand the philosophy of the acceptance of prayer. Therefore, to enquire about this holy philosophy from Sayyid Ahmad Khan Sahib is like seeking the remedy of a human illness from a veterinary surgeon. If Sayyid Sahib were to expound the relationship between a worldly government and its subjects,
* Qutub-e-Rabbani and Ghauth-e-Subhani are titles signifying the spiritual status of Sayyid Abdul Qadir Jilani (ra). [Publishers]
he describes everything as having a permanent existence, as though all things have slipped away from the Hand of God and He now exercises no control over their transformation or alteration, as if His divinity is confined to a narrow sphere and the manifestation of His power is something that belongs to the past, and the state in which we find things is not due to His Determination—for the concept of Determination requires the control of the Lord of Destiny—but14 is an innate quality of the things themselves which cannot be changed or transformed.
Obviously, characteristics over which God Almighty has no control cannot be called His Destiny. On the other hand, if He does have control over them, there will always be the possibility of alteration. Thus in the second booklet Sayyid Sahib has done away with
the governance of the True Lord of Destiny over all things to the extent that in respect of their inherent qualities he considers them to be no longer under the will of the Lord of Destiny. It is like Section 5 of the
Act regarding the tenants, in which the British have righteous. If you succeed in this you will become [precious as] the red brimstone and your status will be raised beyond people’s imagination, and God shall make you heir to His Prophets and Messengers (as), which means that all their knowledge, wisdom and blessings, which had disappeared into obscurity and oblivion, will be granted afresh to you, and you will reach the highest level of sainthood, and none after you shall be able to rise higher. Your prayers, your fortified resolve, and your blessings will relieve people of their anguish; the famine-stricken will be granted rain and crops will grow; the affliction and anguish of every low and high, and even the troubles of kings shall be alleviated through your attention and prayers; the Hand of Providence shall be with you, whichever direction it takes you will be guided in the same way; the Eternal Voice will beckon you to itself, which means that whatever flows from your tongue will be from God and it will be blessed; and you will be made a successor to all the righteous servants of Allah who were granted knowledge before you; a kind of power of creation will be bestowed on you, i.e., your attention and your prayer will exercise control in the world; if you then wish to turn the existing into non-existing, and vice versa, it will come to pass; extraordinary and miraculous things will take place at your hand; Divine secrets shall be revealed to you and you shall be given understanding of subtle and profound matters of Divine knowledge, of which you are considered to be worthy and deserving. [Author]
upheld the rights of hereditary tenants to such a degree that the landlord will no longer have any authority over them. Sayyid Sahib considers all things, for instance fire, to be hereditary tenants of the same category. Sayyid Sahib’s law is, in fact, even more severe than that of the British, because in Section 5 there is a clause which allows for the expulsion of a hereditary tenant if he does not pay his dues for the period of one year, even if it amounts to two annas; but Sayyid Sahib has usurped the rights of the Owner in every respect. One can hardly conceive of greater injustice!
Sayyid Sahib has demanded from a rival of his the criteria for evaluating the standard of a commentary of the Holy Qur’an. Therefore, I, who consider it my foremost duty to show the way to one who has gone astray, deem it proper to serve him in this aspect as well. It, therefore, needs to be understood that:
The first and foremost criterion for an accurate commentary of the Holy Qur’an is the testimony of the Holy Qur’an itself. One should bear well in mind that the Holy Qur’an is not like other books that are dependent upon extraneous sources for the proof or disclosure of their verities. The Holy Qur’an is like a perfectly balanced structure, the whole dynamics of which are disturbed by the displacement of a single block. The Holy Qur’an possesses no verity that is not supported by at least ten or twenty testimonies contained within itself. So, when we interpret a verse of the Holy Qur’an in a certain way, we should try to find out whether or not there are other testimonies present in the Holy Qur’an which support this interpretation. If there are no other testimonies, and the interpretation is found to be clearly opposed to some other verses, then we should conclude that this interpretation is false, for there is no possibility of contradiction in the Holy Qur’an. The touchstone of a true interpretation is that it should be supported by a host of clear and supporting testimonies of the Holy Qur’an itself.
The second criterion is the interpretation of the Holy Prophet (sa). There can be no doubt that our beloved and revered Prophet (sa) was the one who best understood the Holy Qur’an. Thus, if an interpretation made by the Holy Prophet (sa) is available, then a Muslim is duty-bound to accept it without any hesitation or reservation, otherwise he will appear to be feeble of faith and under the spell of philosophy.
The third criterion is the interpretation of the Companions of the Holy Prophet (sa). There is no doubt that the Companions (ra) were the first to inherit the light of the Holy Prophet (sa) and were the foremost inheritors of his knowledge. Allah blessed them abundantly and helped them in their understanding, for they practiced what they preached.
The fourth criterion is to meditate upon the meanings of the Holy Qur’an with the purity of one’s own self, because purity of the self has a certain affinity with the Holy Qur’an, as Allah says:
which means that the verities of the Holy Qur’an are disclosed only to a person of pure heart, for the two have an affinity with one another. Such a person recognizes these verities, and smells them, and his heart cries out that this indeed is the true way. The light of his heart is an excellent criterion for evaluating the truth. Unless a person is endowed with this quality and treads on the narrow path which the Prophets (as) have tread, it is only prudent that he should refrain from impertinently and arrogantly assuming the role of a commentator of the Holy Qur’an. Otherwise his commentary will be based upon his own inference, and this is something which the Holy Prophet (sa) has forbidden. He has said:
That is, he who interprets the Holy Qur’an based on his own inference, does an erroneous interpretation even though he thinks he has done well.
The fifth criterion is the Arabic lexicon. Since, the Holy Qur’an itself has provided sufficient means for its understanding, recourse to Arabic lexicon seems unnecessary. But there is no doubt that it helps in enhancing our understanding, and sometimes, when we consult the lexicon, our attention is drawn to some hidden subtleties of the Holy Qur’an and we discover some mystery.