Cover Page
Christianity - A Journey from Facts to Fiction, Part 3
as possibility which can be scientifically considered is that Mary’s unfertilized ovum provided the 23 chromosomes as the mother’s share in the forming of the embryo. That being so, the question would arise as to how the ovum was fertilized and where the remaining 23 essential chromosomes came from? It is impossible as to suggest that Jesus’ cells had only 23 chromosomes. No normal human child can be born alive with even 45 chromosomes. Even if a human being was deprived of a single chromosome out of the 46 necessary for the making of normal human being, the result would be something chaotic, if anything at all. Scientifically, as Mary could not provide the 46 chromosomes alone; 23 had to come from somewhere else. If God is the father then that presents several options. One, God also has the same chromosomes that humans have, in which case these must have been transferred somehow to the uterus of as Mary . That is unbelievable and unacceptable; if God has the chromosomes of human beings He no longer remains God. So as as a consequence of belief in Jesus as the literal ‘Son’ of God, even the divinity of the Father is jeopardised. The second possibility is that God created the extra chromo- somes as a supernatural phenomenon of creation. In other words, they did not actually belong to the person of God, but were created miraculously. This would automatically lead us to reject as Jesus’ relationship to God as one of child to father, and would result in the all-embracing relationship of the Universe to God, that is, the relationship of every created being to its Creator. === PDF-Seite 32 === 4 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
Is a Literal Son of God Possible? Evidently, therefore, literal sonship of God is impossible because a literal son must have half the chromosomes of his father and half the chromosomes of his mother. So another problem surfaces, the son would be half man and half god. But those who believe in as literal sonship, claim and emphasise that Christ was a perfect man and a perfect god. If the chromosomes were half the required number then we are not left with any problem, since no child would be born anyway. suppose it did happen, that child would only be half a man. Not to mention the missing twenty three full chromosomes, even a single defective gene within one chromosome can play havoc with a child born with such a congenital defect. He could be blind, limbless, deaf and dumb. The dangers attendant to such a mishap are unlimited. One should be realistic; it is impossible to conceive of God as possessing any chromosomes, human or otherwise. Therefore, with the personal physical contribution of God hav- as ing been ruled out, if a son were born to Mary with only the human character-bearing genes possessed by her ovum, whatever the outcome, he would certainly not be the ‘Son’ of God. At best you could describe that freak of nature as half a man and no more. as If the reproductive organs of Mary were like those of any other female and still the ovum were to fertilize somehow by itself, the maximum one can expect is the creation of something with only half the human characteristics. It would be abominable to call that something the ‘Son’ of God. === PDF-Seite 33 === The Sonship of Jesus Christ 5
as So how was Christ born? We understand that research on the subject of single mother birth without the participation of a male is being carried out in many advanced countries of the world. But so far human knowledge is only at a stage where scientific re- search has not yet advanced to such a level where positive irrefu- table evidence of virgin births in human beings can be produced. However, all sorts of possibilities remain open. At lower orders of life two phenomena are scientifically well established: Hermaphroditism and Parthenogenesis. As such, the as as miraculous birth of Jesus to Mary can be understood to belong to some similar natural but very rare phenomenon, the peripheries of which are not yet fully fathomed by man. Here follow brief descriptions of the phenomena of Hermaph- roditism and Parthenogenesis. Readers interested in a more scientific treatment of the subject matter, based upon current understanding, may refer to Appendix II.
Hermaphroditism Hermaphroditism exists when organs of both sexes are present within a single female and the chromosomes show both male and female characters aligned side by side. Laboratory tests have revealed cases such as that of a hermaphrodite rabbit which, at one stage, served several females and sired more than 250 young of both sexes, while at another stage, it became pregnant in isolation and gave birth to seven healthy young of both sexes. When autopsied, it, while in a pregnant condition, showed two func- === PDF-Seite 34 === 6 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
tional ovaries and two infertile testes. Recent studies suggest that such a phenomenon is possible, rarely, among humans also.
Parthenogenesis Parthenogenesis is the asexual development of a female ovum into an individual, without the aid of a male agent. It is observed among many lower forms of life such as aphids and also fish. There is also evidence that parthenogenesis can be a successful strategy among lizards living under low and unpredictable rainfall conditions. In laboratory conditions, mice and rabbit embryos have been developed parthenogenetically to a stage equivalent to halfway through pregnancy, but have then been aborted. In a recent study, scientists found that human embryos could be occasionally activated by parthenogenesis using calcium ionophore as a catalyst. Such research raises the prospect that some early human pregnancy losses may have involved the parthenogenetic activation of the embryo. According to the latest experimental research, however, the possibility of virgin birth has been shown to be scientifically feasible. A report in the Nature Genetics of Oct. 1995 discusses the remarkable case of a three year old boy whose body is derived in part from an unfertilised egg. The researchers examined DNA sequences all along the X chromosomes in the boy’s skin and blood and discovered that the X chromosomes in all his cells were identical to each other and derived entirely from his mother. Similarly, both members of each of the 22 other chromosome === PDF-Seite 35 === The Sonship of Jesus Christ 7
pairs in his blood were identical and derived entirely from his mother.
What are Miracles? With the possibility of virgin birth being wide open, it does not remain to be all that impossible and unnatural. Where is the need as to search for a supernatural explanation of Jesus’ birth, or to even go beyond that to the farthest extreme of believing in the birth of a literal ‘Son’ of God through human birth? When various phe- nomena, as described above, are observed as a fact of nature, why as is it hard to believe that the birth of Jesus Christ was a hidden natural phenomenon, brought about by a special design of God? as Something happened in Mary which gave that child a miraculous birth, without a man having touched her. It is the Ahmadiyya Muslim belief that this is exactly what happened. Our case is unshakeable because no scientist can dismiss it as nonsensical or opposed to the known laws of nature. Miracles are not seen in Islam as unnatural occurrences, but as natural phenomena that are concealed from human knowledge at a certain period of time. Otherwise, there would be many ques- tions raised against the wisdom of God. If God created the laws of nature Himself, He should have made some provisions whereby without breaking them, He could bring about desired solutions to a problem. Not all laws are known to man. There are categories of laws working as if in different tiers and on separate planes. Sometimes they are known to man only on one plane and man’s sight is not === PDF-Seite 36 === 8 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
able to penetrate beyond. As time goes on, man’s knowledge increases and so does the penetration of man’s sight and his capacity to observe such laws as had hitherto remained unper- ceived. As science progresses, new discoveries throw more light on such laws which seem to work in groups. So, their function and interaction with other laws is better understood. Those things that appeared to be miracles in the early ages are no longer considered so. Miracles are so, only in relation to man’s knowledge in a specific period of time. When a special exercise of God’s power is displayed, apparently a law is broken. But it is not so; actually a hidden law was already there and only came into operation through God’s command. The people of that time could not have understood that law, nor had they any control over it. For example, the force of magnetism was not known to man a few thousand years ago. If somebody had accidentally discovered it and had contrived a device by which he could levitate things without any apparent cause discernible to the naked eye then, to the wonderment of everyone, he could exclaim, ‘Lo! A miracle has happened.’ Today, such tricks are considered commonplace and trivial. The knowledge of man is limited whereas that of God is unlimited. If a law comes into operation that is beyond the scope of man’s knowledge, it looks like a miracle. But looking retrospectively at such instances with the hindsight of knowledge gained since then, we can dismiss all such so-called breaches of the laws of nature as merely natural phe- nomena which were not fully comprehended by the man of that age. This is why I said that there had to be a natural phenomenon as responsible for the single parent birth of Jesus Christ which was === PDF-Seite 37 === The Sonship of Jesus Christ 9
unknown to man of that period; it is not fully known to man even today. But science is advancing in that direction and more is being understood. A time may therefore come, when no one will as be able to claim that the birth of Jesus was unnatural. They would have to agree that it was a natural but rare occurrence, so rare that it seldom occurs in human experience.
Jesus, the Son of God? There are many other problems with the Christian understanding as of Jesus , his nature and his relationship with God. From further critical and analytical study of Christian doctrine what emerges is that there is a ‘Son of God’ who possesses the characteristics of a perfect man and also those of a perfect God. However, remember that even according to Christian doctrine the Father is not exactly like the ‘Son’. The Father God is a perfect God and not a perfect man, while the ‘Son’ is both a perfect man and a perfect god. In that case these are two separate personalities with different charac- teristics. It should be realised that these characteristics are not transfer- able. There are characters in certain substances which are transfer- able. For instance, water can become snow and also vapour, without causing a change in the substance or composition of water. But the differences in the characteristics of God and as Christ , where certain characteristics are added to one of them, are irreconcilable. It is not possible for one of them to go through this transformation and still remain indistinguishable from the === PDF-Seite 38 === 10 Christianity – A Journey from Facts to Fiction
other. It, again, is a problem, and a serious one for that matter, as whether Jesus Christ was a perfect god as well as a perfect man. If he possessed both characteristics simultaneously, then he was surely different from the Father who was neither a perfect man nor even an imperfect one. What type of relationship was this? Was the ‘Son’ greater than the ‘Father’? If this additional character did not make the ‘Son’ greater, then it must have been a defect. In that case a defective ‘Son God’ is not only against the claims of Christianity, but is also against the universal understanding of God. How, therefore, could anyone comprehend the paradoxical tenet of Christianity which would have us believe that ‘One in Three’ and ‘Three in One’ are the same thing, with no difference whatsoever? This can only happen when the very foundation of a belief is raised, not on a factual basis, but merely on myth. as Yet another problem to be resolved is this: if Jesus became the as ‘Son of God’ as a consequence of his birth from Mary’s womb, then what was his position before that? If he was eternally the as ‘Son’, without having been born of Mary , why was it necessary to give birth to him in a human form? If it was necessary, then the quality of Son was not eternal; it only became an added character- istic after he was given birth to, and, it disappeared when he rejected the body and returned to heaven. So there are many complexities rising out of a belief which common sense rejects. I invite you again to accept a far more respectable and realistic as scenario: that of believing the birth of Jesus Christ to be a special creation brought about by God, who activated some hidden laws as of nature. Jesus was the metaphorical son of God, loved by Him in a special way, but a human being all the same. His ‘Son’ status === PDF-Seite 39 === The Sonship of Jesus Christ 11
was attached to his character some three hundred years later, to allow his legend to live on—this will be discussed later. The nature of the nuptial relationship between God the Father and as Mary is an issue which one loathes to discuss barefaced. Yet in an as attempt to understand the intermediary role of Mary between the ‘Father’ and the ‘Son’ this is an unavoidable evil. Perhaps it is the same question which bothered Nietzsche so much that he gave vent to his pent up dissatisfaction, at last, in the following words:
Not long after Zarathustra had freed himself from the sorcerer, however, he again saw someone sitting beside the path he was going: a tall, dark man with a pale, haggard face; this man greatly vexed him. ‘Alas,’ he said to his heart, ‘there sits disguised affliction, he seems to be of the priestly sort: what do they want in my kingdom?’... ‘Whoever you may be, traveller’, he said, ‘help one who has gone astray, an old man who may come to harm here!’