Abuses Hurled by the Christian Writers

Claims of the Promised Messiah (as)

A famous Christian writer, William Muir, in his book Life of Mahomet, p. 46–47, criticizes the Holy Prophetsa with regards to his developing claim of Prophethood. He says:

[ 14 ]

Khutba_11.book Page 15 Thursday, July 12, 2007 12:06 AM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

Thus we may suppose was Mahomet by degrees led on to believe that God had called him to preach refor- mation to his countrymen.… The commission per- vaded throughout the future course of Mahomet, and mingled with every action. He was now the servant, the prophet, the vicegerent of God; and however much the resulting sphere of action might expand in ever widening circles, the principle on which the commission rested was from the commencement absolute and complete. (Life of Mahomet, p. 46–47)

If we substitute the name of William Muir with the names of the authors of the White Paper, and then change nothing else in the above paragraph, the theme is the identical. William Muir argues that the absence of a controlling authority, and internal strifes between people in Mecca enabled Muhammadsa to claim to be a Prophet. He then goes on to allege that: Two to three months after his arrival in Medîna, Mahomet saw the Jews keeping the great Fast of the Atonement; and he readily adopted it for his own people. Prior to this, fasting does not appear to have been a prescribed ordinance of Islam. It was estab- lished at a period when the great object of Mahomet was to bring his religion into harmony with the Jew- ish rites and ceremonies. (Life of Mahomet, p. 200)

As for diseases, the same allegations of epilepsy and hysteria were made against the exalted being for whom the

[ 15 ]

Khutba_11.book Page 16 Thursday, July 12, 2007 12:06 AM

Claims of the Promised Messiahas

heavens and the earth was created. The same person who is the chief of all of humanity, higher in status than all Prophets, was abused. This is that person whom God has stated that he could have illuminated the whole world even if he had not receive any revelation. About this person, William Muir makes accusations of mental confusion and fear of darkness. May the curse of Allah be upon the willful liars. I cannot read the whole passage. I refer people who have the capac- ity to read such allegations to Reverend C.G. Pfander’s book Mizan Ul Haq, p. 459–463, wherein he makes very distasteful remarks about the supposed illnesses of the Holy Prophetsa. He bases these allegations on ahadith and asserts that this is what is written by Muslim holy men and jurists. He repeats reference after reference of baseless stories, or draws misleading conclusions from events which he fails to understand. Of course, there is no reality to these claims. I cannot stand to read such writing. Perhaps our opponents may wish to read this, since they seem to have learned their style of allegations by reading such writings.

10 of 10 left today