About the Author
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 4
It was in my early youth when I was about twenty years of age, that I happened to go to Dalhousie for a change. A well-known Christian missionary, Mr. Ferguson, by name, was on a visit there. He had converted hundreds of people to Christianity. He was engaged in distributing literature there and spreading the Christian mission work. Some Muslims who had a zeal for the faith approached their Maulvis, urging them to counter-act this threat. Nevertheless, they pleaded their inability. At last, they called on me and asked me to take it up with the missionary as they felt they had lost their face. I was very young then and was not so advanced in theological studies, but I readily responded to their call. Accordingly, a party of us started towards the Christian missionary’s residence. On arrival there, I told him that I wanted to put a few questions to him. We were seated around a table at that time, and a pencil was lying there before me. I put it to him that in case he wanted to pick up the pencil what would people think of him, if he called to his help me and his companions and his waiter and his cook and his neighbours and when all the people of the locality had collected, required of them to lift the pencil from the table and hand it over to him? He asked me back what I was driving at. I wanted to know if it would be considered rational on his part and how people would react to it. He answered back that they would take him for a lunatic. Then addressing him, I asked whether God, the Father, had, independently, the power to create the world. He said He had. Next, I asked him if God, the Son, had independently the power to create the world. He affirmed that he had. Then I asked him if God, the Holy Ghost, had likewise similar power to create the universe. He said he too had.
Then I observed that all this looked very much like the lifting of the pencil from the table in the manner mentioned above. When all three had equal power and could do the creative work equally well, they were wasting their time; as they could very well bring the world into being individually. Then I asked him if he could tell me of a particular job which, God the Father could do but God the Son could not, which again God the Son could, but God the Holy Ghost could not, or God the Holy Ghost could, but God the Father could not, or, God the Son, could, but God the Father could not. He said there was no such undertaking as either one of them could and the other one could not do. Then I asked him what all this fuss meant: that if two gods sat idle, it really became great predicament that they could do a job but were wasting their time, and if all three jointly undertook a business, while each one could do it equally well, it looked something mad. He lost his equanimity and remarked that vicarious atonement constituted the basis of Christianity and that one understood Trinity only after he believed in Christianity. I observed that his theory led from one hypothesis to another in that one could not believe until one understood Trinity, and one could not understand Trinity until one believed and that as such, all logic rejected this as an impossible thing. He begged to be excused and wanted the talk to be confined only to the theory of vicarious atonement.
The theory of vicarious atonement is deeply connected with the Trinity. If the former is proved to be untenable, the latter falls to the ground. Since this belief is polytheistic, the Divine attribute of knowledge has, therefore, been stressed explicitly in this context. The Promised Messiah (peace be on him) has in his books, discussed threadbare the point that if one is endowed with perfect knowledge of a thing, one could certainly make it. If, for instance, a man knows that a house can be built by laying bricks together in a certain order, he can be enabled to build one therewith. Or, if one knew that by mixing earth with water and pouring the mixture in moulds, one could make mudbricks, and by burning the same in the fire-kiln, one could make clay-bricks, he would be able so to make bricks. Similarly, if one could know how super-soil was made, one would be able to make it. In short, the art of creation is dependent on knowledge. When a man attains perfect knowledge of the composition and constitution of a thing, he can make it. If one knows how to make a watch, he can manufacture one. One who attains perfect knowledge of the functions of organs, he would become a doctor. Briefly speaking, the perfect knowledge of a thing equips with the power of perfect creation. Furthermore, when a person has perfect knowledge, it means, he is also capable of perfect creation and perfect design and that he dispenses with the need of another designer.
In the abbreviation, the letter ک stands for the attribute, the Sufficer; Allah has hinted thereby that He is Sufficient as much for the creation of men as for their management and equally for planning for their existence, without there being an occasion, or cause or need of a vicarious atonement, or a son or holy ghost, as help.
It can be argued here that notwithstanding our belief that God is the Sufficer, we believe in the angels and in the physical universe, in wind and lightning and matter. The answer is that we accord these things a secondary position which is far different from that of equality, the secondary position being at par with the status of servants. God has made a particular order to keep Himself invisible to the view. If belief in Him was to be productive of results and we were to be rewarded for it, it was imperative that the person of Allah, the Almighty, should remain behind a veil. For, belief in visible objects can earn one no approbation. We see the sun; we believe in its existence, but we are not rewarded on that account. Similarly, the mountains are visible objects and we do believe that they are very much there, but we get no reward for that.
Since the creation of man called for perfection of spirituality which depends on divine approbation and keenness of spiritual insight, therefore, trials and ordeals should naturally interpose as necessary adjuncts to refinement and evolutionary progress, for, trials and ordeals are experienced, usually, in the attainment of difficult objectives. It was, therefore, essential that the person of God should remain hidden, otherwise the scheme laid down for the spiritual progress of mankind would have failed. And with an invisible God, it was necessary to have some physical as well as spiritual means of seeking to conform to His will. The spiritual agencies consist of the pure constitution of human nature besides angels. The material means comprise matter and the law of dynamics. Therefore, the existence of angels or matter gives no cause for criticism. Christianity ascribes equal partners to God. We have only servants and subordinate agents. The latter is a necessary means so that the person of Allah, the Excellent, remains inaccessibly high and immeasurably distant and that a wall intervenes between God and His servants, which, only one who strives in His way, may be able to breakthrough. In short, the one who knows of the source of life and has knowledge of the extant is alone the All-Powerful Being. In like manner, the righteousness of God is a guarantee of the salvation of the devotee.
If a man cannot be saved without vicarious atonement, then all the previous Prophets turn out to be liars, and the God Who sent them shares the epithet. For, Adam came and required men to believe in him. Noah came and asked people to accept his word. The story of Adam does not occur in detail in the Bible. In the case of Noah, the Bible goes into detail and says that Noah invited people to believe in Him. If man could not be saved without vicarious atonement, both Noah and the person who deputed him were liars. Then came Abraham making the same offer to men to accept the truths he had brought. The story of Abraham, however, is as sketchy in the Bible as that of Adam. But, following this, the story of Moses is recorded in great detail. The Bible says that he put before the people his teachings, warning them of God’s wrath if they rejected it and assuring them of salvation if they observed it. He did not say that he had been propounding to them his teachings, which were, nevertheless, impracticable, like the Christians who assert that the law was far from practicable. Moses did not say aught but that if they observed the law, they could rest assured of salvation. Therefore, if the Christian doctrine is true and salvation is beyond the range of possibility, then Moses was an impostor who cheated people by telling them that if they obeyed him, they would be saved. But if he was a Prophet as the Bible claims, in that case, God Himself cannot escape the implication that He was equally a liar, Who sent him with that message. By the same token, all the Prophets who came after Moses turn out to be liars, for, each of them claimed that observance of his teachings ensured salvation. It is said that David (peace be on him) proclaimed:
“And the law is the truth.’’
(Psalms 119:142)
If, however, Shariat (law) is impracticable, since the Christians rate it as a curse. One must agree that truth is impracticable and that, on the contrary, only falsehood is practicable. It must be further admitted that truth cannot lead to salvation, but falsehood does. To revert to the point, if we agree that man cannot conform to the law and cannot follow the Prophets, then the conclusion that the entire chain of Prophets is a big lie becomes inescapable. But if He is the Truthful God, then there is no denying the fact that salvation is a possibility, for, all the Prophets of God announced that salvation could be the lot of men, if they cared to obey them.
Besides, the Arabic word صــدق (truth) also carries a sense of perpetuity in addition to veracity. In fact, it also applies to what is everlasting. “The truthfulness of Allah, the Almighty,” which implies that His person and His law are everlasting. In other words, the word, as well as the act of God, are everlasting, and they can be so only if man also was immortal. If mankind is not worthy of salvation and must perish, then we are led to the conclusion that neither the word of God nor His actions are immortal.
Perfect truth, therefore, evidently must find its reflection, for, truth, as aforesaid, implies perpetuation which is inadmissible without a corresponding eternal grace inhering in Divine attributes. The Bible also supports our view. It says,
“God created man in His own image.”