(Jonah 1:4)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?
This is the story of Jonah to whom Jesus has made an allusion. Its perusal shows that when Prophet Jonah received the word of God to go forth to preach to his people, it occurred to him that when a prophet preaches to his people, he also receives a share of fore-warnings of fearsome happenings but God the Almighty out of compassion for His creatures, deals by them mercifully and as a result the prophets lose face; therefore instead of proceeding on his mission to his people, he made a bid to escape to another country in order to save himself from the humiliation he feared he would suffer at the hands of his people. But God the Almighty had decreed that he should go forth to the inhabitants of Nineveh and deliver to them the message of the Lord. Accordingly, He planned it so that he was cast in the sea and then He commanded a big fish to swallow him up which gorged him alive. According to the statement of the Bible, he prayed to the Lord when he was in the belly of the fish. Since only a living person can pray and not a dead corpse, it is clear that he entered the belly of the fish alive and so long as he was in it, he remained alive. Then the fish disgorged him as Allah wished that it should, on the land and not in the sea. He was then commissioned by the Almighty Lord to go to preach to the people of Nineveh. He went there accordingly and was successful in his mission. It is evident from this miracle that:
(1) Prophet Jonah entered the belly of the fish
alive.
(2) He remained three days and nights alive in it.
(3) He came out of it alive.
(4) His preaching term started after he came
out of the fish’s belly.
He did not first apprise the people of his mission to reform them; possibly he told a few persons but the masses in general had no inkling of it. He fled from there wishing to escape to some other country; but after the incident of the fish, Allah the Mighty forced him back to his own country where He commanded him to preach. He accordingly undertook preaching and the people believed in him. After fully grasping the import of this miracle, no one can deny the implication that this incident applies to the Messiah only when
(1) He enters the sepulchre alive
(2) Remains therein alive
(3) Comes out of it alive and
(4) Gets a lease of successful preaching term after
his escape from the tomb.
These are the four features deducible from the incident of Prophet Jonah. If the Christian version of Christ’s death on the Cross is correct, then these four points are falsified altogether, namely (1) If the Messiah gave up ghost on the Cross and did not enter the grave alive and (2) if the Messiah remained in the tomb dead three days and nights but that he remained in hell he can have no resemblance with the Prophet Jonah, for, the Prophet Jonah remained three days and nights alive in the fish’s belly and he was at peace with God the Almighty as he kept praying to Him. On the contrary, firstly the Messiah entered the tomb dead and then he remained in hell. In other words he was alienated from God the Almighty. (3) Again, if the Messiah rose from the grave alive, a second time, he is, even in this respect, far short of being the like of the Prophet Jonah. For, the Prophet Jonah did not rise a second time from the fish’s belly; he was alive first, he remaind alive also in the fish’s belly and alive did he come out of it. (4)If after his rising from the grave, the mission of Jesus came to an end as Christianity says that he remained in hell for three days to atone for the sins of mankind and after rising from the dead, he ascended to heaven to sit on the throne of his father, he has not the least resemblance with the Prophet Jonah. For, the miracle of Jonah was that Allah the Mighty granted him a successful term of preaching after he came out of the fish’s belly. And as a matter of fact the real miracle that God Almighty showed the world was this—“Look, Jonah turned down My word and would not become
My messenger; he feared that he would be humiliated and that people would not accept him. Accordingly he made off but We put him in the fish’s belly and kept him alive in it and later We ordered the fish and it disgorged him on land. We then made him go to Nineveh and he preached and was successful in his mission.”
The Almighty God thus made it manifest that “whomso He raises as His Prophet, howsoever weak he may think himself to be and howsoever humble the people of the world may regard him to be, Allah the Mighty, has the power to make His message flourish through him and to make him popular with the people. This is the true sign of Jonah that was shown to the inhabitants of Nineveh. But if the Christian version of the Messiah’s incident is accepted, he cannot be proved to have the slightest resemblance with Jonah. For, the true miracle of the Prophet Jonah was that he was granted a term of preaching and people witnessed that the self-same person who had made off fearing on account of his own weakness, proved a successful reformer and people on accepting him made an intrinsic change. As against this, when the Prophet Jonah entered the belly of the fish, the inhabitants of Nineveh did not see him. When he was alive in the fish’s belly they did not see him then either: nor did they see him when he came alive out of the fish’s belly. There lay then between him and the inhabitants of Nineveh a distance of some five to seven hundred miles, nay, even as much as a thousand miles. Wherefore could they see that Jonas entered the fish’s belly, or, that he had remained alive in it or had come out of it alive? Of all these things not one could the people of Nineveh see. The Ninevites saw him not when he entered the fish’s belly; nor did they see him when he stayed alive in its belly and nor did they see him when the fish disgorged him. But when Jonah went back to the people of Nineveh and they saw that it was the same person that had taken to flight in fear, and God the Almighty had forced him back and granted him success where he thought there were no prospects, this became a mighty sign of the dominion and power of the Almighty God which the people of Nineveh witnessed. The Messiah had similarly claimed about himself:
“For as Jonas was a sign unto the Ninevites,
so shall also the Son of man be to this
generation.” (Luke 11:30)
Now the question is what did the people of Nineveh witness?
The Ninevites did not see Jonah enter the belly of the fish; they did not see him living in it, nor did they see him coming out of it. All they saw was that a man received the revelation commanding him to go forth and call the people of Nineveh to God. But he lacked the courage to deliver to them the message of the Almighty and fled away, seeking to escape to another country. But, after he had suffered many hardships and disasters, God forced him back to the Ninevites , and they were compelled to accept his message. Hence if the Ninevites witnessed any sign, this was the only sign. There is no doubt about it that his going into the belly of the fish was a sign, so was his staying alive in the fish’s belly a sign and likewise was his coming alive out of it a sign. But all these signs are such as were not witnessed by the inhabitants of Nineveh. The only sign they saw was that a misgiving occurred in the heart of the Prophet Jonah and he went away from there, not wishing to deliver the message of prophethood to the people. But from hundreds of miles and through different kinds of hardships, God brought him back to his people again and fulfilled the mission for which He had raised Jonah. People rejected him and offered opposition to him. But in the end, they had to bow down to him. This was the sign that the Ninevites witnessed. There can, therefore, be a sign also of the Messiah only when he enters the tomb alive, remains in the tomb alive and comes out of the tomb alive. But all this the enemy will have not witnessed. This will be followed by the latter part of the sign: that he should preach to the lost sheep of Israel, settled at that time near about Nineveh and in Iran, Afghanistan and Kashmir and bring them into the fold of his faith and thus succeed in the mission God had entrusted to him. If it come about, the Messiah’s similarity to the Prophet Jonah will have been established and the sign he promised to show become manifest to the world. But if it did not happen that way, the sign of Jonah would not have come to pass.
In short, as the Prophet Jonah preached to his people after he came out of the fish’s belly and succeeded in his mission, in like manner should the Messiah have, after his exit from the tomb, preached to the Israelites and brought them to the right path. If he has not accomplished that, the sign of Jonah has not been implemented and it cannot be said that he showed the sign that the Prophet Jonah showed to his people. The Ninevites saw with their own eyes that the man who had run away from their midst, because he thought himself to be inadequate, and evaded the call to deliver the message of his Lord, came back to them and they were compelled to believe in him. But if the Messiah fades out after the incident of the Cross, how does his similarity to Jonah come about and where is the sign that the people witnessed as had the Ninevites? In other words the sign that the Messiah had to show as did the Prophet Jonah, which purported to demonstrate how the Almighty God gets His purpose served through such people as regard themselves to be inadequate, he did not show, while the part that the Prophet Jonah did not show to the people, the Messiah did. Jonah entered the belly of the fish without the Ninevites having seen this sign. Jonah remained alive in the fish’s belly but the people of Nineveh did not witness this sign either. Jonah came out of the fish’s belly alive; again the inhabitants of Nineveh did not see this miracle. After this when Allah brought Jonah back to Nineveh, he demonstrated to the people his work, to wit, that nobody can run away from the Almighty God—he had run away but had been forced by God back to them. This was the sign the people saw and whoever reflects even in a superficial manner, would be compelled to glorify God and treat it as a wondrous miracle.
Jonah did not consider himself to be worthy of the office of God’s prophet and in panic he made off to another country. But God taking hold of him brought him back to the Ninevites and when he delivered the message, the very Ninevites about whom he had entertained misapprehension believed in him and bowed down to him. As one ponders this miracle, one is forced to believe in the powers of Allah and to marvel how great is Allah the Lord of Might, He grants honour to whomso He pleases and gives to whomso He pleases. But if Jonah had told the people that he had remained alive in the fish’s belly or had come out of it alive, they would have refused to believe, treating the claim as a lie and a falsehood. The Messiah’s likeness, therefore, to Prophet Jonah could have been complete only when he would enter the tomb alive, stay in the tomb alive and come out of it alive, like Prophet Jonah and after the incident of the Cross successfully preach to a part of the Israelites. But the New Testament informs us that the Messiah showed to the people the sign that Jonah did not, and did not show them the sign that Jonah did. The New Testament says that the Messiah showed to the people the sign of entering the tomb, of staying therein and of coming out of it. The Bible says that the sign that Jonah showed the Ninevites was that after coming out of the fish’s belly, he preached and the inhabitants of Nineveh had to believe in him. The New Testament, however, says that the Messiah simply vanished away after he rose from the tomb and did no preaching. Evidently, therefore, the sign that Jonah showed and which was a substantial sign, the Messiah did not show, but the one he did not show, the Messiah did.
Again, the Old Testament says that Jonah entered the fish’s belly alive, stayed there alive and came out of it alive but the Christians aver that the Messiah entered the grave while dead, remained therein three days dead and rose again from it alive. If this version of the Christians is true, then the Messiah failed to show the sign of the Prophet Jonah; but if he showed the sign of the Prophet Jonah and did not die on the Cross, nor did he stay dead in the tomb, the theory of redemption is finished. For, atonement stands proved only when it is accepted that the Messiah bore the sins of people by hanging on the Cross. If, however, he remained alive, it is clearly established that he offered no sacrifice and when no sacrifice was offered, redemption is automatically ruled out.
In short, the incident of the Cross which Christians hold forth goes wholly against the signs shown by Jonah and promised by Messiah to his people.
Now we would examine whether the purport of the prophecy relating to the Prophet Jonas deduced by us has been touched upon in any prophecy of the Messiah. When we carefully ponder over the New Testament, we are wonderstruck to find the Messiah saying the same thing. Further, even the Prophets who preceded the Messiah and foretold of his advent, have hinted at it. For instance Isaiah says:
“The Lord God which gathered the outcast
of Israel saith, Yet will I gather others to
him, beside those that are gathered unto
Here the Prophet Isaiah foretells of a time when Lord God would again gather the lost sheep of Israel and will send a prophet around whom they will all gather. The prophecy of Isaiah here relates to the Messiah, for, there has been none besides him, to claim that he had come to gather the lost sheep of Israel. These lost sheep are the ten tribes of Israel which the then Iraq State destroyed in a campaign in Nebuchadnezzar’s period. A deplorable feature of this invasion was that the Jews were divided amongst themselves at the time and engaged in internecine hostilities. The Jews had then two States—one was called Israel and the other was known as Jew, the former held Jerusalem and the latter had a separate centre. When the Iraq State launched an attack on the Jewish State to destroy it, one section of the Jews joined it out of hostility to the other group. The result was that due to the mutual animosities of Jews, the Iraqi State overran the territory and destroyed all the holy places of the Jews; even the synagogue of Jerusalem which was built by Solomon (peace be on him) was desecrated through pig slaughter in its precincts, and many other acts of carnage were committed.