(Jonah 1:4)
Did Jesus Redeem Mankind?, Part 3
In the same way, the Messiah was commanded to go to a foreign land lying in the east and deliver the message there. Again, it appears from the story of Jonah that God had forced him to go to that country; he had in fact fled from there wishing not to go to Nineveh. God, however, forced him back to Nineveh. Similarly, the prophecy indicated that God will force the Messiah out of his country to a foreign land and deliver the message through him to the lost sheep of the Jews. And further that when he would go there, people would receive him well and accept his claim.
What befell the Prophet Jonah was this: he entered the fish’s belly, he remained in the belly of the fish for three nights and days and then the fish disgorged him on land and when he recovered, Allah commanded him to go forth to Nineveh and deliver to the Ninevites His message. Thus it dawned on him that he could not run away from the situation, howsoever, he might try, that he had to abide by the Will of God. Accordingly, he returned and communicated to the Ninevites the Divine message. At first they offered a mild opposition but, as soon as signs of Divine punishment became evident, they believed.
In short, when we compare these references with the references about the prophecy relating to the Prophet Jonah, we find that the sign of the Prophet Jonah which the Messiah had to show, did not consist only in the Messiah entering the tomb alive, staying in the tomb alive and rising from the tomb alive; it indicated yet another fact—the fourth and by far the most important, that like the Prophet Jonah, the Messiah will go to the lost tribes of Israel and communicate to them the word of God and that they will hear him and that it will be a sign which the lost sheep of Israel will witness as did the people of Nineveh. At a glance it will be apparent that the Messiah had to go through similar happenings. Messiah was born in Palestine. His tongue was Hebrew. His mother was also in Palestine and so was his so-called father as also the other sons of this father and his cousins. Besides, they had there all the people of their tribe, their native customs, their own culture and tradition. All these things have very great importance and one is deeply attached to these. But the country to which he was being deputed was a foreign land and the Messiah had no connection with it. There was a vast divergence between the language of Afghanistan and that of Palestine. The two had nothing in common. The Israelites had through inter-mingling adopted the customs and traditions and culture of the Buddhists and other people and reconverting them was no ordinary job. Besides, the way to Afghanistan and Kashmir from Palestine was difficult and full of hazards. There existed no facilities and on top of it the long journey of two and a half thousand miles was a hard task. Therefore the Messiah was afraid of setting out to Afghanistan and Kashmir as was the Prophet Jonah afraid of going to Nineveh. For, by going over there, he to give up his tongue, leave his people and his dear and near ones.
An easy course was that the Messiah should live among his own people and staying back in Palestine continue preaching to the Jews. But as the Prophet Jonah sought to evade and God put pressure on him through creating circumstances that forced him back to Nineveh and made him realize that there was no sense in running away from the Almighty God and that he must: therefore, betake himself to wherever the Lord wanted him to go; similarly in the case of Messiah, God created conditions which led to a general opposition against him, so much so, that he was involved in a case, had to appear before a court, and the court finally sentenced him to be hanged and he had to suffer hanging on the Cross. It is another thing that God Almighty saved him, in accordance with His prophecy, as he had saved Jonah; as when the Prophet Jonah was cast into the sea, He appointed a fish which swallowed him up, and he remained in the fish’s belly alive three nights and days and came out of the belly of the fish alive and when he saw this, his faith gained fresh vigour and he marvelled how great was the might of the Lord and how wondrously He managed to protect His servants. In like manner was the Messiah taken off the Cross alive, stayed in the tomb alive and came out of it alive, with the result that his faith was reinvigorated and he knew that God had marvellous powers. But as he came out of the tomb, under the impact of circumstances, he was forced to hit out for the country where God the Almighty wanted him to go. For, one who was condemned to death by the court but was saved, could not stay in the land as he would be liable to be hanged again, if apprehended. In short, the Almighty God created such conditions as compelled him to quit for Kashmir and Afghanistan, in the manner of the Prophet Jonah.
There is no doubt about it that a Prophet is never afraid of death in the cause of God, but, all the same, a Prophet cannot reconcile himself to an idle life. He is born for work and loves work. He is a machine which operates constantly. The Messiah could not therefore agree to spend the rest of his days in hiding hither and thither. While, therefore, this incident further strengthened his faith, at the same time, it helped to speed up his departure from Palestine for the east like the Prophet Jonah, to preach the word of God.
The Messiah’s account of these events given to the ten tribes and his narration of the circumstances leading to his visit to them must have immensely strengthened their faith and evoked in them, sentiments of thankfulness to God. Histories of Kashmir show that the Messiah’s wounds were still green yet when he entered Kashmir. It appears that the surgeons of the time were not so good. It is said that when the Prince Prophet reached Kashmir, he had wounds on his hands and feet which the surgeons took long to treat. When the Messiah narrated to them the circumstances through which Allah forced him out of Palestine to Kashmir, telling them he would have been liable to be re-hanged, had he stayed back, how greatly must those people have marvelled with pride at their own good fortune. There is not the least doubt about it that God the Almighty had the power to save him yet again. Had they put him again to the Cross, He would have saved him again but it would have meant repeated hanging on the Cross and getting off it because of which the Messiah would not have been able to do any preaching. In short, the narration of these events must have enhanced greatly the love of God in their hearts as they would wonder how He forced a prophet to visit their land so that they might be guided aright. Some, however, must have offered opposition; for, opposition is inevitable.
But history confirms that those people soon became devoted to the Messiah readily believing him to be a prophet.
In brief, under the circumstances, God compelled him to go there. If we do not accept this explanation, leave alone the theory of redemption, the Messiah loses even the status of a truthful and true man. For, he clearly says that he would enter the tomb alive, and stay in the tomb alive and come out of the tomb alive and that after all these events his journey to the lost tribes was unavoidable, so that his likeness to the Prophet Jonah is established. Now when did Jonah go to the inhabitants of Nineveh to preach? The answer is, when he came out of the fish’s belly. Similarly, the real period of work for the Messiah came when he rose from the grave. If it had not so happened and the Messiah had not preached after rising from the tomb and had not gathered the lost sheep, he would be proved to be a liar and so also Isaiah and other Prophets who foretold that he would gather together the lost sheep of Israel. (We seek refuge with God against such belief).
These incidents conclusively establish that it was not ordained that the Messiah should die on the Cross or offer atonement. The theory of redemption makes it impossible to accept the Messiah as a righteous person;
for thus, his greatest prophecy turns out to be false and so also the word that was revealed to Isaiah and what was foretold by some other prophets. It is established therefore, that Jesus did not offer the sacrifice which is ascribed to him by those who subscribe to the theory of vicarious atonement; nor did he make any atonement.
Now we shall examine whether the incident that took place confirms the fact that Jesus would enter the tomb alive, would stay in the tomb alive and come out of the tomb alive or it establishes the fact that he entered the tomb dead, remained in the tomb dead and rose out of it resurrected. I would mention here some basic facts pertaining to this end which make it clear that the Messiah did not die on the Cross.
The foremost point is the fact that the officer before whom the Messiah was hauled up was a well-wisher of Jesus and a friend of some of his followers. Of the Messiah’s followers who had not yet become his disciples openly but believed in him at heart, one was Joseph Arimathea. According to the New Testament, being a respectable and wealthy person among the Jews, he was a friend of Pilate and when Messiah appeared before Pilate, he tried quite a number of times that the Messiah may be let off on one ground or the other. Of the devices he resorted to in this behalf, one was this: It was on Friday when the Messiah appeared before him and the Sabbath Day, the holy festival day of Jews, fell on the morrow. The same day was a special holiday when the Roman State used to set at liberty a prisoner to please the Jews so that they should feel that the State held religion in esteem and thought particularly well of their religion. Considering that on account of this festival, one or the other prisoner must be set free, Pilate tried to set the Messiah free. But the Jews refused to agree to the proposal and would rather get a thief to be set at liberty insisting that the Messiah should not be freed (Matthew 27:21-22). There occur many disparities in the New Testament in this regard and there is no use going into these at the moment. In any case, they would not let the Messiah be set at liberty. While Pilate was yet pursuing his endeavours to release the Messiah on his personal initiative, a messenger came to his court saying that he had been sent by his wife. As Pilate rose to hear him, the messenger told him that his wife had sent him with the word that she had no sleep last night as the angel warned her again and again that this man was innocent and should not be persecuted, otherwise they would die. When Pilate heard this, he made a further attempt to persuade the Jews to agree that the Messiah should be released. But they were adamant.
Instead, they threatened to write to the Emperor that Pilate had set at liberty a man who claimed to be king, which meant that Pilate was also a rebel. When he heard this he was frightened and sent for water. Jews were given to talking in parables. Pilate washed his hands in the presence of them all, and said that he would not bear the responsibility of sin and was innocent of the blood of “this just person,” and that the sin of it, if any would lie on them and on their children. Thereupon they said with one voice “His blood be on us and on our children” (Matthew 27:24). Then Pilate delivered Messiah to them to be crucified.
When they took the Messiah to the site of the Cross, according to the New Testament, the sixth hour had set in, which in terms of the time of that period would be between 3 and 4. There were also two other convicts who were to be crucified. It is clear that it means a lot of difference between hanging one convict and hanging three; it would take a short time to hang one but three would definitely take much longer. There is still another point which neither Muslims in general understand nor do the Christians due to lack of knowledge of their religion. In those days a wooden frame was affixed to serve as Cross. It was shaped like (+). When it was decided to hang a person on the Cross, he was made to stand pat against this wood-piece and his out stretched aims were held in place with wooden pieces. Then nails were driven in the fleshy parts of the arms and legs of the convict. He would thus hang there thirsty and hungry till death.