First Propter Quid Argument for the Need of Revelation

Early Writings

We have no such absolute law whereby we can truly safeguard ourselves from error. This is why even the philosophers who formulated rules of logic and debate, and constructed philosophical arguments have always made errors, and have left behind hundreds of absurd notions, flawed philosophies and meaningless discussions to remind the world of their ignorance. This proves that it is utterly impossible for a person who depends solely upon their own investigations to reach the essence of every truth and arrive at a reliable opinion about a thing without making any error in judgment. I say this because I have never seen or heard of, or found in any book of history the name of any such person who was perfectly free from every error and mistake regarding all their conclusions and judgments. In light of inductive reasoning, we arrive at the correct and truthful conclusion that the existence of such people who have reached the pinnacle of truth in their investigations—by contemplating and reflecting only on the laws of nature and reconciling their own judgement with the phenomenon of the universe—such that it is impossible to find any error in their understanding, is itself an impossibility, as observation has always demonstrated.

Nonetheless, the only way you could argue my assertion, which you have the right to challenge, would be for you to put forth an argument against the inductive argument I have made and thus disprove my conclusion. In other words, the correct approach in presenting a response is that if, in your view, my inductive reasoning is flawed, you ought to show me, so as to refute my reasoning, an example of a perfect individual from among the learned, intellectuals and whose every opinion, conclusion and judgment cannot be faulted in anyway, and whose tongue and pen are free from even a single error, so that I too am able to see whether such a person is truly faultless, or whether the actual state of affairs is something else. If such a person emerges to be truly free from fault, you will surely be proven true in your claim, and I will be considered wrong in my claim. Otherwise, it is quite evident that if man is unable to protect himself from error merely by his own knowledge and judgement and if we accept that God too (Who is Gracious and Merciful and free of every error and fault, and is the Knower of the truth of every matter) does not help His servants through His true revelation, then how can we, who are His helpless servants, emerge from the veils of ignorance and misguidance, and gain deliverance from the calamities of doubt and misunderstanding? Hence, based on my firm and considered view, I would invite you to accept that the wisdom, mercy and compassion of the Omnipotent Lord demands from time to time, whenever He deems it necessary to raise such people who receive revelation from God so that they are enlightened in respect of true beliefs and morals. The inherent capability of understanding divine teaching ought to be deemed a bestowal of God, so that the souls of the people, which have been created to receive true guidance do not remain deprived of the blessings ordained for them.

Sincerely,

The Author, Ghulam Ahmad (may Allah forgive him)

21 May 1879

10 von 10 heute frei