[A Reply from the Promised Messiah(as)]

Early Writings

Respected Pundit Sahib!

I have received your kind letter. I was eagerly waiting for your response. I must write with the deepest disappointment that you were made to suffer such inconvenience, yet I have not received a proper response either. My point, in nutshell, was that since the means of our salvation (which even you accept is something for which we must search) is based on our discovering the right set of beliefs, the right morals and good deeds, which are absolutely free of all forms of falsehood. Therefore, we cannot achieve salvation until our religious knowledge and insight of the divine law has been acquired through such a secure source as is completely free from all forms of corruption and error.

In response to this, if you had followed the right path and kept in view the etiquettes of debate (in the case that you reject my arguments) you ought to have formulated your rebuttal, as rationality dictates, in accordance with one of the three principles that follow.

Firstly, you could have outright refused to acknowledge that there was any such thing as salvation and declared the means for its attainment to be non-existent and unobtainable, and thus considered its need to be merely as useless a pursuit as one’s desire to have four eyes.

Secondly, you could have said that you believed in salvation but did not believe that the doctrine and deeds required for salvation must be free from all forms of falsehood and corruption, and thus you considered such means as are absolutely false, or ones which are a muddle of both truth and falsehood, sufficient to attain salvation.

Thirdly, you could have declared salvation to be dependent upon absolute truth (which is perfectly free of every kind of falsehood) and then claimed that rationality alone is the means to attain absolute truth and sufficient for salvation. In this case, to prove your claim, it would have been necessary for you to show an example of such a wise man who was absolutely free of error and you would have been required to present his writings containing such knowledge stemming from his own ideologies and rationality, and thus prove my inductive argument (which is the third kind of argument among the three categories of argumentation which we have presented in our previous paper) to be invalid. By this method, if you had successfully disproved my inductive argument, and if I had failed to point out any flaw in the said piece of writing, certainly you would have largely clinched the argument against me. Regrettably, however, you did no such thing. You did say that there were thousands of writers but you did not mention the name of even one of them, nor did you present any examples of their writings on logical or theoretical matters.

Now, from this discussion, what I mean to convey to you is that if you still hold any reservations regarding the reality of revelation, you should choose one of the above-mentioned three options so that it is clear what course you have chosen and then provide evidence to support your view. The reason for this is that while I have proved that there is a ‘need’ for revelation, you must, as per the rules of debate, prove my point to be invalid. And, as I have said, you only have three options, out of which you are bound to choose one. It should also be clear to your good self that my only desire is for the truth to be manifested through this debate. I am not predisposed to prejudice or egotism as is the way of the foolish. It is with a sense of heartfelt affection and friendship that I engage in this discussion with you, and I hope for a response from you with the same sentiments.

Sincerely,

The Author, Ghulam Ahmad (may Allah forgive him)

10 von 10 heute frei