[A Reply from the Pundit]

Early Writings

Respected Mirza Sahib,

I am in receipt of the reply you wrote to me in the fifth month of the current year. I am extremely saddened to know that you have not been satisfied by what I had written in my reply to you regarding the nature of revelation. My regret grows even more when I see that you have not put forward any clear and logical reason for your dissatisfaction with what I had written to you. This shows that in reading and understanding my response you have not reflected and contemplated fully.

Then, another interesting aspect in your reply is that you do not appear consistent in your own point of view. In the first place, you sought to prove the ‘need’ for revelation by arguing that since the human intellect is unable to find truth on its own, and since it is prone to error in its investigations; therefore, it is necessary for man to receive revelation from God. When I proved that your argument regarding this ‘need’ was based on a mere assumption, and when I clearly demonstrated that divine wisdom does not acknowledge this ‘need’ to be a genuine one, you turned away from your initial stance and adopted a new one. Instead of either acknowledging the soundness of what I had written to you or then presenting a reasonable argument if you had any objection, you confused the discussion with the issue of salvation. In other words, you put aside the actual subject of debate, which is the nature of revelation, and have begun to discuss the issue of salvation. Having done so, you have now made a new claim and have begun a completely new discussion. And then the real marvel is that towards the end of your letter you have written:

If you still hold any reservations regarding the reality of revelation, you should choose one of the above-mentioned three options so that it is clear what course you have chosen and then provide evidence to support your view. The reason for

this is that while I have proved that there is a ‘need’ for revelation, you must, as per the rules of debate, prove my point to be invalid.

For me, this was like suffering one misfortune on the heels of another. I have already once refuted the argument you presented for the ‘need’ of revelation and proven that the very foundation on which you have built your so-called edifice of revelation is baseless. Regretfully, as you have developed over a long period of time the habit of supporting this point of view, this prevents you from reaching the truth in spite of your claim that your ‘only desire is for the truth to be manifested through this debate.’ I would like to remind you that the search for truth cannot be credible unless one develops the ability of reconsidering one’s own deeply ingrained opinions and welcoming new findings. The young child of a Christian sees the water of the River Ganges to be nothing more than the water of an ordinary river and does not consider it capable of purging people of their sins. However, as far as the belief of a conservative Hindu is concerned, he believes that even one dip into that water purges man of all his sins. On the other hand, a Christian considers the belief in Trinity to be an established truth while a Muslim or Brahmu Samajist deems this belief to be absolutely absurd. Even if a person holds a debate with a Hindu or a Christian and proves his beliefs to be absurd (which is not at all difficult to do), the latter will not acknowledge the absurdity of his beliefs, so much so that when he finds himself unable to argue, he would simply say: ‘Although I am unable to provide a valid refutation, I hold this belief nonetheless and consider it to be true from the core of my heart.’ In fact, this voice from his heart reflects the same old habit of man which philosophers refer to as ‘second nature’.

Hence, the same is the case with your belief regarding revelation. Since you have by way of habit, held this belief for such a long period of time, it has become so firmly ingrained in your heart and has become so creditable in your view that you consider even the strongest of arguments which I have presented against your view to be unimpressive. Furthermore, when you find your argument to be weak in some respect, you seek to change the course of the debate and jump to another subject. It is impossible to arrive at a conclusion in this manner. Neither has anyone succeeded in doing so in the past, and neither will they be able to do so in the future.

You have asked me to provide you the names of such writers whose books or investigations are free from error. You have said this despite the fact that academics in the fields of knowledge to which I had made reference are convinced of the authenticity of their writings. Have you not studied books on mathematics? Have you not gone through books on physics? Of course, you may not have gone through more modern literature that is still to be translated from English into Persian or Arabic, but you would perhaps know about the writings of some Greeks such as Euclid’s principles of geometry; and it is obvious that no scholar of the world (whether a believer in revelation or not and whether a believer in God or an atheist) has ever denied the authenticity and soundness of these principles. If, you believe them to be flawed, you may please point out their flaws to me.

Also, you have written that in my response to you, I have not observed the proper rules of debate. To this I consider it sufficient to say that when all of our writings are published in the newspaper Baradar-e-Hind, the fair-minded will judge for themselves whether or not your statement is true or not. If you write back to me agreeing to the aforesaid proposal, I can begin publishing our exchange in the aforesaid newspaper from next month.

Sincerely,

Shiv Narayan Agnihotri

Lahore

10 von 10 heute frei