An Important Response to the Query Published in the Aftab Newspaper on 16 May 1878
Early Writings
by Munshi Gardiyal Sahib, the Middle School Teacher from Chiniot
Having expressed his thoughts on the issue of the eternity of souls, Munshi Gardiyal has emphatically demanded that I too write my response to his views. I stated previously, at the end of my last article, that I would not write on this subject again unless it becomes necessary. However, respected Munshi Sahib has very keenly requested me to remove his misunderstandings and I too consider this to be a worthy endeavour of scholarship which will also prove to be beneficial for the general public. Therefore, as an exception, I agree to briefly put forth my response to his views as it is necessary and required, and will serve to benefit the general public.
The first idea held by Munshi Sahib which he considers to be an argument for the eternity of souls is that God is the complete cause of all His creation and that the whole of creation is an effect of the cause, and since no effect can fail to follow in the presence of its complete cause, this proves that the souls which exist at present are as eternal as the being of God and were, therefore, not created by Him.
My answer is that this argument of Munshi Sahib is absolutely false and does not benefit him in any respect. On the contrary, instead of proving his claim to be true, it disproves his argument. The reason for this is that the Holy and Merciful being of God is undoubtedly Infinite and Boundless; the complete cause of the creation of souls is the very same Infinite Being Who is God Almighty. Now, in view of the argument presented by respected Munshi Sahib, if we suppose that the non-occurrence of an effect in the presence of its complete cause is an impossibility, this would necessitate that existent souls (which he says have been present since the very beginning) are also countless and infinite in their existence. For if the complete cause is limitless, the effect too should not be confined to any limits. Otherwise, we would have to accept that a perfect cause produced a deficient effect. However, I have already proven, with as many as fourteen arguments, that the souls in existence are not limitless, and Swami Dayanand Sahib has been compelled to concede this point as well, as he was unable to refute my arguments. How can an argument put forth in favour of the infinite nature of souls, once proven false, be valid in proving that souls are eternal?
In addition to this, our observation of Allah’s actions also testifies against this notion. The reason for this is that our daily experience and observation of the law of nature has categorically established that the actions of God which are performed by Him at a given time and moment, and which continue to be manifested on different occasions—at times we witness sunshine and at times we find the sky to be overcast; there is night and day; at times we suffer distress and at times we are happy; there was a time when we were non-existent and now we exist and live on the earth, and after this, a time is to come when we will cease to exist; it is evident, therefore, that all this occurs by the will of God and all these phenomena and temporary conditions come forth by the will of the very same Complete Cause. Hence, if we suppose, as per the statement of the honourable teacher, that their must be a complete conformity between the Creator and the creation, this would necessitate that all such occurrences that transpire in the world from time to time should remain in the same state with no change whatsoever. However, any sensible person knows that the world continues to undergo change and that the elements of all such events cannot come together in the same moment and that no creation remains in the same form forever. This proves that even the arguments presented by the honourable teacher are untenable and absolutely false.
Now, let us return to the second part of this discussion. It is suggested that when one reflects over whether there is any robust argumentation for the eternity of souls one finds that such strong and categorical argumentation exists that man is unable to deny this fact. I would like to state that I have already written on this subject at length in my previous essay; there is no need for repetition here.
However, a novel argument which categorically disproves the belief in the eternity of souls and in fact, manifestly exposes its absurdity is mentioned herewith in this exposition as well. The premise of this argument is that the Arya Samaj themselves acknowledge as an established tenet of their faith that the time which has elapsed since the present souls came into existence is no more than four and a quarter billion years—irrespective of the total number of these present souls, they begin to exist and then cease to exist within this period. The Arya Samaj also states that the permanent abode of all these souls is this very earth, which is a known and finite sphere, and that all souls are taught and imparted knowledge in this very school, as it were; in fact, all those souls which have so far been conferred the position of salvation passed through this small institute of learning. Hence, these admissions evidently show that the souls that exist today are not eternal; rather on account of their being confined to a particular time and age they are bound to a limited lifespan.
Now, when this is the case, worthy readers should reflect as to how the statement of the honourable teacher, whereby he suggests that souls are eternal in their existence, can carry any weight. For when I have proved that souls are not infinite and rather fixed in number, we surely are bound to admit that their transmigration and salvation began at a particular time in history, i.e. at the time when one particular soul was born or granted salvation. Hence, when we believe that transmigration and salvation began at a specific time, we also must believe that the souls are not eternal. The reason being that the term eternal is applied to a thing that has no beginning. Hence, it stands proven that the souls are not eternal. Quod erat demonstrandum.
In response to this, some have sought to respond (so perhaps you too will continue to call the souls eternal) by saying: it is possible that initially the souls were suspended in an idle state for a limitless period in time and then Parameshvara thought it inappropriate for the souls to remain idle, so from the very day when Parameshvara arrived at this realisation, He turned the souls into human beings and different animals such as donkeys and horses, and subjected them to the pain of birth and death, and in this way the time-bound phenomenon of salvation came into existence. Such people hold that if the transmigration of souls and the attainment of salvation began in this manner, this would not invalidate their belief in the eternity of souls.
Glory be to God! What an astonishing answer! It appears that the followers of the Arya Samaj have made great progress in hatching the profoundest mischiefs hence the reason they have begun to put forth such remarkable answers. Sir, might I ask that if all the souls, before they began to transmigrate and obtain salvation, were living in pain and misery or living in comfort and peace? If they were suffering in a state of misery, which action on their part resulted in that condition? And, if they lived in comfort, what good deed of theirs created such a condition for them? Moreover, if, prior to having gained salvation, they were already living in peace, then to desire salvation again is but to seek that which they already possessed. So, by this account one must accept that the souls were once non-existent. Now, someone may argue that although they were already living in peace, they were subjected to the cycle of transmigration so that they might obtain cognisance of God Almighty. The obvious answer to this would be that when they could not obtain cognisance of God despite having lived with Him and spending time in His presence—as His eternal partners—for an immeasurable period of time, what treasure of divine insight would they have possibly amassed once transformed into worms and insects? In fact, to punish someone without having been guilty of a crime; to subject them to various kinds of afflictions and make them undergo the miseries of life and death is against the very teachings of the Arya Samaj. In fact, it is this very principle in light of which they believe that the cycle of transmigration eventually comes to an end. Furthermore, the concept of souls remaining in an idle state is contrary to the belief of the Arya Samaj. How then could the souls have been in an idle state for an eternity? Hence, the belief that souls are eternal is absolutely false.
Then, the honourable teacher has written that the continuous birth of souls is an impossibility, rather all the souls that can come into existence are already present since the very beginning, and that now God’s power of creation is has ceased to function any further. This is a statement which, we would describe in other words as……