The Second Coming of the Messiah
Elucidation of Objectives
THE S ECOND C OMING OF THE M ESSIAH Muslims and Christians both believe, albeit with some difference, that the Messiah son of Mary was physically raised to the heavens and that he will descend from the skies at some later time. I have already disproved this notion in the first part of this book. I have also pointed out that the 'Descent' or the 'Coming' does not mean the coming of the Messiah son of Mary; that actually it is a figure of speech signifying the coming of someone resembling the son of Mary; and that, in accordance with Divine intimation and revelation, it is the present writer—my own humble self—to whom it applies. I am only too well aware that as soon as this view of mine, which is based on clear and definite revelation, is made public, many a hostile pen shall come alive and a public outcry full of horror and rejection will ensue. At first, I thought I should hold my peace for the time being and forego engaging in any detailed discussion, so that I could answer the objections as and when they were raised, and could lay down my reasons and arguments at fuller length, in view of the critics' perceptions. On second thought, however, this idea does not seem to be without blemish. I now feel that my silence is more likely to be misconstrued, not only by the Muslim laity, but also by some of the clergy, who, on account of their warped thinking—which is the unavoidable consequence of their decadent condition—and their being influenced by an old hackneyed belief, will rise up in protest and reject my claim out of hand. And, as party to their own cherished opinion, they will be eager at all costs to establish its bona fides. Indeed, it would be hard and rather impossible for them to retreat from a publicly declared position. It is common experience that once a Mullah has expressed his opinion publicly and pronounced it to be final, he finds it worse than death to retract it. Hence, before they should get entangled in the meshes of hidebound obduracy by confronting me, I decided that, as an act of pity, I should try on my own to bring home to them the truth with such clear and cogent reasoning as should adequately satisfy any intelligent and fair-minded seeker after truth. Later on, the occasion may arise when I am required to elaborate further for the sake of those who happen to be naïve and of lesser intellect and are unaware of the metaphors, terminology, and subtle and abstruse exegeses common to the revealed scriptures. They rather fall under the
Let it be clear, that according to the Bible, our own books of Ahadith and other records, only two Prophets are supposed to have physically ascended to the heavens, namely Elijah, also known as Elias, and Messiah son of Mary, also known as ‘Isa or Jesus. Concerning both these Prophets some books of the Old and New Testament say that they were raised to the heavens and shall return to the earth sometime in the latter days, and that people will actually witness their descent from the skies. The Ahadith of the Holy Prophet (sa) also contain words to the same effect. Concerning Elias, whose Biblical name is Elijah, the Gospels positively declare that the prophecy of his descent from the skies has been fulfilled with the birth of Yahya or John, son of Zechariah. The Messiah son of Mary declares in unmistakable terms: “He is indeed the Elijah who was expected to come. Acknowledge him if you will.”
Through this arbitration by no less a person than a Prophet of God, the case of Elijah, his ascension to the skies and subsequent descent has been effectively settled and the manner and meaning of the 'Second Coming' clearly determined. This, therefore, is the doctrine, consistent with the Gospels, to which Christians should unanimously subscribe, that Elijah, whose descent was awaited, did, in the time of the Messiah, return from the heavens in the person of John who was born to Zechariah, with the temperament and qualities of Elijah. The Jews, however, continue to await Elijah's descent. They believe that he will physically descend from the skies and land on the minarets of Baitul Muqaddas, where the Jews will assemble and lower him down to the ground with the help of ladders or some such device. When you confront the Jews with Jesus Christ's interpretation of the descent of Elijah, they fly into a rage and start abusing not only Jesus Christ but also John the Baptist, and condemn as heresy the solemn declaration of a Prophet of God. In any case, the real connotation of the term 'descent from the skies' has been determined by the verdict of Jesus Christ himself, and the dispute about Elijah's descent has been finally settled. The manner of his descent has also been conclusively established. But, concerning the descent of the Messiah, it is still claimed with great fervour that he will descend from the skies, clad in rich royal robes, accompanied by angels. The two camps have, however, failed to agree on the place in which he will actually touch down. Will it be Holy Mecca, a church in London or some royal Russian Cathedral? Were the Christians not waylaid by their holding fast to their hackneyed opinions, they could have realized, more readily than the Muslims, that the descent of the Messiah should take place in exact conformity with what has already been spelled out in such clear terms by Jesus Christ himself, for it is impossible for two similar scenarios to admit of contradictory interpretations. This is a point which deserves serious consideration by all seriousminded people. If Jesus Christ's interpretation regarding the descent of Elijah from the skies is true, the question arises that the case of the Messiah being parallel to that of Elijah, why not draw the same conclusion, particularly when a Prophet of God has already lifted the veil off the face of this close secret? And, what is more, this interpretation is also in exact consonance with the laws of nature. Why then digress from the right and straight
is woven with a thread of silver or gold), zari (a silk fabric embroided with threads of gold), lahi (a fabric made of coarse or raw (wild) silk); or some sort of ordinary cotton, like nain-sukh (a fine fabric of cotton, English name nainsook (OED)), tan-zaib (a fabric softer and finer than nainsook), ingchikan (embroided muslin dyed in vermilion), gulshan (a cotton fabric with floral embroidery), muslin, jali (another kind of cotton fabric embroided with flowers), khasah (a kind of fine cotton cloth of light weight), duria (a fine streaked fabric of cotton), or charkhana (a fabric with square holes in its texture like that of a lettice). The Muslims and Christians are equally silent as to who will have done the weaving and the tailoring in the heavens. [Author] The translations in brackets are by the translator. [Publisher]
path and opt for one that is both crooked and objectionable? There is no reason to adopt an alternative interpretation. Can the conscience of honest and enlightened people, fully supported by Jesus' own verdict, accept any other meaning of the term 'Descent'? Incidently, about ten years ago, some Christians published a prophecy in the British press to the effect that the Messiah's descent would take place within three years of its publication. Now that God has identified the Messiah who was to come, it is incumbent upon the Christians to be the first and foremost to accept him lest they are guilty of defying their own prophecy.
Christians also believe that Jesus entered Paradise after he was raised to the heavens. In Luke's Gospel, Jesus, reassures one of the thieves saying: "Assuredly, I say to you, today you will be with me in Paradise." Christians also unanimously believe that no one, however sinful, will ever leave Paradise, having once entered it. The Muslims hold exactly identical view. Says Allah in the Holy Qur’an:
that is, those who enter Paradise shall never be made to leave it. True, there is no pointed mention in the Holy Qur’an of Jesus entering Paradise, but his death is mentioned in three different verses. And it is also true that the death of holy people and their entry into paradise is one and the same thing, because, according to the verses,
they enter Paradise straight away, without any let or hindrance. Muslims and Christians are, therefore, under obligation to consider seriously if it is possible for a man of God like Jesus to enter Paradise and then be driven out? Wouldn’t it be contrary to the Divine promise contained in all the Holy Scriptures with such frequency and detail, that those who enter Paradise will
(See Surah Al-e-‘Imran) [Author] “But since Thou didst cause me to die, Thou hast been the Watcher over them.” (5:118).
“There is no sect or group from among the people of the Book but will have faith in him (Jesus Christ) before his death” (4:160), i.e. from all the tribes of Bani Isra’il there would be those who would accept him as the true Messiah before his death, as it happened. [Translator]
“When Allah said: O Jesus, I will cause thee to die and exalt thee in my presence.” (3:56) [Translator]
never be made to leave it. Would the breach of such a solemn and positive commitment not shatter the credibility of all Divine promises? Of a certainty, such a belief will not only unfairly place Jesus in an awkward position, but indulging in such futile exercise will also be disrespectful and derogatory to God Himself. The matter deserves a very keen and close study. Belief in a lesser doctrine of this kind, which can otherwise easily be explained as a metaphor, amounts to a virtual murder of cardinal religious verities. It is in fact a doctrine which is full of faults and is heir to a host of complex problems and difficulties. It provides the opponents with occasion for ridicule. As I have already mentioned elsewhere, the disbelievers of Mecca also wanted the Holy Prophet (sa) to perform this miracle, namely, that he should ascend to the skies before their very eyes and then come down. The reply they received was:
This means that it is against the wisdom and glory of God Almighty to show such palpably obvious miracles in this world of trials, and thus undermine the wisdom and value of belief in the unseen. Now I say to you: How is it possible that something, being against the divine law, should not be permissible for the Holy Propht (sa) —who is the best of the Prophets— and be permissible for the Messiah. It amounts, to rank disrespect that we, with respect to the Holy Prophet (sa) , regard a merit as impossible for him to have, and about the same merit we believe that it is possible for the Messiah to have it. Can a true believer be guilty of such insolence? Absolutely not! It may also be pointed out that this sort of thinking, which has become endemic among the Muslims for quite some time, is conspicuous by its absence in the entire range of basic Islamic literature. The truth of the matter is that it is the failure to understand Ahadith that has led to this mistaken belief, to which quite a few unwarranted details have been appended. To invest it with plausibility, some baseless decorative material has been added in utter disregard of the facts which would otherwise have shown the way to truth. In this regard, the most clear and crucial Hadith of the Holy Prophet (sa) is the one recorded by Hadrat Muhammad Isma‘il Bukhari in his collection the Sahih Bukhari. Hadrat Abu Huraira (ra) reports that the Holy Prophet (sa) said:
i.e., (the Holy Prophet says:) how will it fare with you when the son of Mary descends among you? Who will be this son of Mary? Indeed, he will be none other than your own Imam, your Mentor, who will be born among you. In this Hadith, the Holy Prophet (sa) has unequivocally stated that you should never be led into imagining that the Messiah son of Mary will himself descend in person. Actually, the name son of Mary has been used metaphorically; in reality he will be your Imam from among your own people and, in character and temperament, he will be a living similitude of the son of Mary. People who believe in old tales misinterpret this Hadith to mean that when the Messiah descends from the skies he will have resigned his office as Prophet and disowned the Gospels. He will accept Islam, practise the teachings of the Holy Qur’an, observe the five daily prayers and call himself a Muslim. But they fail to explain why he should suffer such relegation. In short, our Muslim brethren unilaterally admit that at the time of his Second Coming, the Son of Mary will be a Muslim by faith, will proclaim himself as one, and will have completely forgotten about his earlier station as a Prophet. It is an insurmountable difficulty indeed into which our brethren have managed to land themselves by treating a metaphor as literal truth. This is why they had to resort to proposing the removal of a Prophet from his Prophetic station. There was, however, an easy way out of this self-made difficulty, if only they had accepted the simple and straightforward meaning of the sacred words of the Holy Prophet (sa) already spelled out by Jesus Christ in the context of the second coming of Elijah. In that case they would neither have to expel from Paradise the soul of Messiah, nor would they be constrained to divest a pious Prophet of his Prophethood, nor would they be guilty of showing disrespect for the honour and glory of the Holy Prophet (sa) , while believing that they are respectful to him. Nor will they have to pronounce what amounts to a veritable abrogation of injunctions in the Holy Qur’an.