Retaliatory Fatwa Based on Qur’an and Sunnah
Extreme Lies and Verdicts of Disbelief Against the Founder of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama’at
In Lecture Ludhiana, when the Promised Messiahas issued a fatwa in response to the fatawa against him, he remained within the limits imposed by the Holy Qur’an, taking due
[ 17 ]
khutba14.book Page 18 Monday, April 27, 2009 8:26 PM
Extreme Lies and Verdicts of Disbelief Against the Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama‘at
care of all the requirements of the teachings of the Holy Qur’an. He said: Muslims of today are no doubt included among those who say: , 11 but they are not those who can 12 claim: . (Lecture Ludhiana, p. 47, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol. 20, p. 295)
By saying this, he expressed all the subtleties of the situa- tion in very few words. In the matter of Muslims, he did not permit the Ahmadis to go beyond the point the Holy Prophet sa adopted under divine command. Allah the Almighty had commanded the Holy Prophetsa: ‘O Prophet, even you are not permitted to deny them the right to call themselves Muslims; indeed, you are not even permitted, on your own, to deny their claim of being believer or to make any such demands.’ The light that the history and actions of the Holy Prophetsa throw upon the subject in respect of these limits and conditions is that nobody has the right to label someone else as non-Muslim [contrary to his own claim]. Accordingly, the Promised Messiahas has never used the term non-Muslim for his opponents. How- ever, as regards the issue of declaring a Muslim as disbe- liever, he said:
11. We have entered the fold of Islam. 12. We have believed.
[ 18 ]
khutba14.book Page 19 Monday, April 27, 2009 8:26 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
This is a matter of Sharia. Anybody who calls a believer as kafir [disbeliever] becomes a kafir himself. Therefore, since 200 maulavis declared me a kafir, and applied the fatwa [edict] of kufr [disbelieve] upon me, the natural consequence—fully supported by their own fatawa is—that someone who addresses a believer as kafir becomes a kafir, and similarly, someone who declares a kafir as believer also becomes a kafir. (Haqiqatul-Wahi, p. 164, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol. 22. p. 168)
That is to say, the response of the Promised Messiahas was the natural consequence of the situation caused by the opponents; he was left with no other choice. The Promised Messiahas also referred to the hadith that I mentioned ear- lier. He says:
The Holy Prophet s a says: Whenever a Muslim declares another Muslim as kafir, such caller himself becomes a disbeliever. (Sunano Abi Dawud, Kitab-us- Sunnah, p. 484, published in 1983, Lahore, Pakistan)
Again, in an answer to a question that was posed to him, the Promised Messiahas said: We do not declare anyone, who adheres to the kali- mah [creed of Islam], outside the pale of Islam.
[ 19 ]
khutba14.book Page 20 Monday, April 27, 2009 8:26 PM
Extreme Lies and Verdicts of Disbelief Against the Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama‘at
See how consistent and uncontradictory his position is. It is based on the Holy Qur’an and on a saying of the Holy Prophetsa. Within those limits, he issues his fatwa with due respect: We do not declare anyone who adheres to the kali- mah outside the pale of Islam, unless he renders him- self a kafir [disbeliever] by calling us kafir. You may not be aware that when I announced that I am a com- missioned one, Muhammad Husain Maulavi Abu Sa‘id prepared a fatwa with great effort in which he stated: This man is a kafir [disbeliever], dajjal [Anti- Christ], and misguided. His funeral prayer shall not be offered. Anyone who says Assalamo ‘Alaikum13 to them, or shakes hands, or calls them Muslim, would also be a kafir. Now listen! It is an agreed doctrine that anyone who calls a mo’min [believer] a kafir, becomes a kafir himself. How can we go against this agreed doctrine. Tell us, what option is left for us under these circum- stances. I have never been the one to issue such a fatwa first. But when we call them kuffar [disbeliev- ers] now, it is because of their own fatawa of kufr. Someone had asked me for a prayer-duel, and I told him: It is not lawful for one Muslim to engage in a prayer-duel against another Muslim. But he answered that he considered me a staunch disbeliever.
13. Peace be unto you. An Islamic salutation.
[ 20 ]
khutba14.book Page 21 Monday, April 27, 2009 8:26 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
Ponder over it. Despite the plethora of fatawa containing such filthy language that they cannot even be considered religious fatawa, the response of the Promised Messiahas showed remarkable patience and fortitude. He told the questioner that it was not lawful to engage in prayer-duel with a Muslim. The man who had initiated the question to the Promised Messiahas said: Let them call you kafir if they wish. But what is the harm if you do not call them a kafir.
Please note that although the Promised Messiah as had explained fully that they were suffering from the conse- quences of their own fatawa, yet the questioner kept repeating his point, that even though the others have issued such declarations ‘what is the harm if you do not call them a kafir.’ The Promised Messiahas replied: We certainly do not call anybody a kafir if he does not call us a kafir. But as far those who have called us kafir, if we do not consider him kafir we would be going against the hadith and the agreed doctrine; this we cannot do. (Malfuzat, vol. 10, p. 376–377)