What do Shia Think About Their Opponents?
Extreme Lies and Verdicts of Disbelief Against the Founder of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama’at
It might be considered that perhaps the Shia would be more courteous. So let us take a look at the fatwa issued by the Shias about the Sunnis. It is written: The righteous sect of Shia does not consider it legitimate that a Shia woman accepting the twelve
[ 31 ]
khutba14.book Page 32 Monday, April 27, 2009 8:26 PM
Extreme Lies and Verdicts of Disbelief Against the Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama‘at
A’immah [leaders] should marry a non-Shia because we do not consider them believers. Any Muslim who does not subscribe to the Shia doctrine of twelve A’immah is not a mo’min [believer], but he is a Muslim.
So far, the statement is reasonable and needs to be appreci- ated. Now we can say why they call themselves believer— they have based this upon the Holy Qur’an and have, in this respect, used better sense and judgment that the Sunni ulemas. Their statement that if anyone calls himself Muslim, let him do so, is very sensible. But what is the ver- dict if a Shia gets married to a non-Shia? ‘Allamah al-Ha‘iri was a great Shia scholar. His son writes: ...If such a nikah20 does take place, the nikah will be null and void and the children would be illegitimate according to Islamic Law. (Conclusive Verdict on the issue of Nikah between Shia and Sunni a.k.a An-Nazar, by Sayyed Muhammad Radi’ur Ridvi al-Qami Ibn ‘Allamah al-Ha‘iri, p. 2, printed at Steam Press Lahore)
Listen to another fatwa: Those who entertain doubts about the leaders of the innocent, you may marry their daughters, but do not give your daughters in marriage to them, because the wife adopts the manners of her husband. The hus-
20. The announcement of marriage in Islam.
[ 32 ]
khutba14.book Page 33 Monday, April 27, 2009 8:26 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
band does bring her by force and coercion to his faith. (Ibid,.)
These two fatawa use relatively more civilized language and do contain an element of rationality. It does not seem that someone is uttering profanities. There is some logic that is offered. But there is no fatwa issued by the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama‘at which directly or indirectly calls such marriages illegitimate or considers the relationships of wife and husband in such marriages to deserve the profanities which others have used.