Part
Fazl-e-Umar, Part 26
But Maulvi Muhammad Ali and Khawaja Kamal Uddin bubbled with suppressed rage. They took the pledge of allegiance only outwardly because they stood fully exposed.
Khawaja Kamal Uddin learnt a deep lesson from these two mistakes. After this greater reverse he called off the publicly exposed campaign altogether and devoted himself to a task comparable to running a tunnel under enemy lines to blow them up with dynamite.
Maulvi Muhammad Ali, however, with a more irritable temper and a sensitive skin that felt even the casual caress of the wind as a deliberate pinprick continued to clash with Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih [ra]. He could not forget an injury to his vanity however slight and knew not how to bide time as his friend did. In his capacity as secretary Majlis-i-Motamadeen Sadr Anjuman, he began to obstruct Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih [ra] in the affairs of the Community. The clash over Maulvi Hakeem Fazal Uddin’s house is only one example of his obstinate opposition to the wishes of the Khalifa.
Hakeem Fazal Uddin of Bhera, a close relation of Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih, had left a certain property in Bhera, which he had purchased very cheap from a Shia who had sold it under some temporary stress, as a legacy to the Sadr Anjuman by his will. The Anjuman decided to sell the property. When its original vendor came to know that the property was for sale, he wrote to the Khalifatul Masih, setting out the background of his sale of the property to Hakeem Fazal Uddin, and requested that the property may be sold to him on somewhat favourable terms. The Khalifatul Masih forwarded his request to the Sadr Anjuman and directed that it should be considered favourably. The response of the Anjuman was that the property would be put up to auction and its former owner could bid for it at the auction. They were not willing to extend a favour to him, which might occasion loss to the Anjuman. Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih [ra] conceived that this attitude not only lacked beneficence but was an affront to him, and he expressed his annoyance by minuting, “do as you please; I will not concern myself any further with the matter.”
When the question came up again in a meeting of the trustees of the Anjuman the Secretary reminded the trustees of their responsibility to God and enquired what should be done. Hadhrat Sahibzada Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad suggested that as Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih [ra] desired that some concession should be made to the former owner of the property, his wishes should be complied with. The Secretary, Maulvi Muhammad Ali, said that Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih had left the decision to them and read out his minute; whereupon Sahibzada Sahib pointed out that the minute was expressive of displeasure and not of permission and that they must comply with his wishes. A long discussion ensued during which Hadhrat Sahibzada Sahib was repeatedly urged to keep in mind his responsibility to God as a trustee, but he adhered to the view that he had expressed. Finally a majority took a decision contrary to his plea.
When the matter was reported to Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih [ra], he summoned the trustees who urged that the decision was taken after full discussion and consultation in which Hadhrat Sahibzada Sahib also participated. Hadhrat Sahibzada Sahib was sent for and when he arrived Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih enquired from him, “how is it Mian that my express directions are contravened?”
He replied, “Huzur, I do not recall any such default on my part.”
Huzur asked, “I had given a direction concerning the sale of Hakeem Fazal Uddin’s property in Bhera. Why has it been contravened?”
“Huzur, I was no party to the contravention. I had repeatedly urged compliance with your direction and had urged that your minute was expressive of displeasure and not of permission.” Hadhrat Sahibzada Sahib replied.
Huzur then turned to the others and said, “you say he is only a stripling, and yet he understood my minute aright and you failed to comprehend it.”
He admonished them at some length that obedience was a source of blessings, and they should mend their ways else they would disentitle themselves to Allah’s Grace.
Hakeem Fazal Uddin’s younger brother had been ready to pay a good price for the property, but when he learnt of the difference between Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih and the Anjuman, he drew back, and the Anjuman was left no choice but to comply with the wishes of Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih. The obdurate trustees submitted profuse apologies to Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih, but there was no change in their attitude and their propaganda against him went forward apace.
In September 1909 he announced that if there was no real improvement in their attitude by Eidul Fitr, they would be expelled from the Community. In this situation the leaders of the group submitted a sort of apology, but their attitude did not exhibit any real improvement. In his sermon on the occasion of Eidul Fitr, 19 October 1909, Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih admonished them once more at length.
Sometime in 1910, Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih [ra] resigned the presidency of the Sadr Anjuman on the grounds that the two offices were incompatible and directed that Sahibzada Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad, who was then only 21 years of age, should be president of the Anjuman. But by that time the question of supremacy between the Khalifa and the Anjuman had already come to the surface.
On Friday, 18 November 1910, Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih [ra] fell while riding a pony and received injuries of which one, on his right temple, was serious. For some days his condition was considered grave. While he was in this condition he said one day to Dr. Mirza Yaqub Beg, his principal physician: I am not afraid of death. If in your judgment my condition is serious, you may tell me so frankly, so that I may dictate certain directions. He assured him that he was in no danger, but that if his illness took a turn for the worse he himself would warn him. Yet as soon as he left him and joined his colleagues in Maulvi Muhammad Ali’s room, they put their heads together and despatched him to invite Sahibzada Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmud Ahmad sahib to join them. When he arrived, Khawaja Kamal Uddin explained the situation to him in the words, “We have troubled you to come over as we are told that Hadhrat Maulvi sahib is very ill and weak. Those of us who are from Lahore cannot afford to stay here longer, as we must return to Lahore. We desire that we should consult together and agree upon some plan that should obviate any risk of trouble in case of an emergency. We wish to assure you that none of us desires to be Khalifa, nor does Maulvi Muhammad Ali.”
On this Maulvi Muhammad Ali made an affirmation to that effect, and Khawaja Kamal Uddin proceeded, “We do not consider anyone beside you worthy of being
Khalifa, and we are all agreed that you should be Khalifa; but we request that no decision should be taken till after our arrival from Lahore, lest someone should take some step in a hurry that might cause trouble. Our arrival must be awaited.”