Part
Fazl-e-Umar, Part 35
This system of diarchy worked with varying degrees of success in different provinces. In the Punjab it worked with marked success due mainly to the ability, political skill and acumen of Mian Sir Fazl-i-Husain, who was a senior Minister in the Punjab.
The Government of India Act 1919 had provided that after the experience of the working of diarchy for ten years, a Royal Commission would be appointed to make recommendations with regard to the further constitutional advance of India. By 1926 political leadership in India had begun to agitate for the appointment of the Royal Commission, in response to which a Royal Commission was appointed under the chairmanship of Sir John (later Lord) Simon, in the autumn of 1927. The Commission was composed of members of the two Houses of Parliament. The Indian National Congress took great offence at the exclusion of Indians from the membership of the Commission and declared that it would not cooperate with the Commission. Thus the question of co-operation with the Commission became a matter of keen controversy in Indian political circles. In an effort to placate opposition to the Commission, it was announced that the Commission would invite a committee of the Central Indian Legislature to sit with it and to participate in its proceedings while the Commission examined witnesses, and when the Commission visited each province, a committee elected by the Provincial Legislature should also sit with it and participate in its meetings.
Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih II [ra] came out very strongly in support of the presentation of the Muslim case before the Commission, both at the provincial and central levels. He made out a strong case in favour of cooperation; lest the Muslim case should go by default. He did not profess to hope for any very favourable result from the report of the Commission, but was anxious that the Muslim case should be put clearly and forcibly before the Commission.
The very strong plea that Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih II [ra] made for cooperation had considerable influence in persuading Muslims to cooperate in setting up the Central and Provincial committees which were to work with the Commission.
Parallel with the activities of the Simon Commission, the All India Congress established a committee of ten members under the chairmanship of Pandit Moti Lal Nehru for the purpose of proposing a constitution for India which should have the support of all political parties and minorities, and which could be treated as the agreed demand of the whole of India. The committee was known as the Nehru Committee. Its report was published on 12 August 1928.
Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih II [ra] was much perturbed on reading the report as the proposals embodied in it, if they were accepted and given effect to in the future constitution of India, would place the Muslims of India completely at the mercy of the majority and their future in India would be put in serious jeopardy. He carried out a penetrating analysis of the report which was published in seven instalments in the Al-Fazl, and was subsequently issued in the form of a book entitled Muslim Rights and the Nehru Report.
At the beginning the reaction of an important section of Muslim leaders and the Muslim press was, on the whole, in favour of the Nehru Report. But the analysis of the Report by the Khalifatul Masih alerted Muslim leadership to the dangers to which the Muslims would be exposed in case those proposals were accepted. It was then freely acknowledged that the keen intellect and the political foresight of Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih II [ra] had served to rescue the Muslims of India from the serious hazard to which their fortunes had been exposed by the Nehru Report.
The report of the Simon Commission proved most disappointing and was universally condemned in India as a reactionary document. His Majesty’s Government was so impressed by the force of this reaction that it authorised the Governor General, Lord Irwin (later Lord Halifax) to announce on 31 October 1929 that Dominion status for India was the immediate objective of His Majesty’s Government and for the purpose of ascertaining Indian public opinion on the future constitution of India it proposed to invite the representatives of British India and of Indian states for consultation and advice to a Round Table Conference to be held in London. This announcement was followed on 12 May 1930 by the intimation that the Round Table Conference would be called together on or about 20 November 1930.
On this occasion also Hadhrat Khalifatul Masih II [ra] prepared and published a well-reasoned analysis of the report of the Simon Commission and put forward his suggestions with regard to the shape of the future constitution of India together with the safeguards that he considered essential to the interests of the Muslims. This booklet was published under the title The Solution of the Political Problem of India. It was given wide publicity both in India and in Britain and was much appreciated in thoughtful circles. It proved of great assistance to the Muslim representatives in the series of Round Table Conferences that were held in London in 1930,1931 and 1932.
Mr Muhammad Ali Jinnah was one of the Muslim representatives in the First and Second Round Table Conferences, but he was so disgusted with what he considered the lack of reality in the discussions of the Conferences that at the end of the Second Conference he decided to withdraw from politics and settle down in London with the intention of carrying on his practice as an advocate before the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. In his own words:
“I received the shock of my life at the meetings of the Round Table Conference.
In the face of danger the Hindu sentiment, the Hindu mind, the Hindu attitude
led me to the conclusion that there was no hope of unity. I felt very pessimistic
about my country. The position was most unfortunate... I began to feel that I
could neither help India, nor change the Hindu mentality; nor could I make the
Muslims realise their precarious position. I felt so disappointed and so depressed
that I decided to settle down in London. Not that I did not love India but I felt
so utterly helpless.”
The Hindus of the Congress and the Congress-led Muslim leaders were very jubilant over Mr Jinnah’s decision. The Muslims were now in the hold of those who believed in Gandhi as a potential prophet. A very prominent and powerful Muslim leader, the so called “Amir-e-Shari’at” Sayyad Ata Ullah Shah Bukhari, once declared, “I believe that Gandhi has in him the makings of a prophet.”