Volume – A Collection of Addresses to Women
Flowers for the Women Wearing Veils – Volume I, Part 28
The third disagreement concerns whether the Messenger has any right before Divine command?
These principles which lead to disagreement between the believers and non-believers of Khulafa are worth considering. a. Kharijites: They believe there was no Khilafat after the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) and instead, there should have been a Parliament. In their opinion, sin inevitably leads to hell and there will be no intercession. The basis for their beliefs is that it was an error, God forbid, to appoint a Khalifa after the [demise of the] Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa). Kharijites emerged during the time of Hazrat ‘Ali (ra) Karam Allah Wajhahu [May God exalt his face].
b. Motazili Sect: ‘Umar Bin Ameer founded this sect. He felt that human beings should use the intelligence granted them by God. They deny predestination and verbal revelation. c. Shia: They believe that an Imam is chosen from among the Ummah. That right belonged to the progeny of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa). After the Holy Prophet (sa), Hazrat ‘Ali (ra) and his children were due this right. This sect is particularly against the Khulafa, and God forbid, dubs them as thugs.
d. Naturee Sect: They wish to adapt Islam to European teachings. It is a grave error to modify God’s word to fit in with man’s knowledge. They apparently feel that there should be no distinction between God’s word and God’s work. However, when the two are assessed, they adapt to man’s word, rather than God’s word. This sect resembles the Motazili sect.
e. Ahl-e-Qur’ān (people of the Holy Qur’ān): They say the Messenger’s role is that of a postman and is of no significant importance. Thus, they reject the Hadith and look for their answers within the Holy Qur’ān. For this reason, some will determine the number of raka’at in Salāt to be two and some consider it three.
These are the key features of the aforementioned sects. I will not go into further detail concerning the validity of their arguments.
f. Ahmadiyyat - the true Islam: You must understand the following facts regarding Ahmadiyyat. Firstly, what was the Promised Messiah’s (as) claim? Did he or did he not claim prophethood? Also, could there be a prophet after the Messenger of Allah (sa)? Secondly, the question arises as to whether [his] claim is that of the Promised Messiah (as). Within the context of his claim, one then asks whether or not Jesus (as), son of Mary, died? If he did die, will the Messiah come from among his ummah? If he did not die, will the same Jesus (as), son of Mary, reappear? If he does reappear, how will it affect Hazrat Muhammad’s (sa) prophethood? Thirdly, what is the purpose of Ahmadiyyat? Was there a need for this movement and did the coming of Ahmadiyyat fulfill this need? The next issue worth pondering over is whether the Promised Messiah (as) was a Prophet or a Messenger. Did he nurture those very characteristics present in the prophets or messengers of God or did he meet the criteria of authenticity established for the prophets? What are those criteria?
Then there is the science of prophecy and the truth regarding prophecy. What is a prophecy? What type of prophecies did the other prophets present and what type did the Promised Messiah (as) present? We must then consider what type of relationship the Promised Messiah’s (as) Jama‘at had with previous sects. A recent point of contention is whether Khilafat will be established after Promised Messiah (as) or will a Parliament be established, as proposed by the Kharjites? Is the system in place for the future progress of Ahmadiyyat and what would be the individual responsibilities in this regard?
g. Sufism: Sufism is the eighth sect. Various people have defined Sufism in different ways. Some interpret it as the purification of the heart and others view it in other ways. The general opinion is that it concerns the purification of the heart: how to develop an attachment and grow near to Allah. Many great aulia [saints] have passed away. Secondly, there is the history of Sufism. When did it start, and who started it? What was their purpose and what did they do? What changes took place in Sufism in the past? Thirdly, there is the matter of the various sects of Sufism. This delves into whether there are differences among these sects and if so, what are their dissimilarities? Within this sect, different movements have formed, such as Qadri, Chishti, Suharwardi, and Naqshbandi. There is no fundamental difference, but they do differ in some respects. These differences revolve primarily around spiritual exercises. It appears they have absorbed the practices of their particular regions as well as using those remedies in medical healing which they witnessed in their own culture, just as doctors use their own methods. For example, some may prescribe Quinine for fever and others may use purgatives. In addition to their larger sects, there are several smaller ones. In Sufism, there is a sect called Mulaeheda which has abolished Shariah. They assert that they have reached their destination or something along those lines. They argue that if a person traveling in a boat has reached the riverbank, should he disembark or stay in the boat? They deceive people by claiming such absurdities. h. Malamati Sect: They too are corrupted. In reality, they are not immoral, but they believe hypocrisy or pretense leads to destruction. To counter this, they indulge in such activities, which will disparage their name. For example, they will go and sleep in a brothel house and offer Tahajjud prayers there. However, this way is fraught with danger. By adopting such behaviors, people are ruined. In believing that they are safeguarding their ego, they often end up entangled in various vices. The reality is that the outcome is often tragic.
8. Knowledge of Judgment: This deals with judgments over matters of dispute. For example, this covers the recording of witness’ statements, its cross examination, evaluating the witness’s testimony, and assessing the judge’s knowledge, familiarity [of the case], taqwa, and piety, etc. The second part to this institution is the history of justice. How was this institution developed and who were the notable Muslim judges from history?
9. Knowledge of the Rules of Inheritance: Though the rules of inheritance are included in Fiqh, it is also an independent science, as it affects politics and the nation.
10. Knowledge of Prayers and Remembrance of Allah: This outlines the timings and what to recite when engaged in prayers, as well as the remembrance of Allah.
11. Ilm Us Sair: This study covers the way of life of the companions of Prophets and other pious elders.
12. Moral Philosophy: This explains how to rid oneself of damaging habits and behaviors while adopting a good character and good manners. This [science] also reveals the causes behind moral diseases in human beings and why these are considered diseases.
13. Kalam [word or speech]: This study explains how to prove Islam’s superiority over other religions and how to establish the principles of Islam through argument. Within the kalam branch is the science of debate, which explains the failure of doctrines supported by those religions that oppose Islam. For example, highlighting the errors of the Christian belief in the Trinity and the notion that God inhabits a human form. Or, that Hindu beliefs are erroneous. This study of debate has two parts. One part is refuting the opposite party with arguments. The second deals with the principles of kalam which defines the criterion of truth and the ways in which to confront the opposition. The science of kalam is comprised of the above principles.
14. Islamic Politics: What is the system of government? What is the relationship between citizens and government? What are the rights of the government over citizens and vice versa? This is a vast subject. How should the government govern and what is its relationship with other governments.