Volume – A Collection of Addresses to Women
Flowers for the Women Wearing Veils – Volume I, Part 58
My thinking was that helping women in this way makes them cowardly. The only way women will successfully work, is if they work with strength and courage. It was the greatest lesson that Hazrat Khalifat-ul-Masih I, Hakeem Maulana Nur-ud-Din (ra) taught me when studying with him. Whenever I would ask him a question, he would say, “Mian [a term of endearment], carry on reading. When you go home, reflect upon this question for yourself.” Hence, he would not let me ask any questions. Hafiz Roshan Ali had a habit of asking questions and while he would answer them, he would not answer my questions. Sometimes, when I would ask a question, he would look at Hafiz Sahib displeasingly, saying, “You have developed in him a habit of asking questions as well.”
Women accuse us of not educating them and use this excuse for why they are behind in learning. I ask them, “Who educated us?” God did not collect all the knowledge [in the world] and reveal it to men, who in turn kept all of it for themselves and refused to share it with women. Men worked hard to learn, and they succeeded; you must make the effort to learn as well.
The fact of the matter is that although men did have advantages, women have even more advantages because men are willing to teach them. However, it is necessary for women to strive with courage. They should write articles and speeches. The worst that will happen is that a few people will laugh at their mistakes when reading their articles or listening to their speeches. However, the majority will appreciate their efforts and respect them. This is the best advice I can give to Lajna members. Besides this, I also wish to instruct the Lajna to increase their membership. The Lajna has not yet done anything about it. It is not necessary that only educated women become members. Rather, anyone who speaks and listens in a dignified manner, even if she cannot read a word, should become a member. The best work is done through cooperation, thus other women should be included in Lajna. Today, if the Lajna membership numbered fifty or sixty, they would all have been affected favorably in so many ways.
Now that the call for Maghrib prayer has been made and I have a sore throat, I will end my speech with this prayer. May Allah grant success to this part of our Jama‘at and bestow His blessings upon them.
(Al-Fazl, May 15, 1926)
Address to the Students of the Women’s
Educational Institute
Delivered by Hazrat Mirza Bashir-ud-Din Mahmud Ahmad Khalifat-ul-Masih II (ra)
This speech was given at a reception given by students of the ‘Madrassah Khwateen’ [Women’s Education Institute], in honor of Mohatarram Sayyed Zain-ul-Abideen Waliullah Shah (ra) and his wife.
This Institution is a Tree of Knowledge Planted by Me
Anyone who sows a plant with his own hand, develops a natural fondness and love for it; especially those plants he believes will carry on his good name. Those who plant trees with their own hands come to hold them so dear, that they weep if the trees are cut down by natural disaster or by an enemy. These trees cannot speak, nor can they extol the virtues of the one who planted them although those who benefit from the tree, do say, ‘God bless the person who planted it.’ However, those trees of knowledge which speak, and carry on one’s good name are twice as dear compared to other trees. Hence, I have a special love for ‘Madrassah Khwateen’ and my heart yearns for it to achieve its purpose, that such female teachers are trained who will educate the best generations in such an exemplary manner that the graduates of this institute excel all other students. Due to this love and relationship, I feel I have the right to direct and advise this institution for its benefit. I am particularly pleased with the fact that our students love and cherish their responsibilities and they understand that through education, they will progress academically and spiritually, making them more useful to our community.
Yet the sense of responsibility alone is no substitute for the actual accomplishment because no matter how great a person’s desire or longing is, success cannot be achieved until the right means are used and implemented upon. You see, if a person makes an effort and struggles in order to draw water from a well during a winter night, this effort of his will not cook the bread! Why? Because the laws which God has necessitated for making bread have not been obeyed. Therefore, I believe our mission will only be fulfilled when we follow the rules established for this task.
One’s Voice Should Resound with Power and Dignity
I feel that to advance the learning of the girls and women at this institution, the most critical point to keep in mind is to speak in a clear voice. It should be void of softness or hesitation and should be full of courage, determination, and authority. In my opinion, our women cannot succeed in achieving their work, until their voices resound with that authority and dignity which can be heard in the voices of those who are strongly determined to finish their work. It is the delivery of the speech which leaves the greatest impression. If the tone of the voice is filled with self-doubt and hesitation, and uncertainty over whether the audience will accept one’s notions, then the voice will leave no impact.
We had a Maulvi Sahib amongst us, who despite being very knowledgeable spoke in a manner which suggested self-doubt. He would feel intimidated if someone challenged his arguments. Once he said to a man that the Holy Qur’ān contained thirty verses proving Hazrat Jesus’ (as) death. He was asked to present any one of them. When he did, the person raised an objection to it and Maulvi Sahib replied, “Fine, forget that one. Here is another,” and recited a second verse. The other person raised an objection to the second verse, so he recited a third one, and this continued until he had recited all of them. A commanding voice has a profound effect on its listener; thus, it is crucial for women to develop the habit of speaking with dignity and command in their voices. However, despite my desire and my efforts in this direction, I have been unsuccessful. I now assign this task to Shah Sahib and hope that he will give this matter its due attention, even if he has not done so before. It has been brought to my notice that there are some students who have never answered questions in class and neither have the teachers demanded an answer from them. Mere education has no meaning. The Holy Qur’ān has compared it to a donkey. Until there is confidence, ambition and resolution, education is of no use. In order to be successful, one needs a voice which is clear, full of dignity, courageous, and commanding. I hope that the teachers at this institute will focus upon this and inculcate a habit of speaking courageously, promptly, and correctly within their students.
Since I stress on overcoming weaknesses and it is perceived as being strict, some women may be pleased at Shah Sahib’s new appointment, believing they will be relieved of my severity. However, what they misinterpret as severity was actually in their best interests. As a child, I read a story of King Henry, who as a child was very mischievous. He was sent to be raised in a village. One day, he was brought before a magistrate and he misbehaved, taking advantage of the fact that he was the heir to the throne. The magistrate punished him for his poor behavior. When the King died and Henry became the king of the land, he called for the magistrate. The magistrate was afraid, unsure of how he would be treated. However, the King called him and said, “That incident left such an impact on me that I would like to appoint you to be the highest-ranking judge in my kingdom. Had I not learned to obey the law then, I would not be a king today.”
In short, some guidance is painful, however the outcome is good. Women should not feel discouraged over these points but should progress academically, while facing these hardships.
Advice to the Teachers
Teachers should make sure that there is harmony amongst the entire student body. I expect that Shah Sahib will pay attention to this. Some girls are clever and intelligent and progress quickly, however when teaching a class it is necessary to ensure that the slow learners progress as well. The only way this can be done is to ask them more questions and pay more attention to them. In my opinion, it is necessary to ask each person a question, and that each student be obligated to answer. I was surprised to discover that my daughter had never answered a question in her class. When I realized this, I immediately called her and firmly instructed her to give an answer when asked. I advise Shah Sahib to oblige those women who are not in the habit of speaking, to do so and to pay more attention to those who are weak in their studies. I have noticed this quality in women that if attended to, they can overcome their weaknesses rather quickly.
Another consideration is to ensure that women feel a need to use their knowledge. The only study we cannot overlook is grammar, and it is included in the upcoming syllabus. Students often try to avoid speaking a foreign language. However, when studying Arabic it is my hope that when Shah Sahib insists they answer in Arabic, the students will begin to reply in Arabic.