Conclusion

Flowers for the Women Wearing Veils – Volume I, Part 31

If we suppose that parents are allowed to accept mehr, they will endeavor to marry their daughter into a family where they can expect to gain the most money, rather than considering whether the girl even agrees to the match. Greed would cause them to attempt to marry her to an inappropriate match, rather than an appropriate one. For example, they might marry her to a rich man who could not keep her happy in any circumstance; where she would find grief rather than solace, pain instead of comfort, and where she would suffer for the rest of her life. A daughter could be persuaded to jump into a well once for her parents but bearing a lifetime of tribulation would be intolerable for her.

A girl who is the target of her parents’ selfish desires and is married to an unsuitable match will forever be in distress. Due to this incompatibility, her requirements of love, emotions, feelings, needs, and comfort will not be met, and she will consider her life worse than death. Therefore, no girl is willing to tolerate such misery forever, even if she is ready to die for her parents at any given time.

Consequences of Marriages Borne from Selfish Motives

A girl is naturally desirous of finding ease and comfort in her husband’s home and she wishes to spend her days in happiness and contentment. However, when these girls are wedded into unsuitable families for certain reasons, they become bitter and angry. This clearly indicates that they are not satisfied with their marriage and instead of receiving comfort, they feel only grief. Since I have received such complaints, I am well informed on this issue. When women are counseled or advised to endure, they reply, “What are we to do? This miserable existence has sparked flames of anguish and rage within us. Our parents were blind when they pushed us into a position which brings nothing but distress and difficulty for us.”

A Girl’s Love for her Parents

This does not mean that girls no longer love their parents, or they no longer wish to be devoted and gracious towards them. Rather they complain because they find themselves in a never-ending suffering that they find unbearable. Otherwise, if those very same parents, of whom she complained, were drowning in a river, she would not hesitate to jump into the water to rescue them, regardless of whether she can save them. Due to her intense love for her parents, it would not even occur to her that she was risking her own life by undertaking this act.

Bidding for Girls

Hence, if it becomes permissible for parents to take mehr, thousands of girls will be married to unsuitable matches, where they would lead a life of misery, even though their parents will receive some money. Even now, many such examples can be found where marriages are irresponsibly arranged and girls are more or less sold off, rather than wed. Many people covet money, and they will marry their daughter off to wherever they can gain the most advantage, without any further consideration. I have seen with my own eyes such parents who auction off their daughters and declare that whoever brings them the most money, can take their daughter. Such parents only value money and wed their daughters to whomever they can gain the most income from, regardless of whether the two are compatible or suitable for each other. Some parents are so ruthless that they do not even consider the age difference. For instance, it is common among Hindus to marry a five- or six-year-old child to an elderly man of eighty years. This is not marriage, but a slave trade. Shariah law does not permit slave trade, for each person has the right to freedom and no one can take this right away.

Human Freedom Cannot be Sold

It is entirely possible that some people may believe that children are the parent’s property, so they have the right to benefit from them, but that too is not allowed. My belief is that one cannot even sell one’s own self. I do not believe that it is permitted to sell oneself, let alone have someone else sell you, even if they are your own parents. Parents have no right to sell the freedom and liberty of their children, but alas there exist such parents, who feel no anxiety over this. A female farmer used to visit our house from a nearby village. She would happily boast how they had married one daughter off for this much money and another for that much money, thus ridding them of their debts. They married them off so far away, that they have yet to visit them. If parents are allowed to procure the mehr under such circumstances, it would be a grave injustice and would go against God’s will, forcing girls to suffer pain and misfortune.

The Result of Well-Intentioned Marriages

There is no doubt that sometimes, parents agree to a match after much contemplation, yet that marriage still fails to be a source of comfort for her. However, it is clearly evident that their intentions were not impure, and in such circumstances, she does not blame them. She believes her parents married her off after careful consideration. Beyond that, it was her destiny that her partner was not a good match. She then strives to live her life with patience and gratitude.

The Mehr is for the Woman’s Living Expenses

Since mehr is meant to provide for a woman’s lifelong expenses and for any future necessities, presenting it to her at the time of marriage in order that she may present it to her parents, or spend it upon some trivial expense, is not appropriate. This is because at that stage [generally] she is not aware of the value of money, nor does she understand the needs of married life. At this stage, she believes that when she arrives at her husband’s home, she will take what she wants. However, she is unaware that this assumption is incorrect. Instead, she should have some money of her own to spend independently, so that she may help her parents, brothers, or other relatives.

Moreover, her mehr can also be spent upon her own children. She can use it while her husband is alive, but upon his death, she can utilize it to make ends meet and support her children. However, if at the start [of marriage], she is unaware of the potential circumstances and her parents take this money right away, she will be left destitute and in difficulty when the situation arises. Therefore, it is not permissible for parents to take the mehr from the outset, but yes, once a woman has recognized her own needs and requirements after marriage, she can certainly give her mehr to them if she considers them needy. In this way, a woman can also give her mehr to her husband, but he should not secure a promise for it, without first giving it to her.

If it is the case [that her husband secures a promise for the mehr to be returned to him by his wife] then a woman will think to herself, ‘I haven’t been given anything, at any rate. I only have a verbal commitment, thus not waiving the obligation is of no use to me. I might as well free him of this responsibility.’ Otherwise, if she had received her mehr and was aware of its value, it would not be so easy for her to free him from his responsibility. Hazrat ‘Umar (ra) and other scholars and judicious elders settled that a woman could give her husband her mehr after a period of at least one year. Meaning, she should keep the mehr for one year after receiving it, and then if she wishes, she can offer it to her husband.

Mehr Should Absolutely be Accorded

Hakeem Fazl Deen (ra), who was among the first and foremost to join our community, had two wives. One day, the Promised Messiah (as) said that mehr is a Shariah mandate and must be given to women. Hakeem Sahib responded that his wives had exempted him from the payment of their mehr. The Promised Messiah (as) asked, “Did you place the mehr in their hands and then ask for an exemption?” He replied, “No, Huzoor, I just mentioned it and they waived it.” The Promised Messiah (as) replied that he should first place it in their purse and then ask for a waiver. (Though, even this is of a lesser standard [in terms of righteousness]). In truth, the woman should keep her mehr for at least one year, and only then is it acceptable for her to waive the payment if she wishes. The mehr for his two wives was five hundred rupees each. Hakeem Sahib (ra) took a loan of one thousand rupees and paid them both their mehr. He then said, “Remember, you exempted me from paying the mehr. So now please return it.” The wives replied, “How were we to know that you would actually pay our mehr? At the time, we said we would free you from the obligation, but now we will not return it.” Hakeem Sahib (ra) went to the Promised Messiah (as) and told him the whole story about how he had taken out a loan to pay his wives their mehr, believing he would receive his money back, but now both had refused him. The Promised Messiah (as) was very amused to hear this and replied that this is the correct way. First, give your wife her mehr and if after some passage of time, she wishes to excuse you, she can. Otherwise, it would be tantamount to receiving credit for nothing. A woman supposes that she has neither received her mehr and nor will she be given it in the future, so she thinks, ‘Let it be. If he wants me to free him [of the responsibility of giving the mehr], then it is fine as it is a favor I can give him without actually incurring any cost to myself.’

When a woman receives her mehr and then decides to return it, that is acceptable. Otherwise, even if her mehr is a million rupees but she has not received it, she will forgive it, for it is not coming out of her own pocket. It is mere talk, so what is the harm? Thus, it is essential to give mehr before asking for it to be waived. Again, if this mehr is given to her while she remains unaware of her needs, or when her parents wish to take it from her, then it is unlawful and is equivalent to slavery, which can never be allowed.

·

10 of 10 left today