Conclusion
Flowers for the Women Wearing Veils – Volume I, Part 45
“And they draw their head coverings over their bosoms.” (Holy Qur’ān, Ch. 24: V. 32) Khimār does not refer to an ordinary shawl or dupatta [long head scarf], but rather is the name of a scarf which women wear on their heads while working. Thus, it does not mean that part of a dupatta should be stretched over your chest, for a khimār does not have a side. It is short. This means that you should lower the scarf from the head, so that it covers the chest. This suggests that a person approaching from the front should not be able to see your face.
To an extent, the question of purdah is also related to the mixing of men and women. Regarding this, it can be ascertained from the Holy Qur’ān and Hadith that keeping the rules of purdah in mind, a woman can work alongside men in all kinds of matters. She can learn from men, listen to their lectures, give lectures, she can sit separately from men during gatherings, sermons, and lectures. When needed, she can express her opinion and present arguments. Additionally, it is necessary to consult women in matters which pertain to them.
In times of need, a woman can sit with a man. As the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) said, “If a person is riding an animal and sees a woman, he should let the woman sit behind him.” According to the customs in our country, if a person acted in such a way, the entire nation might boycott him. However, the laws of Shariah were conferred to us thirteen hundred years ago and no one can change them.
In accordance with this statement of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa), I give this decree, that if a ladies’ carriage [in India, the men and women sit in separate compartments] is in danger, the men should let the women sit with them in the gents’ carriage. Or a woman should go alone and sit in the gents’ carriage if she feels her dignity is better safeguarded in the presence of noble men rather than in sitting alone in a carriage by herself. At this time, I have dictated as many examples as possible which readily come to mind. Should you need to inquire furthermore, please do so.
Mirza Mahmud Ahmad,
Qadian
(Misbah, 1 April 1928)
A Clarification of Islamic Purdah
Delivered by Hazrat Mirza Bashir-ud-Din Mahmud Ahmad, Khalifat-ul-Masih II (ra)
(By an Al-Fazl reporter)
Dalhauzi, June 29, 1928 – After Friday prayer, Sheikh Abdul Ghafoor, a medical student asked:
What are the limits of Islamic purdah?
Hazrat Khalifat-ul-Masih II (ra) responded:
Maximum purdah is covering the face except for the eyes and covering the clothes which lie close to the body. Other than that, under the allowance of:
“…except that which is apparent …”
(Holy Qur’ān, Ch. 24: V. 32) whatever part remains exposed due to force of circumstance, is permissible. For example, a female farmer is unable to till the soil and perform other farming work with a veil covering her face. Hence, it is permissible for her to expose her hands and face in order to work. However, those ladies who do not do such work, but rather go out for a stroll, should cover their faces.
Nowadays, the way purdah is discussed is not appropriate. An attempt is being made to derive a different meaning from the Qur’ānic verse, which includes the injunction on purdah, even though the meaning they wish to draw from this verse cannot be derived. Yet we should look upon the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) and his companions (ra) to see how they interpreted it and how they acted upon it.
When we delve deeper, we find that covering the face was included in purdah. It has been clearly written that when the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) suggested that his grandson marry, he sent a woman to see the girl’s complexion. If at that time, the face was not covered, then why send a woman to see the complexion? Similarly, Hazrat ‘Umar (ra) said to a woman, “Umme Hani, I have recognized you.” This suggests that he recognized her from her walk and not by her face. Saying, ‘I have recognized you by your face’ to a familiar acquaintance is no great feat.
Likewise, once when the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) was observing ‘Itikaf [seclusion for prayers in the last ten days of Ramadhan], one of his wives came to visit. Evening time approached and when he was escorting her home, he came across two men. They were most likely hypocrites, and in order to prevent any ill thoughts on their part, he removed the veil from his wife’s face and said, “This is my wife, who is with me.” Had it been customary to leave the face exposed, there would be no need for the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) to uncover his wife’s face as he did.
Similarly, a man said to the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa), “I would like to marry a certain girl, but I do not know what she looks like.” The Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) responded, “Seeing her is permissible. You may see her.” That man went to the girl’s father and told him this. Her father said that he was not ready to show his daughter. The daughter, who was also listening to the conversation, said that if the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) had allowed it, then why stop him. If the girl was out and about with her face exposed, why ask the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) in the first place, and then ask the girl’s father?
There are many incidents of this kind that indicate that women did not walk around with their faces exposed. Indeed, they did go out to work, talk to men, and partake in wars.
The truth of the matter is that unnecessary coercion regarding purdah has resulted in the attempt to extinguish it completely. I myself, have seen women brought in a doli surrounded with curtains as she boarded the train. This was unnecessarily harsh, but it is also dangerous to pervert the actual issue. In this way, damage is done to Islam. If our opponents state that Islam commands us to observe purdah, but we do not, that is another matter. It will be assumed that just as people do not follow many other religious injunctions, so too is the case here. Once it is understood that Islamic purdah is in no way detrimental, but rather is beneficial, people will begin to observe it. However, to say that the injunction of purdah does not even exist in Islam, is to attack Islam. It cannot be expected of those, in whose minds this concept has been imprinted [that the concept of purdah does not exist within Islam], that they will ever be able to justly adhere to true purdah.