An Analysis of the Irrelevant Objection About Stammering

The Founder of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama’at

In the White Paper, published by the government of Pakistan, one of the objections is exactly the same objection raised by the Pharaoh against Prophet Mosesas. It is written: Mirza Sahib was not able to correctly pronounce Ara- bic words. He was not able to phonetically distin- guish Arabic letters with similar sounds; for example, the letter ‘Qaf ’ versus ‘Kaf ’. Occasionally his audience would object, but Mirza Sahib was not able to say anything in his defence. (Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam, p. 12, referencing an article appear- ing in al-Fadl, September 14, 1938)

They have given this reference and then used the caption ‘Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam’. If the Promised Messiahas stammered, and could not say some words prop- erly, how could this possibly be a ‘grave threat’ to Islam? Just how foolish can one be? One could understand the caption of this publication if there were ample reasons for danger. Their own belief is inconsistent with this objection. In the Holy Qur’an, Prophet Mosesas acknowledges:5 ... ...

‘I cannot speak fluently and Aaron is more eloquent.’

5. (al-Qasas, 28:35)

[4]

khutba10.book Page 5 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

If stammering is in fact objectionable, then why did Almighty Allah choose the one who stammered and was less eloquent? In fact, the Holy Qur’an has recorded that the Prophet Moses as could not speak eloquently, but despite that people believe him to be a true Prophet. In addition, people do not believe that the Prophet Mosesas, despite his stammering, was a ‘grave threat’ to his religion. Yet, when they talk about the Promised Messiah as they repeat the same objections raised by the Pharaoh. It is a Divine decree that skeptics repeat the same objections against Prophets that were made by earlier people. In their commentaries, a lot of tales are written about stammering. It is written in Tafsir Ruhul Ma‘ani, part 19, p. 65 that: Because of the atmosphere of suppression, the Prophet Moses was not able to speak clearly. This is a common experience. For example, when even the most eloquent people are struck with extreme grief, their hearts are overwhelmed, and as a result their speech falters, and they cannot express themselves.

Whatever justifications are given, one can easily find refer- ences about the lack of eloquence of the Prophet Mosesas in different commentaries of the Holy Qur’an. For example, Fath-ul-Qadir, part. 3, p. 363, Tafsir Jalalain, p. 408, Tafsir al-Khazin, part. 3, p. 237, etc.

[5]

khutba10.book Page 6 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM

The Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama’at

There is documented evidence about well-recognised Muslim divines who stammered. Have these people forgot- ten Hadrat Bilalra, whom Hadrat ‘Umarra addressed as sye- duna Bilal [our Master Bilal]? Bilal was not able to pronounce the Arabic alphabet correctly. He called the adhan6 saying:

as-hadu al-la ilaha illAllah

Instead of:

ash-hadu al-la ilaha illAllah7

The Companionsra of the Holy Prophetsa used to cry when they heard it. They would not get angry with Hadrat Bilalra, nor would they declare him a ‘grave threat’ to Islam. Instead, they would be overwhelmed with grief, remember- ing that he called the adhan in the same way during the life of the Holy Prophetsa. Hadrat Husainra also used to stammer. It is written in Tafsir Ruhul Ma‘ani, part 16, p. 183 that: Hadrat Husainra used to stammer. In commenting on this, the Holy Prophetsa stated that Husain had inher- ited this stammering from his uncle Prophet Mosesas.

6. The formal call for Islamic daily prayers. 7. ‘I bear witness that there is none worthy of worship except Allah.’

[6]

khutba10.book Page 7 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

In Tafsir Ruhul Ma‘ani, part 16, p. 183, the following is written about Hadrat Imam Mahdi.8 It has been stated that the awaited Mahdi would also stammer. And when he will not be able to express himself, he will strike his left thigh with his right hand.

Now if the Imam Mahdi has come with the so called ‘grave threat’ as prophesied, then we would have to accept this danger, as this is a sign of his truthfulness. It should be noted that this entire discussion is based upon a ‘reference’ in the White Paper, which cites the daily al-Fadl, September 14, 1938. This ‘reference’ does not exist anywhere in the September 14, 1938 al-Fadl. Look it up in the al-Fadl, there is no mention at all in the entire newspa- per. The whole reference has been fabricated. One wonders at the moral deprivation of this government which resorts to fabricating an entire reference just to deceive the world.

10 of 10 left today