Another Baseless Objection

The Founder of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama’at

Another objection is that: After receiving basic education in his ancestral vil- lage, Mirza Sahib was employed in the office of the

8. The literal translation of the Arabic word Mahdi, is ‘the Guid- ed One’. This is the title given by the Holy Prophet Muhammadsa to the awaited Reformer of the Latter Days.

[7]

khutba10.book Page 8 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM

The Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama’at

deputy commissioner in Sialkot as a junior clerk with a salary of 15 rupees per month. Some writers have written that Mirza Sahib was expelled from his home by his father as a punishment for embezzlement. This was the reason that he had to leave Qadian and take up a menial job in Sialkot. He was employed for about four years and left it in 1885. (Qadiyaniyyat— A Grave Threat to Islam, p. 9)

This objection has two parts. One is that he was employed at a salary of 15 rupees per month, implying that he was a very insignificant person. This also implies that God could not have chosen him to be a Prophet, which thereby repeats the same objection raised by the Pharaoh. The second aspect of this objection is that Prophets do not work for someone else. In addition, the Promised Messiahas is being falsely accused (God forbid) of theft. Supposedly, he had to leave home as a punishment for this theft. We have researched to determine where anyone could possibly have found such an incident as a basis for such an allegation. We found in the biography Siratul- Mahdi, vol. 1, p. 43–44, narration no. 49: Once the Promised Messiahas went to Sialkot to col- lect his grandfather’s pension. Mirza Imam-ud-Din, a member of his family, went after him, snatched the money, and ran away. After this, the Promised Messiah as did not return to Qadian because he deemed it better to earn some money by finding a

[8]

khutba10.book Page 9 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

job, rather than going back to his family after incur- ring the loss.

This incident illustrates the innocence, righteousness, and modesty of the Promised Messiah as . The person who robbed him was a non-Ahmadi and a staunch enemy of the Promised Messiahas. But now, the allegation (of theft) is levelled against the Promised Messiahas. The opposition must have read this narration and thought that it could be used as an accusation. Their allegation against the Promised Messiahas is a total lie and a baseless accusation. There is a testimony of a person on record (who later became the Promised Messiah’sas worst opponent) that the Promised Messiahas spent his entire life in a state of utmost righteousness. If one looks at the past to understand the reason for such an accusation against the Promised Messiahas, one sees that accusations of theft were levelled against previous Prophets of God by similar people. Obviously, they would not spare a person whom they consider to be an impostor and a false Prophet. In the Holy Qur’an, it is noted that the brothers of Prophet Josephas stated (with reference to Benjamin) that the Prophet Josephas had also committed theft. Here, it is obvious that the Holy Qur’an has presented this accusation to be a false one, and it does not accept it; rather, it has mentioned this incident to let us know that Prophets are

[9]

khutba10.book Page 10 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM

The Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama’at

falsely accused and even tormented. Unfortunately, some Muslim commentators have accepted this accusation to be true in different commentaries, including Jalalain, al- Khazin, Fath-ul-Qadir, and Ruhul Ma‘ani. The presumed theft has been investigated under this Qura’nic verse.9 ... ...

The commentators disagree about what was stolen, but they all agree that the Prophet Josephas was a thief (God forbid) as well as a Prophet of God. And despite their acceptance that this theft did occur, it did not pose a ‘grave threat’ to their faith or to the world of Islam. Now, let me tell you what are the different speculations of the item that the Prophet Joseph as supposedly stole. Some commentators say that it was a statue made of gold. Some say it was a chicken. Some say it was not even that valuable, and that it was an egg, not a chicken. Others say that he stole some food, but he did so to feed the poor. In short, these people accept such outrageous accusations about Prophets and yet have no doubt about their Prophethood. So, it is not surprising that they should fabri- cate such a totally false accusation against the Promised Messiahas. As far as the character of the Promised Messiahas is con- cerned, there is an account of Mr. Munshi Siraj-ud-Din, the

9. …a brother of his had also committed theft before... (Yusuf, 12:78)

[ 10 ]

khutba10.book Page 11 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

father of Maulavi Zafar ‘Ali Khan Sahib, who knew the Promised Messiahas in Sialkot, when the alleged incident occurred. Talking about that time period he states: We can say on the basis of eyewitness accounts that even in his young age, he was a righteous and pious divine. After work [his employment in Sialkot], he spent all of his time in the study of religion. He would rarely socialise. (Newspaper Zamindar, May 1908; as quoted in Badr, June 25, 1908, p. 13)

Maulavi Muhammad Husain Batalavi writes: The author of Brahin-e-Ahmadiyyah, according to the observation and experience of friends and foe, 10 is— —a follower of the religion of Hadrat sa Muhammad and a righteous and truthful person. (Isha‘atus-Sunnah, vol. 7, p. 9)

With regards to the question of Prophet working as an employee, these Deobandi and Ahl-e-Hadith accusers themselves acknowledge and accept that a Prophet can work as an employee of a non-Prophet. In the Holy Qur’an, Almighty Allah has clearly mentioned the employment of the Prophet Joseph as. Moreover, there is no logic to the statement that a Prophet cannot work as an employee. Why can he not? They are unable to offer any argument for this

10. This Arabic phrase is an affirmative statement by which the author states that, ‘I affirm what I say and Allah is witness to it.’ [publisher]

[ 11 ]

khutba10.book Page 12 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM

The Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama’at

assertion. There is no basis, nor any reference to support it. As I mentioned earlier, the Holy Qur’an clearly mentions one such Prophet who served as an alien nation and, of his own, indicated his desire to head the department of finance. An Ahl-e-Hadith scholar, Maulavi Thana’ullah Amritsari, writes the following regarding the Prophet Josephas: We find it in the Holy Qur’an that Prophet Joseph administered the government of a non-believer king. The ways of any single Prophet is exemplary conduct for us. (Ahl-e-Hadith, Amritsar, November 16, 1945)

The Ahl-e-Hadith, in its October 15, 1946 issue, writes: From the time of the Prophet Joseph to the time of the Prophet Jesus, there have been many Prophets who were subservient to the governments of their time.

One wonders why those Prophets did not become a ‘grave threat’ to their religion?

10 of 10 left today