Replies to an Objection About Ancestry
The Founder of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jama’at
Another objection raised against the Promised Messiahas is that: Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani traces his ancestry to the Moguls of the of Central Asia. According to his earlier writings, he belonged to the Barlas sect of the
[ 12 ]
khutba10.book Page 13 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
Moguls. [This cites a reference to Kitab-ul-Bariyyah, 2nd ed. 1932, p. 134.] Later on he declared that he had received revelation that he is of Iranian descent. He probably made this claim so that he could fulfil the Hadith of the Holy Prophetsa that praised Iranian Muslims for their effort in the propagation of Islam. However, till the last moment of his life, he was not able to determine his exact ancestry. First, he claimed to be a Mogul, and sometime later, he stated that he has some relationship with sadat i.e., and that he is from the progeny of the Holy Prophetsa. In the end, he made the claim that according to the revelation, he was of Iranian descent. He acknowledged that with the exception of a so called vision, he had no evidence that he was of Iranian descent. (Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam, p. 9–10)
In this concocted story, there are many points worth not- ing, which I will recount separately. One aspect of this objection is that he claimed to be of Iranian origin, so that he could prove himself to be the fulfilment of the Hadith in which Iranian Muslims are praised for their part in the propagation of Islam. This is a distortion of facts. They did not have the courage to narrate the original Hadith. In the Hadith, no mention is made about Iranian Muslims serving Islam. What is mentioned is that faith will ascend to the Pleiades. In one version of the Hadith, ‘one person’ is mentioned and in another version ‘persons’ (in plural) are mentioned.
[ 13 ]
khutba10.book Page 14 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM
The Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama’at
It is narrated that while explaining a verse of surah al- Jumu‘ah, the Holy Prophetsa put his hand on the shoulder of his Companion Hadrat Salman Farsira and stated that if faith ascended to the Pleiades, then ‘one man’ or ‘some men’ from among them will bring it back to earth. They did not have the courage to narrate this Hadith. They have intentionally distorted the words of the Holy Prophetsa as if he praised the role played by Iranian Muslims in the propa- gation of Islam, and that is why the Promised Messiahas is presenting himself as being of Iranian descent. As far as the ancestry of the Promised Messiahas is con- cerned, the Promised Messiahas states: My genealogy is from the Mogul Barlas. According to the documents of my ancestors, which have been pre- served, my ancestors came to this country from Samarqand. They had around two hundred people from among their servants, subordinates, and family accompanying them. They entered this country as honoured nobility. (Kitab-ul-Bariyyah, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol. 13, p. 162–163, footnote)
Then he states: As it is commonly understood, this family is known as the Mogul family. But God, the Knower of the Unseen, Who is aware of the reality of the situation, has repeatedly made it known to me through His sacred revelation that this is a Persian family and He
[ 14 ]
khutba10.book Page 15 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
has called me a ‘Son of Persia’. (Haqiqatul-Wahi, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol. 22, p. 80 footnote)
According to the government of Pakistan, a person whose ancestral descent cannot be verified as being of either Per- sian or Mogul origin, and whose ancestry can be ques- tioned regarding whether or not it actually included Sayyed 11 women, is without a doubt a ‘grave threat’ to Islam. But the fact is that there is no contradiction between these three. Because of a lack of understanding, they see a contradiction. As a matter of fact, all three are correct. Research shows that the ancestors of the Promised Messiahas, as he himself claims, came from Samarqand. In this day and age, Samarqand is not included in what we call Iran. Historians would call people from Samarqand, Moguls. What about the Persian descent? Almighty Allah informed the Promised Messiahas of his descent by revela- tion, and for him nothing was more reliable. Therefore, looking at the current geographical divi- sions, on the one hand he acknowledges that his ancestors did come from Samarqand, and he also acknowledges that historians describe them as Moguls. The Promised Messiahas also stated that although there is no obvious rea- son to believe that he is of Persian descent, as he does not have any way to ‘prove’ it, but God (the Knower of the
11. From the descendants of the Holy Prophetsa of Islam.
[ 15 ]
khutba10.book Page 16 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM
The Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama’at
Unseen) has informed him that: ‘You are of Persian descent.’ Geographic boundaries change with historical develop- ments. There is no fixed and permanent line defining the borders between countries. It is stated in the Encyclopaedia Britannica that at the time of the Emperor of Iran, Firuz Shapur, who ruled about 300 years before the Holy Prophetsa, Samarqand was the capital of the border state of the Persian empire, Sog Diana. The distance from Samar- qand to the border was more than 120 kilometers, which is how far the Iranian Empire had spread. It is also written in the Encyclopaedia Britannica that in the time of Khusro Pervez, the king at the time of the Holy Prophetsa, Samar- qand was a part of the Persian empire and remained part of Iran for many centuries thereafter. (Encyclopaedia Britan- nica, vol. 9) The Promised Messiah as was informed by Almighty God, Who knows the Unknown. It was absolutely correct and there is no discrepancy in his statements. It is an estab- lished fact that the ancestors of the Promised Messiahas migrated from Samarqand, which at the time was inhab- ited by people from Persia. These inhabitants of Samar- qand were known as Persians. The question of the Promised Messiahas being a Mogul or not is a secondary issue. Those Moguls who settled in India became Indian Moguls, and those who settled in Afghanistan became Afghani Moguls. Therefore, this is not
[ 16 ]
khutba10.book Page 17 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM
A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam
a big issue. However, if one pursues the matter, we find the following proof from the experts. They say that even if someone is known as a Mogul, it does not necessarily refer to the same Moguls who came from Mongolia. Mr. Stanley Pool, in his authentic book on the history of Mogul Emperors, Medieval India under Mohammedan Rule, writes: The term Moghul…and came to mean any fair man from Central Asia or Afghanistan, as distinguished from the darker native Indians. The various foreign invaders, or governing Muslim class, Turks, Afghans, Pathans, and Moghuls eventually became so mixed that they were all indifferently termed Moghuls. (Published by T. Fisher Unwin Limited, London, 15th ed. 1926, p. 197, footnote)
There is nothing to be surprised. First of all, it is a mean- ingless objection whether the Promised Messiah as was Mogul or not. The Promised Messiahas only says that: we are called Moguls; I am not aware what the facts are. It is possible that history may be wrong. Even historians acknowledge that the possibility of being mistaken is defi- nitely present. There is no doubt as far as the Promised Messiahas being of Persian descent is concerned.
[ 17 ]
khutba10.book Page 18 Sunday, December 31, 2006 10:41 PM
The Founder of the Ahmadiyyah Muslim Jama’at