Question – 2

Four Questions by Mr. Sirajuddin, a Christian, and their Answers

If the aim of Islam is to guide mankind towards Tauhid [the Unity of God], why in its early period did it wage Jihad against the Jews while their revealed books only teach the Unity of God; or why should it now be considered essential for the Jews and those who already believe in the Unity of God to become Muslims in order to attain salvation?

Answer:

Let it be clear that at the time of our Holy Prophet (sa) the Jews had strayed far from the teachings of the Torah. Their scriptures taught the Unity of God, but they had ceased to derive any benefit from this teaching and had forgotten the ultimate cause for which man was created and for which the scriptures were revealed. True belief in the Unity of God means that, having believed in His existence and having acknowledged His Unity, one should submit to the Lord of Grace and Perfection, seek His pleasure and totally immerse one’s self in His love. In practice, the Jews had ceased to believe in the Unity of God and their hearts were no longer in awe of Divine glory and majesty. While their tongues uttered the name of God, in their hearts they worshipped Satan and transgressed all limits in their love of the world and in treachery and falsehood. They worshipped mendicants and rabbis and indulged in shameful acts. Hypocrisy had also become common and deception was widespread. Belief in the Unity of God does not mean merely to utter the words

trary, every person is an idolater in the sight of God who gives his own plans and actions the same importance as should be given to God, or relies upon a human being as he should rely on Him, or exalts his own self the way God should be exalted. In the sight of God, idols are not merely things made of gold, silver, bronze or stone in which people put their trust, rather every object and every word and deed that is given the same importance as should be given to Him is an idol. The Torah does not contain such a fine definition of idol-worship, but the Holy Qur’an defines it in great detail. One of the reasons why God revealed the Holy Qur’an was to rid people’s hearts of idol-worship that afflicted them like an infectious disease. This was the kind of idolatry the Jews were steeped in, but the Torah was unable to liberate them from it because it did not contain a comprehensive teaching. Moreover, the disease which had affected the entire Jewish people required a pure and living example of Tauhid that would be manifested through a perfect man. Remember, the true Tauhid, which God wants us to profess and on which true salvation depends, is to believe that God has no associate—be it an idol, a man, the sun, the moon, our own selves, our devices or our cunning—and to consider Him alone as the Source of all power and sustenance, honour and humiliation, help and succour, and to make Him the object of all our love, worship, supplication, hope and fear. Hence, no concept of Tauhid is complete without the following three aspects:

(1) Tauhid in the context of God’s Person: To consider everything beside Him to be as good as non-existent, mortal, and of no consequence.

(2) Tauhid in the context of God’s Attributes: To believe that no one possesses the attributes of Lordship and Divinity except the Person of the Almighty, and that all those who appear to sustain and benefit creation are only a part of the Divine scheme of things.

(3) Tauhid in the context of love, sincerity and devotion: Not to associate anyone with God in terms of love and devotion, and to immerse oneself completely in Him. The Jews had lost the true concept of Tauhid, one that forms the basis of salvation and comprises these three aspects. Their misconduct clearly testified that their belief in God was merely verbal while, in their heart of hearts, they did not believe in Him. The Holy Qur’an holds both Jews and Christians guilty and says that, had they upheld the teachings of the Torah and the Gospel, they would have been blessed with heavenly and worldly bounties. They would have been granted the signs of true believers, such as miracles, acceptance of prayers, visions and revelations, all of which are heavenly bounties, and, in addition to this, they would also have been granted worldly bounties. But now they are completely devoid of heavenly blessings, and their worldly bounties are attained not by turning to God but by turning to the world. Thus they remain bereft of both.

It is evident from the Holy Qur’an that the wars fought against the Jews and the Christians were not initiated by the Muslims and were not waged to force people to enter Islam. Rather, the enemies of Islam created the conditions for these wars by persecuting the Muslims or aiding their persecutors. And when they had themselves created these conditions, God decided to punish them. But He, in His mercy, still gave them the choice that whoever embraced Islam or agreed to pay Jizyah would be spared. This concession was in keeping with the Divine law of nature, for human conscience naturally turns towards prayer, repentance, supplication, almsgiving and charity in order to ward off calamities such as epidemics or famines which come down as God’s punishment. This indeed is the eternal law which shows that the Gracious God inspires hearts [towards prayer, etc.] in order to avert punishment. For instance, He accepted Moses’ prayers on a number of occasions and saved the Israelites from Divine chastisement. The Islamic wars were a kind of punishment for Islam’s hardened enemies, but the door of mercy was still left open for them. It is wrong to assume that Islam fought wars to spread Tauhid. These punitive wars were waged only after other nations had resorted to tyranny and oppression. We now come to the question as to why the Jews should become Muslims when they already profess belief in the Oneness of God. I have stated before that Tauhid was not firmly established in their hearts; it was only found in their books and even then it was far from perfect. Hence, they needed the living spirit of Tauhid to be established in their hearts, without which salvation is not possible. They were like the dead and had lost the true spirit of Tauhid due to their hard-heartedness and disobedience of every kind. They had turned their backs on God and the Torah had ceased to provide perfect guidance because its teachings were not only inadequate but had also been corrupted in form and substance. Hence God sent down His Living Word [the Holy Qur’an] like water that descends fresh from heaven and invited them to it so that they might attain true salvation by freeing themselves from all errors and misconceptions. The Holy Qur’an was revealed to teach living Tauhid to the Jews who were spiritually dead, to warn them of their errors and to impart detailed knowledge regarding some doctrines that had only been hinted at in the Torah, such as bodily resurrection, immortality of the soul, and the concept of heaven and hell.

The fact is that the seed of truth, which was sown by the Torah, sprouted in the form of the Gospel and gave a glad-tiding for the future. Just as the green and verdant vegetation of a field promises abundant fruit in the coming days, in the same manner the Gospel gave good news of the coming of the perfect Shariah and the perfect Guide. This seed finally attained perfection through the Holy Qur’an which brought with it the perfect bounty, distinguished right from wrong, and perfected all religious verities as foretold in the Torah:

'The Lord came from Sinai, and dawned on them from Seir, he shone forth from mount Paran'.

There is no doubt that the Holy Qur’an alone has brought every aspect of the Divine law to perfection. This law consists of two major parts: the rights of God, and the rights of man. The Holy Qur’an’s mission was to transform savages into men, men into moral beings and moral beings into Godly ones, and it has done this in such a wonderful way that, by comparison, the Torah seems completely silent.

One of the many objectives of the Holy Qur’an was to settle the dispute between the Jews and the Christians with regard to the Messiah (as), and it has satisfactorily settled all such issues. An example of this is found in the verse in the Holy Qur’an The Jews believed that since the Messiah, the Prophet of the Christians, was crucified, therefore, in the light of the teachings of the Torah, he was accursed, was never raised to heaven and was an impostor. The Christians, on the other hand, believed that he became accursed, but only for their sake, and that later his curse was removed and he was raised to heaven and sat on the right hand of God. But this verse establishes that Jesus was exalted towards God immediately after his death, and that he was neither cursed forever, as the Jews believed—for an everlasting curse is a barrier to attaining spiritual exaltation—nor for a few days, as the Christians would have us believe. In the same verse God also explains that Jesus’ spiritual exaltation [towards God] is not contrary to the teachings of the Torah, because, according to it, only he who actually dies on the cross is accursed and is denied exaltation. Being put on the cross and suffering pain, which does not result in death, brings no curse, nor does it preclude spiritual exaltation. According to the Torah, crucifixion is the Divine method of putting sinners to death, hence whoever dies on the cross dies the accursed death of a sinner. The Messiah (as), however, did not die on the cross rather God saved him from such a death. He had foretold that his situation would be similar to that of Jonah, and so it happened. Just as Jonah did not die in the belly of the fish, so was Jesus saved from death on the cross, and his prayer

'Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani' was heard. Had he died, Pilate, too, would have suffered chastisement, for an angel had warned his wife that they would suffer greatly if Jesus was killed. But Pilate was not visited with any punishment. Another proof that Jesus escaped death is that his bones were not broken on the cross, and blood gushed forth from his body when it was pierced after being taken down from the cross. Afterwards he also showed his disciples his wounds which he would not have had if he had been resurrected. All this proves that Jesus did not die on the cross and was, therefore, not accursed. He died a virtuous death and, like all Prophets of God, was exalted towards Him in keeping with the promise contained in the verse Had he died on the cross, his own statement would have belied him for there would have been no resemblance between him and Jonah. Thus the dispute that had long existed between the Christians and the Jews was finally settled by the Holy Qur’an. And yet the Christians continue to insist that there was no need for the Holy Qur’an to be revealed! You who are ignorant and blind of heart! The Holy Qur’an brought perfect Tauhid. It harmonized reason with the Divine Word. It brought Tauhid to perfection. It established, through incontrovertible arguments, the Unity of God and His attributes, and proved His existence through arguments based on reason, tradition as well as revelation. It demonstrated, in rational terms, the truth of religion which earlier rested on mere stories, and provided a rational basis to each and every one of its doctrines. It perfected the chain of religious truths and verities, which was hitherto incomplete, and absolved Jesus of the curse of crucifixion and testified that he was an exalted and true Prophet. Are these blessings not enough to prove the need for the Holy Qur’an?

Bear in mind that the Holy Qur’an has itself clearly explained the reason for its revelation:

i.e., Know that the earth had become dead and that God is about to give it a new life. History testifies that, by the time the Holy Qur’an was revealed, all nations had become corrupt. Mr. Pfander, a Christian clergyman and author of Mizan-ul-haq, despite his deep-rooted bias, has clearly written in his book that the Jews and the Christians had become corrupt and decadent by the time of the Holy Qur’an that served as a warning to them. But, despite admitting all this, he still argues that God warned them through a false Prophet. What blasphemy! Can we attribute such a thing to God, that finding mankind in error and corruption He led them into even greater misguidance and caused the doom of millions of innocent people with His own hand? Is this what Divine providence does for mankind in its hour of trial? Sadly, in their love of the world they have gone so far as to deny a truth which is as clear as the sun. On the one hand they ascribe divinity to a humble man whom they believe to be accursed, and, on the other, they reject the Greatest of Prophets (sa) who came when mankind was spiritually dead. And they still have the temerity to question the need for the Holy Qur’an. You heedless and blind-hearted people! No Prophet appeared at a time of such complete darkness as had shrouded the world at the time of the Holy Qur’an. Finding the world blind the Holy Qur’an bestowed it with sight, finding it astray it provided guidance, and finding it dead brought new life. What more do you require as evidence for the need of the Holy Qur’an? Your condition is all the more pitiable if you ask what new teaching did the Holy Qur’an bring when the teaching of Tauhid was already present in the world?

I have already pointed out that the concept of Tauhid contained in the earlier scriptures was imperfect—no one can deny this—and that the hearts of the people had become entirely devoid of it. It was the Holy Qur’an that revived it and brought it to perfection, this is why it has been called Zikr for it serves as a reminder for mankind. Open your eyes and reflect: was the Torah’s teaching about Tauhid so unique that the earlier Prophets had no knowledge of it? Was not the same teaching given to Adam, and then to Seth, and then to Noah, and then to Abraham and to all other Prophets who came before Moses? Hence the same objection could be raised against the Torah, i.e., what new teaching did it bring? Misguided people! God is immutable. He was the same in the time of Moses as in the time of Adam, Seth, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and Joseph; and the Torah’s teaching about Tauhid was the same as that taught by the earlier Prophets.

10 of 10 left today