Reply to the Announcement & Letter
A Gift for Baghdad, Part 9
As for our beliefs, which Allah has established for us, know, O my brother, that we believe in Allah as Lord; in Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, as a Prophet; and we believe that he is Khatamun-Nabiyyin [the Seal of the Prophets]. We believe in the Furqan [Holy Qur’an] to be from Allah the Most Gracious. We do not accept anything that opposes the Furqan and differs with its indisputable evidence, its decisive verses, and its narratives, whether it is an intellectual matter from one of the traditions that the Ahlul-Hadith considered to be a true hadith, or whether it is from one of the statements of the Companions or their Subsequent Generation, because the Noble Furqan is a Book whose being tawatur has been proved word by word, and it is recitable, doubtless, and certain revelation. He who doubts its decisiveness is in our opinion a renegade disbeliever and is among the disobedient.
The Holy Qur’an is characterized, specifically, by consummate perfection, and it has a status which is superior to the status of every Book and every revelation. The hand of man has not tampered with it. As far as other Books and traditions are concerned, they cannot approach this sublime position; and whoever prefers anything else over it, indeed prefers doubt over certainty.
How many sects in Islam have differed with each other in accepting some ahadith whilst rejecting others! For instance, most of the ahadith which the Shafi‘i sect accept are rejected by the Hanafis, and those accepted by the Hanafi sect are rejected by the Shafi‘is, and so it is with other Muslim sects. How many ahadith are mentioned by Imam Bukhari in his Sahih, which is the most authentic book after the Book of Allah in the opinion of the Ahlul-Hadith . On the other hand, however, the Hanafi sect do not accept most of his ahadith, such as the hadith concerning the recitation of Surah al-Fatihah after the Imam and saying ‘Amin’ in a loud voice, and so forth. They pay no heed to these ahadith. However, no one designates them as disbelievers or considers them from among those who have abandoned Prayer or as innovators.
In fact, most of the ahadith are ahad,1 whether they are in al-Bukhari or other [collections], so they should not be accepted until after verification, appraisal, confirmation from the Holy Qur’an that they do not violate its clear statements and decisive verses, and after considering who and how many narrated it consecutively. Therefore, how can anyone be accused of disbelief for abandoning a hadith that opposes the Holy Qur’an, or for presenting an interpretation which makes the hadith congruent with the Holy Qur’an, while by doing so he delivers the Muslims from the critics’ attacks? How can you accuse a believer in Allah, His Messenger, and His Book of disbelief, for the sake of denying one hadith which was reported by a single narrator and which may suffer from the blemish of man’s prevarications?
Consider, for example, the subject of the death of the Messiah, peace be on him. It has been confirmed by indisputable evidence in the authentic and mutawatir Book of Allah. His death is clearly attested to in approximately thirty verses, which I have recorded in my book entitled Izala-e-Auham [The Removal of Misconceptions] for the benefit of the seekers after truth. Should you mention a hadith pertaining to Damascus, cited in [Sahih] Muslim, then know it has been interpreted literally. There is no doubt that its literal interpretation opposes the Holy Qur’an, conflicts with its indisputable evidence, as well as other ahadith which we have mentioned in Izala-e-Auham. A Muslim could never be content with abandoning the absolute certainty of the Holy Qur’an for the sake of a single hadith which does not even have a high degree of certainty.
Had we acted in this manner, preferring a single narrated hadith to the Book of Allah, then the Religion would have been corrupted, the Islamic creed would have been destroyed, the impregnability of the Faith would have disappeared, belief would have been violently shaken, and the attack of the disbelievers against us would have intensified. Yes, we believe in that part of the hadith which does not conflict with the Holy Qur’an; i.e. the part that states that the Promised Messiah will appear as a Mujaddid at the beginning of the century during the time of the Christians’ dominance over the earth. He will appear in a land that they have corrupted and whose inhabitants they have converted from Islam to Christianity. Then, he will break the cross, kill the swine, and will bring happiness to the rest.
If the expression ‘nuzul [descent] near a minaret in Damascus’ agitates you, we have established that descent from heaven is preposterous and untenable. The Furqan does not confirm it; on the contrary, it denies it in a clear statement.
If you believe in the Furqan and prefer it to everything else, then you should believe in the death of the Messiah and the implausibility of his descent from the skies, as you read in the words of the Lord of all the worlds. The surprising thing is that the expression ‘descent from the skies’ is not found in any hadith and is only a perversion of the fabricators. All ahadith agree that the Promised Messiah will be from this ummah, for Prophethood has been terminated and our Messenger is Khatamun-Nabiyyin.
The word nuzul, which is mentioned in the hadith, has the meaning of a traveller alighting from place to place, because nazil [in Arabic] means a traveller. Even if we do accept the authenticity of this hadith, then it only establishes that the Promised Messiah or one of his Caliphs will travel from a certain place and will alight in Damascus. So, why should people bemoan the use of the word ‘Damascus’? Nay, it is confirmed, by using the phrase nuzul near a minaret in Damascus, that the homeland from where the Promised Messiah will come forth is in another dominion and he will only alight in Damascus in his travels. This is if we accept the hadith in the literal sense, although that in itself is debatable, because the Hadith in general are speculative except that portion which is confirmed by the continuous practice of the believers.
Had the ahadith that are recorded in al-Bukhari and other books been certain, like the Holy Qur’an, then whoever would reject them would become liable to disbelief, just as denying the verses of the Holy Qur’an makes one liable to disbelief, as is known by those who are well acquainted with the Firm Shariah. If this was the case, then it would necessarily mean that all Muslims should be deemed disbelievers, and it would be unavoidable for any of the Muslims, whether distinguished or ordinary, to escape from the dilemma of disbelief; nay, not even the foremost among our imams would be safe from this predicament. Because it is a general affliction which all fuqaha’ [jurists], imams, and muhaddithin
[Hadith scholars] suffer from—that they abandon and reject some of the ahadith.
However, since our Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, is Khatamul-Anbiya’ [the Seal of the Prophets], there can be no doubt that whoever believes in the descent of a Messiah who is a Prophet of the Children of Israel, has indeed denied Khataman-Nabiyyin. Woe to people who say that the Messiah, Jesus Son of Mary, is to descend after the death of the Messenger of Allah, and say that he will appear and abrogate some of the commandments of the Holy Qur’an and add others, that revelation will descend upon him for forty years, and that he will be the last of the Messengers! The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, has said:
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[There will be no Prophet after me]; and Allah has called him Khatamul-Anbiya’. Therefore, wherefrom shall a Prophet appear after him? Will you not then reflect, O Muslims? You are following delusions borne out of injustice and untruth, and you treat the Holy Qur’an as a discarded thing, and thus you have become slothful.
We believe in the Angels of Allah and in their stations and ranks. We believe that their descent is like the descent of rays of light, not like the travel of human beings from one abode to another. They do not depart from their fixed stations; nevertheless, they do descend and ascend. They are the army of Allah, inhabitants of the heavens and their fellow dwellers; they do not become separated from their positions. There is none that does not possess an assigned station. They do what they are commanded. No one issue can distract them from other issues and they duly obey the Lord of all the worlds.
Had it been necessary to be separated from their stations in order to execute their tasks, then it would not be possible for some souls to die at the same moment. It would be mandatory that a person in the East should not die at the time Allah had decreed for him, before the Angel of Death had finished taking the soul of a man in the West who was destined to die at the same moment as the other man, and before travelling to the East. This is nothing except a clear lie. Their only command, when they intend a thing by the permission of Allah, is to say to it ‘Be!’, and it is. They do not have to descend with great hardship to their selves, nor to expend time, walk away, or leave their station, like the dwellers of the earth.