The Validity of the So-Called Majority in the Eyes of the Ulema

A Great Victory for Ahmadiyyat

What the National Assembly did in 1974 is a shining proof of the truth of Ahmadiyyat. It is rare to find such a glorious sign as I will discuss later. Let me first put forth what the ulema of these people have said about the so-called majority. Syed ‘Ata’ullah Shah Bukhari said: We will not subjugate ourselves to the so-called majority as we know them to be wrong. (Swaneh Hayat-e-Bukhari, p. 11, Akhbar Zamzam, Lahore, April 30, 1939).

The leader of Deobandi sect Maulavi Ashraf ‘Ali Thanwi says: In our times democracy is being touted as superior to personal leadership. What the majority says goes.

[ 15 ]

Khutba 17.book Page 16 Sunday, March 16, 2008 3:01 PM

A Great Victory for Ahmadiyyat

Indeed the point he made is very fine, but it would be a sur- prise if any maulavi comprehended it. Nevertheless, the Maulavi Sahib being quoted had the nobility of hearing a valid point and passing it on. The fine point mentioned by his friend is as follows. He said that even if we understand the meaning of Great Multitude to mean a simple majority, it is still not applicable to all times and ages. It refers to the time of the Holy Prophetsa and the three centuries that passed after him. (Ibid.)

That is to say, the ‘Great Multitude’ mentioned by the Holy Prophetsa refers to the majority of the Muslims during the time which, according to the Holy Prophet sa , was the period of righteousness, truthfulness, and light. The Holy Prophetsa himself declared it to be the best of times. That is to say, his time and the time of the next two generations of Muslims. These three are the periods of light. After that darkness was destined to prevail. The quotation continues: In those times a simple majority was the Great Multi- tude. In other times:

‘then falsehood would spread’

[ 16 ]

Khutba 17.book Page 17 Sunday, March 16, 2008 3:01 PM

A Review of the Pakistani Government’s “White Paper”: Qadiyaniyyat—A Grave Threat to Islam

indicates a simple majority would not be the Great Multitude because most people in these times would be involved in mischief. (Ibid.)

In other words the best of times does not refer to the period in which, according to the Holy Prophet s a himself, falsehood would spread. This is a very valid and cogent point, which cannot be questioned. The Holy Prophetsa did talk about the ‘Great Multitude’, but at the same time, he also pointed out that the best of times is limited to three periods or generations. After that, falsehood and spiritual darkness would start spreading. To draw a valid conclusion from the opinions of the masses during this period is a baseless attempt. The quotation continues: This was an important and valid point expressed by my friend and I concur with it. (Ibid.)

10 of 10 left today