The Scholars of this Era
Guidance for Perceiving Minds
Given the evidence presented in the preceding statement, it is clear that the Muslim rulers in this era have been unable to rectify the widespread corruption that has spread like wildfire. Nevertheless, it remains valid for you to assert that these tribulations stem from the ignorance of the uninformed and can be eradicated through the guidance of scholars. They are the rightful inheritors of the Prophet’s s (as) legacy and the champions in this domain. Enlightened by the radiance of knowledge, they are anticipated to rectify what the rulers of states have failed to address.
Know that I have always attended the gatherings of these scholars, often finding myself alone with them as a confidant. Sometimes, I approached them in the guise of a stranger or an ignorant individual, experiencing first-hand their love, resentment, hardship, and prosperity. Through these encounters, I learned about their character, determination, and piety. It has become apparent to me that many of them are more of a detriment to Islam than a remedy. They are like a severe attack or fierce storm to the religion rather than illuminating it like a bright lamp or light. They accumulate every defect in their behaviour and character, staining themselves with numerous flaws. They come up with all sorts of schemes, means, and tricks to seize people’s wealth for themselves. They speak without practicing what they preach, teaching without learning. They desire to harvest without planting, exhibiting hard hearts, vulgar tongues, darkened chests, feeble opinions, inflexible dispositions, deficient minds, weak resolutions, and corrupt deeds. What you can observe is their intent towards those who dissent from their views: they resort to any means to accuse them of disbelief or inflict harm upon them. They strive to seize their wealth through any method available. They are arrogant despite possessing only superficial knowledge, and they are nothing but like donkeys .
They instruct people to forsake the world and its allurements, yet they themselves covet it more than the average person, resorting to attaining in it, even through illicit means. They take advantage of the charity of the rich filling their pockets like strangers. They resort to begging, even enduring punches or blows in return. They attend funerals not for prayer but for alms. They do not accept the truth or understand it, even if it is a statement that makes the deaf hear and compels the stubborn to relinquish their opinions. Cowardice is one of their traits, and the bird of desire nests comfortably within them. Miserliness is imbued in their nature, envy serves as their religion, and distorting the Shariah is their way. When angered, they transform into wolves, and when they eat, they are like animals.
Their discontent and contentment are solely for their evil egos. Their remembrance and praise of Allah serve only for show. Observe them in public gatherings, and not in private, to witness them with prayer beads in hand, concealing actions that can ruin your perception of this group. They compel people to give them whatever money or clothing they possess, even if lying in the dust (pretending to be poor) leads them to the brink of death. They assert dominion over people’s necks as if they were their masters. If they want, they label them as angels or brethren of the devil.
When required to testify, they withhold the truth; when asked for a fatwa, they conceal the truth and lie, driven by greed of a little gain.
They lead people in Prayers as if they were hired labourers. In fact, you will find some unlawfully exploit mosque endowments, depriving the poor of their rights. They adamantly refuse to relinquish their leadership, asserting, “This is my mosque, and I have led [the Prayers] for more than sixty [years],” even if another Imam is more qualified, knowledgeable, and pious. Despite being disliked by the congregation and perceived as sinful, they resort to pleading with rulers to retain their position, motivated solely by greed for the money allocated for the mosque.
And there are those among them who, upon seeing the wealth you have earned or the treasures you have acquired, would gather around you like flies, approaching you as if they were dear friends. They would not depart from your doorstep until they had eaten from your fruits. You will discover that the hearts of the majority among them resemble barren land, and among the most desolate patches of stony ground. They fail to produce any fruit; instead, all you witness is harm emanating from them. There is no hint of tolerance within them; instead, they resemble wild beasts with sharp teeth and harsh tongues. They approach you cloaked in sheepskins, yet they are beasts that devour through all manner of slander, as long as they are not offered an agate shield. They present themselves to the public adorned with hats, smocks, turbans, and mantles, carrying books and wearing cloaks. This is the facade they project, but their actions reveal otherwise. They have embarked on a quest for worldly pursuits, forsaking the abode of the Hereafter to which they are destined to return.
When asked if they consume questionable sustenance, they respond, “We have no issue; we are compelled by necessity.” Yet, they are not compelled; they are simply lying. They have forsaken the secure abode of righteousness and settled in a land where people are assassinated and kidnapped.
They trade religion for gaining bread, and eagerly seek what comes without cost. Their pens craft false fatwas and malicious accusations, and their faith can be bought with a mere coin or two. They obstruct others from the truth and whisper like demons. At the sight of a table set with diverse dishes, they fall on it like flies or descend upon it like vultures upon carrion. They solicit funds from people through emotional sermons, and they hunt their victims disguised as jurists. Their sole occupation is scheming; where can one find a hunter akin to them? Thus, the books of fables were penned to show their deeds, while the reality of their circumstances was elucidated in hypothetical tales. Some orators dubbed them Abul-Fath al-Iskandari, while others named them Abu Zayd al-Suruji; yet, they are naught but these scholars. So take a lesson, O people of discernment.
Those who crafted such narratives did so only after their hearts trembled upon witnessing the actions of these scholars, and their skin crawled at the sight of the manipulations of these deceitful individuals. They perceived them as people whose words profess belief while their hearts harbour disbelief. Thus, they composed rhythmic tales as a cautionary message to the unaware, attributing their creation and narration to others out of fear of retribution from the malevolent.
Similarly, they bore witness to their grievances against the scholars. Had they lived in our era, they would have exposed their deceitfulness, but they were not deemed as writers. The scholars of yore possessed eloquent speech, even if their faith was lacking. As for the haughty individuals prevalent in our time, scattered throughout every township like a herd of sheep, they are merely worshippers of material sustenance, not of literature nor of the scholarly pursuits. They were not nurtured on the milk of eloquence, nor did they imbibe the cup of reasoned argument. They often remain silent for thousand times, only to engage in contentious dialogue thereafter. They lack deep knowledge of Arabic sciences and are not refined in literary discernment. Their pride swells, while their contemplation wanes.
They are incapable of speaking words that benefit others; instead, their speech just fosters suspicion and doubt. When they remain silent, it signifies neglect of duty and leads to misinformation; when they speak, their words lack impact and effect. Their resolve has weakened, and their determination has waned. They are acquainted only with wishes like the Jews, and their prayers are merely [customary] standing and sitting.
They have nothing to do with the intricacies of the Shariah, nor with the subtleties of the religion. If you were to critique them, you would find that most of them are vile and behave like animals, and it will lead you to believe that their existence is a calamity for Islam. They resemble vicious individuals in their obscenity and behave like dogs in conflict. They seem to believe they can be left unbridled, living as if there is no tomorrow beyond today. The truth is not covered with a veil, but misery overcame them. For them, declaring people as infidels is an easy matter - and the belief in the death of Jesus (as) is a clear proof—and by Allah, they do not desire for the victory of Islam, but rather for the victory of the priests like the mean enemies.