Haqiqatul-Wahi
Haqiqatul-Wahi (The Philosophy of Divine Revelation), Part 10
Moreover, God Almighty, who is the Knower of the Unseen, says in the Holy Qur’an with reference to the mischief of Christianity that the heavens may well-nigh be rend asunder, and the mountains may crumble into pieces. Yet with reference to the Dajjal who, according to our opponents, will zealously trumpet his god-like powers, and whose mischief will be worse than all of the mischief of the world, the Holy Qur’an does not even mention that his mischief can rend asunder a small mountain. It is strange that the Holy Qur’an declares the mischief of Christianity to be the worst, yet our opponents clamour about some other Dajjal.
And also consider the error of the Christian gentlemen. On the one hand, they have raised Hadrat ‘Isa to the level of divinity and, on the other hand, they also believe that he is accursed. Bear in mind that all linguists agree that being accursed is a spiritual matter, and one who is expelled from the royal court of God is called ‘accursed’—meaning the one who is not raised to God and whose heart is bereft of any bond of love and obedience with God—God being weary of him and he being weary of God. This is why Satan is referred to as ‘accursed’. Thus, can any sane person suggest that Hadrat ‘Isa’s heart was totally estranged from God and God Almighty had become weary of him?
It is strange that, on the one hand, the Christian gentlemen, quoting the Gospels, say that this incident of Hadrat ‘Isa resembled the incident of Yunus [ Jonah] and the incident of Ishaq [Isaac], and yet they themselves believe a creed that contradicts this resemblance. Are they able to tell us that Yunus (as) entered the belly of the fish in a state of death and stayed in it for two or three days in this lifeless state? Hence, what resemblance does Yasu‘ [ Jesus] have with Yunus (as)? What resemblance does a living one have with the dead? Are the Christian gentlemen able to tell us that Ishaq was actually slaughtered and was then brought back to life? And if it is not so, what resemblance does the incident of Yasu‘ have with the incident of Ishaq?
Again, Yasu‘ the Messiah says in the Gospels, ‘If ye have faith even as much as a grain of mustard seed, ye shall say unto this mountain, move from here to there; and it shall move.’ But it seems that the entire prayer of Yasu‘ to spare his own life went to waste. Now behold! What conclusion would be drawn about the faith of Yasu‘ according to the Gospels? It is not true at all that Yasu‘ prayed that he may well die on the cross, but that it should be without distress. Was the prayer in the garden [of Gethsemane] meant only to spare him the distress? If this were the case, why did he raise the cry Eli Eli lama sabachtani when he was put on the cross? Does this utterance indicate that his distress had been removed at that moment? How far can a fabrication go? The prayer of Yasu‘ clearly has these words: ‘Let this cup pass from me.’ So God made that cup pass and created such circumstances as were sufficient to save his life; for example, the fact that he was not kept on the cross for up to six or seven days as was the norm, but was taken down within a short time, and that whereas the bones of others [crucified] were always broken, his bones were not broken. It is inconceivable that someone could die from such little torture.
The belief of our opponents that Hadrat ‘Isa, peace be upon him, was saved from the cross and ascended physically to Heaven raises a serious objection against the Holy Qur’an, because the Holy Qur’an consistently refutes all Christian assertions that are used to prove the divinity of Hadrat ‘Isa. For instance, the Holy Qur’an denied any special significance of the fatherless birth of Hadrat ‘Isa (which was used as an argument for his divinity) by declaring:
Thus, if Hadrat ‘Isa had indeed ascended to Heaven with his mortal body and is then to descend again, this would be a distinction far more misleading than his fatherless birth. So pray tell, where has the Holy Qur’an refuted this by citing a precedent? Was God incapable of refuting this distinction?
Let me reiterate that the belief on which the Companions, Allah be pleased with them, had ijma‘ [consensus] was the fact that all Prophets, peace be upon them, had passed away, and none [of them] was alive. All of the Companions (ra) held fast to this belief until their last breaths. This belief was in agreement with the explicit text of the Holy Qur’an. There can be no lie greater than to claim that, at some time, after the Companions (ra) had passed away, this ummah had ijma‘
on the issue of Hadrat ‘Isa being alive with his mortal body in Heaven. The following words of Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal aptly apply to such a person: ‘Anyone who claims ijma‘ upon any issue after the time of the Companions is a great liar.’
The truth of the matter is that after the passage of the first three centuries, the blessed ummah split into seventy-three sects and hundreds of mutually contradictory beliefs took root among them to out of dust, then He said to him, ‘Be!’, and he was (Surah Al-e-‘Imran, 3:60). [Publisher]
[of the Holy Qur’an] nor any sahih [authentic], marfu‘ [for which the chain of narrators reaches all the way up to the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him], muttasil [that is, there is no interruption in the chain of reporters] hadith which substantiates that Hadrat ‘Isa was, in fact, physically raised to Heaven. Hence, it is wishful thinking to expect the return of someone whose ascension is not substantiated. First prove ‘Isa’s ascension to Heaven from either an explicit verse [of the Holy Qur’an] or a sahih, marfu‘, muttasil hadith; otherwise your unjustified opposition is an attitude far removed from righteousness. (Author)
the extent that they were no longer in agreement even regarding such beliefs as the appearance of the Mahdi and the coming of the Messiah. For example, the Mahdi of the Shias is hidden in a cave and he has the original Holy Qur’an. He will appear at a time when the Companions, Allah be pleased with them, will also be brought back to life, and he will take revenge from them for the usurpation of the Khilafat [from Hadrat ‘Ali (ra)].
Likewise, with reference to the Mahdi of the Sunnis, based upon their statements, it is not certain that he will be born to a particular family, nor is it certain that he will appear in the time of ‘Isa. Some say that he will be born from among the Fatimids, and some say that he will be from among the Abbasids. Still others opine, on the basis of a hadith, that he is a man from the ummah in general. Then again, some say that the advent of the Mahdi must occur in the middle period, and the Promised Messiah will come after him and they quote ahadith to support this. Others say that the Messiah and Mahdi are not two distinct individuals, but that very Messiah is the Mahdi. To validate this contention they quote the hadith
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[There is no Mahdi except ‘Isa].