Haqiqatul-Wahi
Haqiqatul-Wahi (The Philosophy of Divine Revelation), Part 15
Can there be any confidence in such a weak ‘God’? Does God suffer death like a mortal human? Besides, the Jews made filthy accusations against him and even his mother, but that ‘God’ was unable to exonerate himself by displaying mighty powers. Therefore, reason cannot propose to accept such a ‘God’ who himself died in distress and could do no harm
futed by his passionate supplications in the garden that the cup [of death] be passed from him; and his lamentation when he was put on the cross: Eli Eli lama sabachtani, meaning: my God, my God, why have you forsaken me? If he was indeed content with that death on the cross why did he make supplications? And this notion that death of the Messiah on the cross was the mercy of God on mankind and God was pleased to do this so that the world could find salvation through the blood of the Messiah, is rejected by the argument that if divine mercy was truly excited on that day then why was there a terrible earthquake which caused the veil of the Temple to be torn, and why was there such a severe sandstorm and the sun became dark? All this, indeed, shows that God was greatly displeased with the crucifixion of the Messiah and this is why He chased the Jews for forty years and they suffered various calamities. First they died of a severe plague and at the end thousands of Jews were killed at the hands of Titus, the Roman. (Author)
Chapter IV 75 to the Jews. There cannot be anything more absurd than to suggest that he willingly accepted death on the cross in order to redeem the sins of his people. The man who spent the entire night in tearful supplication in a garden to save his life—which was not even heard—and then he was so overwhelmed by panic that he cried out Eli Eli lama sabachtani at the time of the crucifixion. He addressed his God as God and forgot to call him ‘Father’ in that extreme anguish. Now, considering all this, can anyone believe that he died by his own volition?
Who can understand the contradictions in Christian theology? On the one hand, they believe Yasu‘ to be God, while on the other, the same ‘God’ is seen praying and crying before another God. Whereas all three ‘Gods’ were inside Yasu‘ and he was the embodiment of them all, to whom did he tearfully supplicate? It appears from all this that there is another mighty God for Christians besides the Godheads of the Trinity, who is distinct from them and rules over them, before whom the three were obliged to supplicate. Furthermore, the purpose for which the ‘suicide’ was committed still remains unfulfilled.
His death was meant to free his followers from sin, worldliness, and
Muslim sects adopted the belief that Hadrat ‘Isa (peace be on him) escaped crucifixion and ascended to Heaven where he physically resides to this day, and he has not been afflicted with death. Such ignorant Muslims have greatly helped the cause of Christianity. They claim that there is no mention of the death of ‘Isa anywhere in the Holy Qur’an, when in truth it does mention it explicitly on several occasions. The verse
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘But since You did cause me to die’, (Surah al-Ma’idah, 5:118)] for example, is categorical about his demise. They claim that the verse
[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]
[‘They slew him not, nor crucified him’, (Surah an-Nisa’, 4:158)] signifies that Hadrat ‘Isa is still alive. Their reasoning for this is truly lamentable! Does a person who is not crucified never die? I have said again and again that the Holy Qur’an negates ‘Isa’s death by crucifixion and proclaims his ascension, not because God wants to prove that ‘Isa is still alive, but to dispel the notion of his accursed death and to confirm that he was spiritually exalted like all believers. It was primarily meant to refute the Jews who did not believe in his (spiritual) ascension. (Author)
worldly enticements, but the result has been quite the opposite. Before his ‘suicide,’ the followers of Yasu‘ sought godliness to some extent, but the more the doctrine of vicarious sacrifice and atonement was emphasized, the more the Christians became steeped in worldliness, worldly enticements, desire of the world, alcoholism, gambling, licentiousness, and illicit relations. The negative effects of this doctrine have been like the sudden collapse of the dam that had been built on a violent and stormy river with resultant destruction of all surrounding land and habitats.
Remember too that abstinence from sin alone is not an accomplishment of any kind for man as thousands of worms, insects, animals and birds refrain from committing any sin, yet they are not considered to have attained communion with God. The question, therefore, is: ‘How did the Messiah’s expiation serve to enhance human spirituality?’ Man is in need of two things in order to reach God: First, abstinence from evil; and second, the attainment of good deeds. Merely eschewing evil is no great feat. Thus, the crux of the matter is that these two forces have remained present in human beings ever since their creation: On the one hand carnal passions lure them towards sin, while on the other hand the fire of the love of God that is hidden in their nature incinerates the straws of sin much like physical fire incinerates the physical straws and dried leaves. But ignition of this spiritual fire that incinerates sins depends entirely on the cognition of God, because love and adornment for anything depends on acquiring its complete recognition. You cannot love something whose beauty and excellence you are unaware of. The knowledge of the beauty and excellence of the God of Honour and Glory ignites the fire of love for Him, which, in turn, consumes sin. It has always been the practice of Allah to grant such knowledge to mankind through His Prophets. Others get light from their light and acquire all the bounties that are bestowed on the Prophets by following them
Sadly, Christianity has the door of cognizance of God closed to its followers for it considers communion with God forever sealed and heavenly Signs to have come to an end. How then is one to acquire a fresh understanding? One is left to ruminate past accounts. Surely, a faith whose ‘God’ is weak and helpless, and which is entirely dependent on fables and myths, is of no value to any intelligent person.
In the same way the Hindu faith, one branch of which is the Aryah sect, falls far short of the truth. According to them, every particle of this universe is primordial and without any Creator. Thus, the Hindus do not believe in the God without whom nothing came into existence and without whose support nothing can continue to exist. They also say that their Parmeshwar cannot forgive the sins of anyone. Such a belief implies that His moral condition is worse than of humans, for we are able to forgive those who transgress against us, and we find the strength in us to willingly forgive the one who sincerely admits his fault, shows deep remorse for his action, resolves to bring about a change in his conduct, and repents before us with contrition and humility. In fact, we experience joy in forgiving. How is it then that the Parmeshwar who claims to be God, lacks this noble virtue when those who have sinned are His own creation and their faculties to commit sin are also from Him? And how is it that He is not appeased unless He has punished them for many millions of years for a single sinful act? Is it possible to attain salvation or spiritual excellence under the rule of such a Parmeshwar?
Thus I reflected deeply and found both these religions opposed to righteousness. It is not possible for me to recount in this work all the obstacles in the path of God and the hopelessness that is encountered in these religions. In brief, these two religions offer no guidance to that God who is sought by pure souls and by finding whom man can achieve salvation in this very life and the gates of divine light can be opened for him and perfect love can be generated through His perfect recognition. Instead, they lead to the pit of ruin. There are other religions in the world similar to them, but they all fail to lead to the One God, who has no associate. They leave the seeker in darkness.
These are all the religions in the study of which I spent a great portion of my life. I reflected over their principles with utmost honesty and diligence, but I found them all distant and estranged from the truth. Indeed this blessed religion, the name of which is Islam, is the only religion that leads to God Almighty and is the only religion which fulfils all the holy demands of human nature.
It is obvious that human nature expects perfection in everything and, since man has been created for the eternal worship of God, he cannot be content with some absurd fables concerning God, when his salvation lies in the recognition of that God. He does not wish to dwell in ignorance, but wants comprehensive knowledge of the perfect attributes of God as if to behold Him. This desire of man can be fulfilled only by Islam. Though in case of some, this desire is buried under carnal passions. Being veiled so strongly, those who crave worldly pleasures and are infatuated with the world, being utterly veiled, do not care for God nor seek His communion, because they worship the idol of materialism. But there is no doubt that one who frees himself of the idol of materialism and desires eternal and true bliss, cannot be satisfied by a religion that only has fables nor can he get any satisfaction from it. It is only through Islam that such a person can find his satisfaction. The God of Islam does not shut the door of His grace upon anyone. He is inviting everyone with open arms to come to Him. And the door is opened for those who eagerly run towards Him with all their strength.