Haqiqatul-Wahi
Haqiqatul-Wahi (The Philosophy of Divine Revelation), Part 31
It was far from the realm of possibility that he would have thought that he would ever escape death by the plague, for on 7 April 1907, the day he died, and even before, such a raging and deadly plague was rampant in Lahore that on certain days as many as 200 persons died of it. One of his relatives had died the day before his death, by attending the burial of whom he had contracted the plague. Hence, in the midst of this deadly epidemic who can say that he would survive? Indeed, thousands of people would hasten, upon contracting the plague, to immediately have their wills recorded in favour of their survivors. In short, all his pretensions to being Musa were thrown into the sea the moment he contracted the plague. Remembering the thousands of dying people and in particular thinking of the death of Ya‘qub, he too must have understood that he would surely die. Under such circumstances, how could he cling on to the perception that he was Musa? Thus, it is indeed the mercy of God that he did not carry with him his false beliefs to the next world. God grabbed him, as it were, by his throat and forced him to recant [his claim] to let him join those about whom God says:
Now, first, I shall prove that all the revelations that he had recorded in his book ‘Asa-e-Musa have been proven to be false. Then I will demonstrate that he died in accordance with my prophecy and that his death is a Sign in support of my truth; nay rather, it sets the seal upon my truth. I will divide this statement into two chapters.
through Mubahalah
207. Sign Number Two Hundred and Seven—Reproduced below is the mubahalah which Munshi Mahtab ‘Ali, a member of our Jama‘at, had on 12 June 1906 with Faidullah Khan, son of Zafar-ud- Din Ahmad, a former professor of Oriental College, Lahore. The result of this was that Faidullah Khan, in accordance with his own wish, suffered from an attack of the plague and not only died himself on 13 April 1907 CE, Besakh 1, 1963—Vikram Calendar—but also became the cause of death for some of his relatives.
In addition, it would be relevant to mention here that the father of the aforementioned Faidullah Khan, Qadi Zafar-ud-Din, was also a bitter enemy of this Jama‘at. And when he started writing an Arabic poem against my Jama‘at, he had not yet finished it and its manuscript was still with him but had not yet been published, when he died.
Below are the reproduced texts of the mubahalah from each side. The signed statements of both sides are in my possession.
The Signed Statement of Faidullah Khan
[In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. We praise Him and invoke His blessings upon His Noble Messenger. All praise be to Allah with whose name nothing can harm, either in the earth or in the heaven. He is All-Hearing and All-Knowing.]
After praising God and invoking blessings upon the Holy Prophet of the Lord of all the worlds, I, Qadi Faidullah Khan, son of the late Qadi Zafar-ud-Din Ahmad, hereby declare that I am a Hanafi Muslim fully abiding by the tradition of the Holy Prophet (sa). I believe that after the demise of the Holy Prophet Muhammad, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, who is Khatamun-Nabiyyin [the Seal of the Prophets], the descent of wahi [divine revelation] is against the teachings of the Holy Qur’an and the Sunnah.
I reject Mirza Sahib’s claim that he is the like of, and the Promised Messiah. And Munshi Mahtab Ali son of Munshi Karim Bakhsh, a resident of Jalandhar city and a follower of the above-mentioned Mirza Sahib, claims that whoever denies this claim of his shall be overtaken by the chastisement of God.
Therefore, I pray that whoever is the liar of us two may be overtaken by a divine chastisement such as death, a disease like the plague, or incarceration resulting from some legal case. In accordance with the example of the Holy Prophet (sa), I fix one year as the time frame for this mubahalah. I prescribe the further condition that if divine chastisement overtakes any relative other than me or Munshi Mahtab, it would not be deemed to fall under this agreement.
[Our last prayer is that all praise be to Allah, the Lord of all the worlds. May Allah the Almighty, send His blessings upon the Best of His creatures, Muhammad, and upon his progeny and upon all of his Companions. We beg you for Your Mercy, O the Most Merciful One.]
Qadi Faidullah Khan Resident of Jandiala Baghwala, District Gujranwala Dated 12 June 1906
Signed Statement of Munshi Mahtab ‘Ali
[In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. We praise Him and invoke His blessings (upon His Noble Messenger.)]
I believe that His Holiness, Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, is the true Messiah, and I believe, without any doubt or misgiving, that all his claims concerning religion are true. On the contrary, in opposition to me, Qadi Faidullah, the son of the late Qadi Zafar-ud-Din, declares with conviction that Mirza Sahib is an impostor and his claim is entirely self-manufactured and self-fabricated. Therefore, I challenge Qadi Sahib to a mubahalah, and I have full and perfect conviction that whichever one of us is a liar will suffer an agonizing torment from God.
The heavens and the earth might change their course, but this chastisement will certainly not be averted and will certainly manifest its flash. For, this is the eternal law of God Almighty, and it is the final and the best method to distinguish truth from falsehood. Therefore, I pray to God that He may show an early conclusion to this mubahalah. O God! O God! Nothing is impossible for You. If You so will, You can send down chastisement in an instant. But, in keeping with the tradition of the Holy Prophet (sa) I propose a time frame of one year. The punishment should come down either upon me or Qadi Sahib. For instance, death or plague or incarceration in some lawsuit. This is the sole condition. The coming down of punishment upon some next of kin or a relative shall not form a part of the condition. The chastisement shall target no one other than us.
Yours humbly Mahtab ‘Ali Sayyah of Jalandhar Dated 12 June 1906
As has already been pointed out, after these statements were signed, the result was that Qadi Faidullah Khan, in keeping with the prayer that had been done for the liar, died of the plague in Jammu within a year and in accordance with the prescribed conditions. God saved