Al-Istifta’

Haqiqatul-Wahi (The Philosophy of Divine Revelation), Part 14

I am supported by the testimony and Signs from my Lord to which you are witnesses. Do you persist in denial? There is no blame on those who passed away before me, and they are not answerable for what they did. However, those whom my claim has reached, who have seen my Signs, who recognized me, and to whom I introduced myself, and against whom my argument has been fully established, but they nevertheless rejected the Signs of Allah and oppressed me—they are a people who have become deserving of Allah’s punishment, as they do not fear Allah and mock at Allah’s Signs and His Prophets. I did not come to them without manifest Signs. My Lord showed them Sign after Sign and miracle after miracle. The argument has been established and all disputes and disagreements have been settled, yet they persist in denial. Do they fight Allah because He made me the Promised Messiah and the Prophesied Mahdi? To Him alone belongs the command and the decision. He cannot be questioned for what He does, but they will be held accountable for what they do. Some of them withdrew from this dispute out of shame and fear and returned to me repentant, but most of them remain astray.

Do they insist that ‘Isa is alive and conceal the consensus agreed upon by all the Companions and go against the people who were blessed with the company of the Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, whereas every one of them benefited from, and was taught by, the Holy Prophet? They formed a consensus on the death of ‘Isa, and this was the first consensus reached by them after the [demise of the] Messenger of Allah. The learned scholars are well aware of this.

Have you forgotten the Word of Allah:

Or do you opt knowingly for disbelief ? Every single one of the Companions died while they adhered to this consensus. Later, you became sects and the winds of dissension started blowing among you. You have been deprived of any authoritative argument for his [‘Isa’s] life. You follow nothing but conjectures. Allah quotes ‘Isa as saying pay heed to them.

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

Or do you say that which you do not know?

Know also that the term that is coined to convey a particular meaning deserves to be applied to everyone equally in its assigned sense without any distinction or exception. But you particularize ‘Isa for the meaning that you have devised for the word tawaffi [to ascend bodily] and say that no one else in all the worlds shares that meaning, as if this particular meaning came into existence only when ‘Isa was born and it had no existence before him, nor will it exist again [after him] until the end of times.

O brave and young person! Assume that ‘Isa was not born and was not granted a physical body by God Almighty. In that case, the word tawaffi would have been left like a woman deprived of her ornaments. So ponder without showing me your canine teeth. Fear Allah, the Oft-Returning with compassion. Do you think that this meaning [for the word tawaffi] is a carpet that only Ibn Maryam [the son of Mary] walked upon, or a tablecloth that no one has betaken except this honourable king [‘Isa]?

Moreover, even if we accept that in the phrase

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

the word tawaffi signifies physical ascension to the heavens, despite the supposition of this meaning, the verse would reject the idea of ‘Isa ever returning to the earth and the purpose of my enemies cannot be achieved; rather, the matter of not descending remains intact. This is not hidden from the wise, because ‘Isa will utter these words on the Day of Judgment. In other words, he will say

[Arabic text in the original, see the original page]

on the day when all creation will be resurrected and presented [before their Lord]. O wise ones! This is what you read in the Holy Qur’an. ‘Isa’s reply, to put it in a nutshell, is that he would state to God that: ‘I left my people established upon the Oneness of God and belief in Allah, the One Jealous of

His Honour. Since then, I never saw them again up to the Last Day, nor did I ever visit the earth again until the Day of Resurrection. Therefore, I do not know what they did after me with regard to polytheism and evil deeds, and I am not to be blamed.’

If his return to the Earth before the Day of Judgment were a reality, then it would imply that he would resort to a despicable lie when questioned by the Lord of Honour about his people. This is evidently false. Hence, the belief in his descent is also false without any doubt and ambiguity.

Therefore—O brave young people!—wake up! How far have you drifted from the teachings of the Holy Qur’an! Actually ‘Isa died just as his fellow Prophets and joined them in Heaven, as you read in the ahadith of the Best of the Prophets (sa). Have you ever read in the Hadith of the Leader of the World (sa) that ‘Isa is resting in a chamber separate from other dead people? Indeed, not. The fact is that he is dead and will never return to the Earth up to the Day of Resurrection. Anyone who deliberately states something contrary to this is from among those who deny the Holy Qur’an. As for those who have passed away before me, they are not answerable to God for the error they made.

The Holy Qur’an testifies that on the Day of Judgment Jesus will deny any knowledge of the apostasy of his people and of their abandoning the Lord of the entire creation and making him into God. He will thus absolve himself of any knowledge of the disorder in Christianity and their falling into error.

If he were destined to descend before the Day of Judgment, then he would have said so truthfully before God Almighty, as was befitting his lofty station. This is what the righteous do. Indeed, truth is from among the cloaks of the Prophets and Imams. How then can it be imagined that he would resort to falsehood and be guilty of hiding the testimony by saying, ‘O my Lord! I never returned to the earth, neither do I have any knowledge of what happened to my people, nor do I know how they acted after I had left them.’ This would be a despicable lie that makes the body tremble and shake violently.

If we assume that such would, indeed, be the answer of Jesus, and he would, when enquired by Allah the Glorious, hide intentionally the fact of his return to the Earth and, despite being aware of his followers’ apostasy and falling away from the right path, will try to conceal it, then no doubt God would say to him, ‘O ‘Isa! What is wrong with you that you do not fear My honour and glory and lie to My face in answer to My questions? Did you not return to the Earth upon your descent, and become aware that your followers indulged in shirk [associating partners with Allah]? Did you not see those who made you into God and then spread to every part of the world and, like a galloping horse, they came down from every high place. You actually fought against them and broke their Cross with your power and effort. But you now deny that you returned to the Earth? Indeed, I am amazed at your falsehood and imposture.’

·

10 of 10 left today