Al-Istifta’
Haqiqatul-Wahi (The Philosophy of Divine Revelation), Part 21
There is no doubt that the impostors are eventually seized and precluded from prospering. The wrath of Allah tears them apart like a ferocious lion and confronts them with the day of ultimate ruin and destruction promised in the Book of the Almighty and Most-Loving God. Verily, those who fabricate lies against God and are guilty of falsehood live not but for a short period of time, after which they are seized. The curse of Allah pursues them in this world and in the Hereafter. They taste disgrace and dishonour and are not granted respect. Has the news not reached you of what became of the impostors of the earlier ages? Verily, God does not care for the end of those who fabricate lies against Him. He draws His sword against them and cuts them into pieces.
When the day of his destruction came near, I invited him to a mubahalah and wrote to him that: Your claim is false and you are naught but a lying fabricator, merely feeding on the carrion of the condemnable world. ‘Isa was nothing more than a Prophet and you are simply an impostor.
You are a man with no extraordinary merit from among those who are in error and you mislead others into error; therefore, fear Him who sees your imposture. I invite you to Islam, the True Faith, and to turn to Allah, the Possessor of Power and Honour, for repentance. If you decline to accept my invitation and move away from it, then let us engage in a mubahalah and invoke the curse of Allah upon the one who has forsaken truth and claims to be a Messenger and Prophet by way of imposture. Verily, Allah will decide between you and me and will destroy the liar during the lifetime of the truthful so that people should know who [between the two of us] is the truthful and who is the liar, and so that, after this judgment, the dispute is settled once and for all.
I swear by God that truly I am the Promised Messiah whose advent was prophesied to occur in the Latter Days and the time of the spread of misguidance. Surely, ‘Isa has died and the doctrine of the Trinity is false. By claiming to be a Prophet, you are guilty of imposture against Allah; for prophethood came to an end after our Holy Prophet, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and there is no Book after al-Furqan [the Discrimination; i.e. the Holy Qur’an] which is superior to all earlier Scriptures, neither is there any new shariah after the Muhammadan Shariah.
However, the Best of Mankind declared me to be a Prophet, and this is a matter of being his reflection due to the blessings of complete submission. And I find no excellence within me; all that I have obtained is through his holy soul. By calling me a Prophet, Allah means only [that I receive] abundant revelations and converse [with God]. May the curse of Allah be upon the one who aspires to anything beyond that, or considers his own person as something special, or frees his neck from the yoke [i.e. complete submission] of the prophethood [of the Holy Prophet (sa) ].
Surely, our Messenger is Khatamun-Nabiyyin [the Seal of the Prophets] and the chain of Messengers has ended with him. Therefore, no one has the right to claim prophethood after our Messenger, the Chosen One, in an independent manner, and nothing has remained after him except dialogue [with Allah] in abundance. Even this is conditional upon following [the Holy Prophet (sa) ] and is not granted unless one is a true follower of the Best of Creation. I swear by God that I have been blessed with this spiritual station only by following the radiant rays of the light of the Chosen Prophet (sa) .
I have been granted the name ‘Prophet’ by Allah, not in its original sense [of being raised independently], but as a subordinate Prophet. This does not in the least undermine the honour and dignity of God Almighty or of His Messenger (sa) , for I am being raised under the blessed wings of the Holy Prophet. I walk in the footsteps of the Holy Prophet. What is more, I never said anything on my own; I have only followed the revelation which my Lord granted to me, and thereafter, I fear not the threats of the people against me. On the Day of Judgment, everyone will be held accountable for what they did. Certainly, there is nothing that is hidden from Allah.
I had told the impostor [Dowie] that:
If you do not come forward for the muba‑ halah after my invitation, and also do not repent of your claim of prophethood that you have made by way of sheer fabrication against Allah, then you should not imagine
that this strategy would spare you; rather,
Allah would destroy you by inflicting utter humiliation and a harsh punishment. He will disgrace you and make you taste the punishment of your imposture.
Hence, he waited for my death and I for his. I put my trust in Allah, the Helper of the truth and Supporter of this religion [of Islam].
Having done this, I fully and completely published all over the United States my statement that I had sent to Dowie, so much so that they were published in most of the newspapers of the United States. I believe that thousands of newspapers published my message and its publication reached such a great number that I am unable to count it, and the papers [at my disposal] do not hold the capacity for me to provide details. As for the American newspapers that were sent to me and which mentioned my point of view, my invitation to Dowie for a mubahalah, and my prayer against him in which I sought judgment, I consider it appropriate to mention the names of some of those newspapers in the footnote so that the people might come to know that there was nothing hidden or secret about the mubahalah; rather, it was a matter well advertised all over the world—in the east and in the west, in the north and in the south.
The reason for such [large-scale] advertisement was that Dowie was like the great kings in renown. In America and Europe there was not even a single person in the upper and lower classes of society who did not know him well. In fact, the people in those countries held him in great honour and revered him as a king. Moreover, he travelled extensively and used mesmerizing speeches to lure people into his trap, like a hunter traps his prey. This is why no newspaper editor ever refused to publish the material sent to them regarding the
mubahalah. Instead, they were eager to publish it out of a strong curiosity to see the end of this contest. There are a large number of American newspapers that published the news of my invitation to Dowie for a mubahalah and my prayer against him.